Matter of Suffolk County Community Coll. v New York State Div. ofHuman Rights
2009 NY Slip Op 03184 [61 AD3d 881]
April 21, 2009
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, June 10, 2009


In the Matter of Suffolk County Community College et al.,Respondents,
v
New York State Division of Human Rights, Respondent and CrossPetitioner. Bruce Simmons, Respondent on the Cross Petition.

—[*1]Christine Malafi, County Attorney, Hauppauge, N.Y. (Jennifer K. McNamara and KellyGreen of counsel), for petitioners-respondents.

Caroline J. Downey, Bronx, N.Y. (Arylne R. Zwyer of counsel), for respondent/crosspetitioner.

Proceeding pursuant to Executive Law § 298 to review a determination of theCommissioner of the New York State Division of Human Rights dated February 7, 2008, whichadopted the recommendation of an Administrative Law Judge dated January 15, 2008, madeafter a hearing, inter alia, finding that the petitioner Suffolk County Community College engagedin unlawful racially discriminatory practices against one of its employees and retaliated againsthim, and awarding him compensatory damages in the sum of $50,000, and the New York StateDivision of Human Rights cross-petitions pursuant to Executive Law § 298 to enforce thedetermination.

Adjudged that the petition is dismissed, without costs or disbursements; and it is further,

Adjudged that the cross petition is denied, without costs or disbursements, the determinationis annulled, and the administrative complaint is dismissed.

As we explained in Matter ofMassapequa Auto Salvage, Inc. v Donaldson (40 AD3d 647, [*2]648 [2007]), "22 NYCRR 202.57, entitled 'Judicial Review ofOrders of the State Division of Human Rights; procedure,' provides as follows: '(a) Anycomplainant, respondent or other person aggrieved by any order of the State Commissioner ofHuman Rights or the State Division of Human Rights may obtain judicial review of such orderby commencing a special proceeding, within 60 days after service of the order, in the SupremeCourt in the county where the alleged discriminatory practice which is the subject of the orderoccurred or where any person required by the order to cease and desist from an unlawfuldiscriminatory practice or to take other affirmative action resides or transacts business. Suchproceeding shall be commenced by the filing of a notice of petition and petition naming asrespondents the State Division of Human Rights and all other parties appearing in the proceedingbefore the State Division of Human Rights.' The complainant . . . who filed therelevant administrative complaint with the New York State Division of Human Rights(hereinafter the SDHR), based on alleged violation of [his] rights under the Human Rights Law,appeared as a party in the administrative proceeding before the SDHR, but was not named as aparty [by the petitioner] in the instant proceeding, as required by the above rule." Under thisCourt rule, the failure to name the complainant in the petition requires dismissal of the petition(id.; cf. Windy Ridge Farm vAssessor of Town of Shandaken, 11 NY3d 725 [2008]).

Nonetheless, the SDHR named the complainant as a respondent in its cross petition toenforce the determination of the Commissioner of the SDHR (hereinafter the Commissioner),and served the complainant with the notice of cross petition and the cross petition. Sinceenforcement of such a determination is only warranted where it is supported by substantialevidence in the record (see Matter of Massapequa Auto Salvage, Inc. v Donaldson, 40AD3d at 649; Matter of State Div. ofHuman Rights v Stoute, 36 AD3d 257 [2006]), we reach the substantial evidencequestion on our consideration of the cross petition.

The Commissioner's determination was not supported by substantial evidence. First, thecomplainant admitted that the majority of incidents of which he complained were related to theuse of profanity and poor hygiene practices by his coworkers, and not motivated by racialanimus (see Matter of 80 LafayetteAssoc. v Gibson, 59 AD3d 231 [2009]; Matter of Pageau v Tolbert, 304 AD2d1067, 1068 [2003]; see generally Matter of Lahey v Kelly, 71 NY2d 135, 141 [1987]).

Moreover, the proof adduced at the hearing did not show that the complainant was subjectedto a hostile work environment in which his workplace was so permeated with discriminatoryintimidation, ridicule, and insult as to alter the condition of his employment and create anabusive work environment. To recover under the Executive Law against an employer for thediscriminatory practices of its employees, it must be shown that the employer became a party tosuch practices by encouraging, condoning, or approving them. This matter involved fewer than20 incidents spread over a period of four years. The employer, Suffolk County CommunityCollege (hereinafter the College), investigated all of the incidents brought to its attention by thecomplainant and addressed them accordingly. The College also adduced evidence at the hearingthat it contacted the local police department to investigate an incident that was potentiallymotivated by racial animus, and that an outside agency was requested to and did conduct aninvestigation of any systemic problems in the department in which the employee worked.Neither the police department nor the outside investigating agency found any evidence ofracially discriminatory practices at the College (see Forrest v Jewish Guild for the Blind, 3 NY3d 295, 310-311[2004]; Morse v Cowtan & Tout, Inc.,41 AD3d 563 [2007]; Thompson v Lamprecht Transp., 39 AD3d 846, 847 [2007]; Beharry v Guzman, 33 AD3d 742,743 [2006]).[*3]

Accordingly, the cross petition must be denied, thedetermination annulled, and the administrative complaint dismissed.

In light of our determination, we need not reach the remaining contentions of the College orSuffolk County Department of Civil Service. Santucci, J.P., Florio, Covello and Dickerson, JJ.,concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.