| Tomaselli v Oneida County Indus. Dev. Agency |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 06865 [77 AD3d 1315] |
| October 1, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
| Chuck Tomaselli, Doing Business as C. Lewis Tomaselli Architects,Respondent, v Oneida County Industrial Development Agency et al., Appellants, et al.,Defendants. |
—[*1] Cohen & Cohen LLP, Utica (Daniel S. Cohen of counsel), for plaintiff-respondent.
Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Oneida County (Anthony F. Shaheen, J.), enteredDecember 9, 2009. The order, inter alia, granted the motion of plaintiff for summary judgment againstdefendants Oneida County Industrial Development Agency and Griffiss Local DevelopmentCorporation.
It is hereby ordered that the order so appealed from is unanimously modified on the law by denyingthe motion and reinstating the answer of defendants Oneida County Industrial Development Agencyand Griffiss Local Development Corporation and as modified the order is affirmed without costs.
Memorandum: Plaintiff commenced this action seeking a money judgment arising from a mechanic'slien filed by him based on money allegedly owed to him in connection with services he performed onproperty owned by Oneida County Industrial Development Agency and Griffiss Local DevelopmentCorporation (collectively, defendant owners). Supreme Court granted plaintiff's motion seekingsummary judgment dismissing the answer of defendant owners and summary judgment granting therelief sought in the complaint against defendant owners. In addition, the court denied the cross motionof defendant owners for summary judgment dismissing the complaint against them. We agree withdefendant owners that the court erred in granting the motion, and we therefore modify the orderaccordingly.
"As the proponent of the motion for summary judgment . . . based upon themechanic's lien, plaintiff had the burden of presenting evidentiary facts showing the existence of a validlien and that there were funds due and owing from [defendant owners] to [plaintiff] to which the liencould attach" (L & W Supply Corp. v A.D.F.Drywall, Inc., 55 AD3d 1026, 1027 [2008]; see Lien Law § 4 [1]). With[*2]respect to the mechanic's lien at issue in this action, plaintiff wasrequired to establish that he provided architectural and engineering services "for the improvement of realproperty with the consent or at the request of the owner[s] thereof, or of [their] agent" (Lien Law§ 3; see Lien Law § 2 [4]). The term "consent" within the meaning of Lien Law§ 3 " 'is not mere acquiescence and benefit, but [it is] some affirmative act or course of conductestablishing confirmation . . . Such consent may be inferred from the . . .conduct of the owner[s]' " (J.K. TobinConstr. Co., Inc. v David J. Hardy Constr. Co., Inc., 64 AD3d 1206, 1208 [2009]; see Elliott-Williams Co., Inc. v ImpromptuGourmet, Inc., 28 AD3d 706 [2006]; GCDM Ironworks v GJF Constr. Corp., 292AD2d 495, 496 [2002]). Therefore, " 'the owner[s] must either be an affirmative factor in procuring theimprovement to be made, or having possession and control of the premises assent to the improvementin the expectation that [they] will reap the benefit of it' " (Elliott-Williams, 28 AD3d at 707,quoting Rice v Culver, 172 NY 60, 65-66 [1902]; see Paul Mock, Inc. v 118 E. 25th St.Realty Co., 87 AD2d 756 [1982]). On the record before us, we conclude that there are triableissues of fact whether defendant owners or other defendants owed any money to plaintiff and, if so, theamount of any such money at the time plaintiff filed his mechanic's lien against the property, thusrequiring denial of both the motion by plaintiff and the cross motion by defendant owners (see Peri Formwork Sys., Inc. v LumbermensMut. Cas. Co., 65 AD3d 533, 535 [2009]; see generally Zuckerman v City of NewYork, 49 NY2d 557, 562 [1980]). Indeed, defendant owners failed to submit evidence in supportof their cross motion establishing as a matter of law that they or their agents did not consent to the workperformed to improve the property that was subject to the mechanic's lien. Present—Smith, J.P.,Fahey, Sconiers, Pine and Gorski, JJ.