| Matter of Yarleque v Sally Lou, Inc. |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 04072 [73 AD3d 1294] |
| May 13, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of the Claim of Enni Yarleque, Appellant, v SallyLou, Inc., et al., Respondents. Workers' Compensation Board,Respondent. |
—[*1] Gregory J. Allen, State Insurance Fund, Melville (Jeremy B. Davis of counsel), for SallyLou, Inc. and another, respondents.
Rose, J. Appeals from two decisions of the Workers' Compensation Board, filed May 6,2008, which denied claimant's request for reconsideration or full Board review.
Claimant worked for the employer for less than four months in 1996. In June 2000, shesubmitted two applications for workers' compensation benefits allegedly arising out of thatemployment. The employer and its workers' compensation carrier (hereinafter collectivelyreferred to as the carrier) asserted that both claims—one for carpal tunnel syndrome andthe second for back, neck and shoulder injuries—were time-barred pursuant to Workers'Compensation Law § 28. Following hearings, a Workers' Compensation Law Judge ruled,in one decision, that the application premised on claimant's back, neck and shoulder injuries wastimely and established that claim. Without addressing the carrier's statute of limitationsargument, the Workers' Compensation Law Judge likewise established the claim related toclaimant's carpal tunnel syndrome. Upon review, the Workers' Compensation Board reversed.Claimant did not appeal from that decision, but subsequently applied for reconsideration or fullBoard review. In two separate decisions the Board denied claimant's request and these appealsensued.[*2]
Where, as here, a claimant's appeal is limited to theBoard's denial of his or her request for full Board review or reconsideration, our analysis isconfined to whether such denial was an abuse of discretion or arbitrary and capricious (see Matter of D'Errico v New York CityDept. of Corrections, 65 AD3d 795, 796 [2009], appeal dismissed 13 NY3d 899[2009]; Matter of Wariner v AssociatedPress, 12 AD3d 863, 864 [2004]; Matter of Graham v Pathways, Inc., 305AD2d 830, 831 [2003], lv dismissed 1 NY3d 564 [2003]). "In that regard, the groundsfor seeking review or reconsideration are narrow; the movant must generally show that newlydiscovered evidence exists, that there has been a material change in condition, or that the Boardimproperly failed to consider the issues raised in the application for review in making its initialdetermination" (Matter of D'Errico v New York City Dept. of Corrections, 65 AD3d at796 [citations omitted]).
In this case, the Board in its underlying decision concluded that claimant's carpal tunnelsyndrome was an occupational disease for which the latest possible date of disablement wasNovember 1, 1996, when claimant stopped working. Consequently, the Board found thatclaimant's June 2000 application for workers' compensation benefits arising out of that injurywas untimely (see Workers' Compensation Law § 28). As for the claim regardingclaimant's back, neck and shoulder injuries, her admission in the footnote of her brief confirmsthat she knew that those injuries were work-related no later than December 21, 1996. Thisadmission, together with the evidence that claimant stopped working on November 1, 1996because of her injuries and the Board's finding that both claims involved occupational diseases,amply support the conclusion that her applications in June 2000 were beyond the two-yearperiod provided by Workers' Compensation Law § 28 (see Matter of Feliciano v New York City Health & Hosps. Corp., 65AD3d 784, 785 [2009]; Matter of Caiazza v Eastman Kodak Co., 300 AD2d 966,967 [2002]; Matter of Cummings v Tenneco Chems. Div., Am. Plastics, 53 AD2d 944[1976]). Inasmuch as claimant failed to present previously unavailable evidence warrantingreview or reconsideration of either claim, the Board did not abuse its discretion or act arbitrarilyand capriciously in denying her present request (see Matter of Green v Kimber Mfg., Inc., 59 AD3d 782, 783[2009], lv dismissed 12 NY3d 865 [2009]).
Mercure, J.P., Lahtinen, Kavanagh and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the decisions areaffirmed, without costs.