Matter of Landry v Mansion
2009 NY Slip Op 06279 [65 AD3d 803]
August 20, 2009
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, September 30, 2009


In the Matter of Joe Landry, Respondent, v Michael P. Mansion etal., Appellants, et al., Respondents.

—[*1]James E. Walsh, Schenectady, for appellants.

Law Office of Daniel W. Coffey, Albany (Mark W. Blanchfield of counsel), forrespondent.

Per Curiam. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Reilly Jr., J.), entered August 11,2009 in Schenectady County, which granted petitioner's application, in a proceeding pursuant toElection Law § 16-102, to declare invalid the certificate of substitution naming respondentDonald R. Cromer as the Republican Party candidate for the office of Town Supervisor of theTown of Niskayuna in the September 15, 2009 primary election.

A designating petition naming respondent Jeffrey S. Frankel as the Republican Partycandidate for Niskayuna Town Supervisor in the September 15, 2009 primary election wastimely filed with respondent Schenectady County Board of Elections. Later that day, Frankelfiled a certificate of declination with respect to this designation. Pursuant to the designatingpetition, the Committee to Fill Vacancies, consisting of respondents Michael P. Mansion, RobinM. Jost and David H. Kim, was authorized to name a replacement candidate in the event ofFrankel's declination. Thereafter, a certificate of substitution purporting to designate respondentDonald R. Cromer as the replacement candidate was filed, signed by Mansion and Jost.

Petitioner, the designated candidate for Niskayuna Town Supervisor of the Democratic,Independence, Conservative and Working Families Parties, commenced this proceeding, as anaggrieved candidate, seeking to have the certificate of substitution invalidated on the ground that[*2]it was not properly executed by the Committee to FillVacancies pursuant to Election Law § 6-148. Cromer, Mansion and Jost (hereinaftercollectively referred to as respondents) answered and moved to dismiss the petition for, amongother things, failure to state a cause of action. Supreme Court denied respondents' motion andsubsequently determined that the certificate of substitution was invalid and granted the petition to invalidate. Respondents now appeal.

Initially, we conclude that Supreme Court properly denied respondents' motion to dismissthe petition for failure to state a cause of action. A review of the petition reveals that petitioneralleged facts indicating that respondents failed to comply with the statutory requirements ofElection Law § 6-148 when filing the certificate of substitution which, if true, providelegal grounds for the invalidation of the certificate (see Matter of Breslin v Conners, 10AD3d 471, 473 [2004], lv denied 3 NY3d 603 [2004]).

Turning to the merits, respondents contend that Supreme Court erred in invalidating thecertificate of substitution, claiming that the Board of Elections gave them misinformationconcerning the filing of the certificate and supplied them with the incorrect form, or,alternatively, that the certificate, as filed, substantially complied with the statutory requirements.As relevant here, "[a] vacancy in a designation or independent nomination, or in a partynomination made otherwise than at a primary, may be filled by a majority of the committee to fillvacancies shown upon the face of the petition or certification of the designation or nomination inwhich the vacancy occurs" (Election Law § 6-148 [2]). In such situations, "the newcertificate shall be signed by a majority of such committee" and "[a]ppended to the certificateshall be the affidavit of the persons signing the certificate that they were a majority of suchcommittee . . . and that the statements in such certificate are true" (Election Law§ 6-148 [4]).

The certificate of substitution filed here, however, erroneously affirmed that the replacementcandidate was chosen by a quorum at a meeting of the Republican Party committee members,instead of by a majority of the Committee to Fill Vacancies. While the certificate was signed byrespondents, who comprise a majority of the Committee to Fill Vacancies, the signatures wereentered in their respective capacities as the Presiding Officer and Secretary of the NiskayunaRepublican Party. Moreover, the affidavit included with the certificate affirmed, erroneously,that both signatories were present at a party committee meeting which chose the replacementcandidate and did not reference their membership in the Committee to Fill Vacancies or affirmthat a majority of said committee had chosen the replacement candidate.

"While substantial compliance is acceptable as to details of form, there must be strictcompliance with statutory commands as to matters of prescribed content" (Matter of Hutsonv Bass, 54 NY2d 772, 774 [1981] [citation omitted]; see Matter of Justice v Gamache, 45 AD3d 508, 511 [2007];Matter of Flach v De Benedictus, 265 AD2d 670, 671 [1999], lv denied 94NY2d 752 [1999]). As the Committee to Fill Vacancies was statutorily required to file acertification of substitution signed by a majority of the Committee, stating that the replacementcandidate was chosen by that majority, we cannot conclude that the certificate actually filed here,which satisfied none of these requirements, strictly complied with the statutory regulations.Furthermore, reliance on the Board of Elections in providing forms and information does notrelieve respondents from their duty to comply with statutory mandates (see Matter of Smith vMahoney, 60 NY2d 596, 597 [1983]; Matter of Cola v D'Apice, 112 AD2d 1060,1060-1061 [1985]). Accordingly, the petition to invalidate the certificate of substitution wasproperly granted.[*3]

Respondents also request, for the first time on appeal,that this Court direct the Board of Elections to provide the Republican Party an opportunity toballot at the upcoming primary election. Courts have the authority, as justice requires, to order anopportunity to ballot, which is "designed to give effect to the intention manifested by qualifiedparty members to nominate some candidate, where that intention would otherwise be thwartedby the presence of technical, but fatal defects in designating petitions, leaving the political partywithout a designated candidate for a given office" (Matter of Harden v Board of Elections inCity of N.Y., 74 NY2d 796, 797 [1989]; see Matter of Hunting v Power, 20 NY2d680, 681 [1967]; Matter of Bowen vUlster County Bd. of Elections, 21 AD3d 693, 694-695 [2005]; Matter of Santoro vKujawa, 133 AD2d 534, 534 [1987], lv denied 70 NY2d 724 [1987]; Matter ofGarrow v Mitchell, 112 AD2d 1104, 1105 [1985], lv denied 65 NY2d 607 [1985]).Here, the designating petitions that manifested the intention of the registered voters in theRepublican Party to nominate some candidate for Niskayuna Town Supervisor were filedwithout objection. Once that candidate declined, the invalidation of the certificate of substitutionof the replacement candidate, which was based upon the technical, but statutorily fatal, flaws inthe content of the certificate of substitution, left the registered voters of the Republican Partywithout a candidate. Under these circumstances, we find that the equitable remedy of affordingthese potentially disenfranchised voters an opportunity to ballot at the September 15, 2009primary election is appropriate (see Matter of Winn v Washington County Bd. ofElections, 196 AD2d 674, 674 [1993], lv denied 82 NY2d 654 [1993]; Matter ofVenezia v Albanese, 153 AD2d 723, 724 [1989], lv denied 74 NY2d 609 [1989]).

Respondents' remaining contentions have been reviewed and found to be without merit.

Cardona, P.J., Kavanagh, Stein, McCarthy and Garry, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order ismodified, on the facts, without costs, by directing that respondent Schenectady County Board ofElections provide registered voters of the Republican Party with an opportunity to ballot for theoffice of Town Supervisor of the Town of Niskayuna at the September 15, 2009 primaryelection, and, as so modified, affirmed.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.