Matter of Natiello v Carrion
2010 NY Slip Op 04397 [73 AD3d 1070]
May 18, 2010
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, June 30, 2010


In the Matter of Carmella Natiello, Appellant,
v
GladysCarrion, Respondent.

—[*1]Annette G. Hasapidis, South Salem, N.Y., for appellant.

Andrew M. Cuomo, Attorney General, New York, N.Y. (Richard Dearing and DavidLawrence III of counsel), for respondent.

In a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review a determination of the State of NewYork Office of Children and Family Services dated December 30, 2008, which, after a hearing,denied the petitioner's application to amend and seal a report maintained in the New York StateCentral Register of Child Abuse and Maltreatment, the petitioner appeals from a judgment of theSupreme Court, Putnam County (O'Rourke, J.), dated July 13, 2009, which denied the petitionand, in effect, dismissed the proceeding.

Ordered that the appeal is dismissed and the judgment is vacated; and it is further,

Adjudged that the petition is granted, on the law, with costs, the determination is annulled,and the matter is remitted to the respondent to amend the incident report to an unfounded reportand to seal the amended report.

Since questions of substantial evidence are involved herein, this proceeding should havebeen transferred to this Court pursuant to CPLR 7804 (g). However, this Court will treat thematter as one initially transferred here and will consider the petition de novo (see Matter of Patterson v State of N.Y. Off.of Children & Family Servs., 34 AD3d 684 [2006]; Matter of Weingarten v Crime Victims Bd., 22 AD3d 763 [2005]).

The determination that the petitioner failed to provide adequate supervision and guardianshipfor her then-13-year-old autistic son, Kevin, was not supported by substantial evidence (see Matter of Richard R. v Carrion, 67AD3d 915 [2009]). Here, the evidence merely established that Kevin sustained minorbruises and scratches when the petitioner left him in the care of his grandmother, who thenallowed him to roughhouse with his younger half brother. We find that, under the peculiarcircumstances of this case, where Kevin had a history of minor self-inflicted injuries regardlessof the level of adult supervision, the proof adduced by the respondent did not constitutesubstantial evidence of neglect (see Social Services Law § 371 [4-a] [i] [B]; Matter of Veronica C. v Carri�n, 55AD3d 411, 412 [2008]).[*2]

The determination that the petitioner educationallyneglected her then-16-year-old son, David, also was not supported by substantial evidence. Theevidence established that David had excessive school absences while he was living with hisfather. Although David's school and the respondent attribute David's excessive absenteeism tothe petitioner, the respondent failed to demonstrate how many of the absences actually wereattributable to the petitioner, given that David resided with his father, or how many of thoseabsences were unexcused. While the respondent demonstrated that the petitioner withdrew Davidfrom school on May 11, 2006, David did not return for the remainder of the school year, and thepetitioner failed to demonstrate that David received the necessary instruction from anotherresource (see Matter of Fatima A., 276 AD2d 791 [2000]; Matter of Aishia O.,284 AD2d 581 [2001]), this evidence did not, by itself, establish the harm or potential harmnecessary for a finding of educational neglect (see Matter of Alexander D., 45 AD3d 264 [2007]; see alsoMatter of Giancarlo P., 306 AD2d 28 [2003]). The record demonstrates that David hademotional problems which caused him to refuse to attend school. At the time that the petitionerwithdrew him from school he was already failing almost all of his courses. Nonetheless, therecord indicates that David completed a four-month GED program during the summer of 2006,and started to attend college at the end of the school year. Accordingly, there was no evidencethat David's education was adversely affected by his absence from school at the end of the2005-2006 school year (see Matter of Alexander D., 45 AD3d at 264). Fisher, J.P.,Dillon, Dickerson and Belen, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.