| Matter of Carabello v DiNapoli |
| 2008 NY Slip Op 04815 [51 AD3d 1361] |
| May 29, 2008 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Bernard Carabello, Petitioner, v Thomas P.DiNapoli, as Comptroller of the State of New York, et al.,Respondents. |
—[*1] Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, Albany (William E. Storrs of counsel), forrespondents.
Malone Jr., J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by order ofthe Supreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review a determination of respondentComptroller which, among other things, denied petitioner's application for reinstatement to tier 1membership in respondent New York State and Local Employees' Retirement System.
In August 2003, petitioner filed an application for reinstatement to tier 1 membership inrespondent New York State and Local Employees' Retirement System based upon his claim that,while a resident of the former Willowbrook State School in Richmond County, he was compelledto provide uncompensated services for which he was entitled to both service credit andplacement in tier 1. This initial application was denied, prompting counsel for petitioner toreiterate the request in October 2004. When petitioner again was denied relief, he sought andreceived a hearing, at the conclusion of which the Hearing Officer denied petitioner's applicationconcluding that petitioner was not eligible for the requested service credit because he was notpaid a salary for the services he performed at Willowbrook. The Hearing Officer also deniedpetitioner's application for reinstatement to tier 1, finding that petitioner did not meet thestatutory requirements for tier 1 reinstatement. Respondent Comptroller thereafter adopted the[*2]Hearing Officer's decision and denied petitioner's applicationfor service credit and tier 1 reinstatement. Petitioner then commenced this proceeding pursuant toCPLR article 78, subsequently transferred to this Court, to annul the Comptroller's determination.
We confirm. "Retirement and Social Security Law § 645 grants tier reinstatement onlywhen a petitioner was a mandatory member of the Retirement System at the time of the priorservice or actually joined the Retirement System at that time" (Matter of Hession v New York State &Local Employees' Retirement Sys., 24 AD3d 1008, 1009 [2005]; see Matter of Walroth v New York State &Local Employees' Retirement Sys., 14 AD3d 918, 919 [2005]; Matter of Scott vMcCall, 302 AD2d 675, 676 [2003]). Here, the Retirement System's director of member andemployer services testified that petitioner was not a member of the Retirement System during hisyears at Willowbrook and, absent payroll records and information regarding a potential job titleor civil service classification, she could not determine whether the services performed bypetitioner would have resulted in mandatory membership in the Retirement System. Under suchcircumstances, the Comptroller properly denied petitioner's application seeking reinstatement totier 1.
We reach a similar conclusion regarding petitioner's request for service credit. Preliminarily,the Comptroller is vested with exclusive authority to determine retirement service credit, and hisdetermination in this regard, if supported by substantial evidence in the record as a whole, will beupheld (see Matter of DeLuca v NewYork State & Local Employees' Retirement Sys., 48 AD3d 876, 877 [2008]; Matter of Siepierski v New York State &Local Retirement Sys., 46 AD3d 1316, 1317 [2007]). Although there is no dispute thatWillowbrook was a "participating employer" (Retirement and Social Security Law § 2 [8],[20]), where, as here, a member seeks credit for "[g]overnment service" (Retirement and SocialSecurity Law § 2 [11], [17]), such service must be "[p]aid service" within the meaning ofRetirement and Social Security Law § 2 (11) (see Matter of Siepierski v New YorkState & Local Retirement Sys., 46 AD3d at 1317; Matter of Catena v New York StateEmployees' Retirement Sys., 91 AD2d 1138, 1139 [1983]). Here, petitioner readily admitsthat he was not "employed" by Willowbrook, nor was he ever paid a salary for the work heperformed or the services he provided while there. Rather, petitioner was "compensated" withnonmonetary privileges such as food and cigarettes. Accordingly, the Comptroller appropriatelyconcluded that petitioner was not entitled to the requested service credit.
Mercure, J.P., Spain, Lahtinen and Kane, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.