Matter of Covert v Schuyler County
2010 NY Slip Op 07861 [78 AD3d 1309]
November 4, 2010
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, January 19, 2011


In the Matter of Beth E. Covert, Petitioner,
v
Schuyler County,Respondent.

—[*1]Levene, Gouldin & Thompson, L.L.P., Binghamton (Margaret J. Fowler of counsel), forpetitioner.

Coughlin & Gerhart, L.L.P., Binghamton (Paul J. Sweeney of counsel), for respondent.

Rose, J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by order of theSupreme Court, entered in Schuyler County) to review a determination of the Schuyler CountyAdministrator which terminated petitioner's employment as a probation officer for respondent.

Following a hearing conducted pursuant to Civil Service Law § 75, petitioner was foundguilty of misconduct for requesting a neighbor to lie to law enforcement officials conducting a criminalinvestigation of petitioner. Because petitioner was suspended from her duties as a probation officer as aresult of the criminal investigation, her supervisor assumed responsibility for her pending probation casefiles and, in the course of handling them, discovered a number of irregularities and deficiencies relatingto petitioner's record keeping and supervision of probationers, which gave rise to additional chargesagainst petitioner. As a result of these additional charges, petitioner was also found guilty ofincompetence. Based on the findings of misconduct and incompetence, together with her priorunsatisfactory service and her failure to take responsibility for her acts and omissions, the SchuylerCounty Administrator terminated petitioner's employment. Petitioner thereafter commenced this CPLRarticle 78 proceeding seeking to annul the determination of the Administrator.

We will not disturb the Administrator's determination made following a hearing [*2]pursuant to Civil Service Law § 75 as long as it is supported bysubstantial evidence providing a rational basis for the findings (see Matter of Wilson v Town of Minerva Town Bd., 65 AD3d 788, 789[2009]; Matter of Clarke v Cleveland,53 AD3d 894, 896 [2008]; Matter of Tottey v Varvayanis, 307 AD2d 652, 655 [2003],lv denied 1 NY3d 501 [2003]). Here, substantial evidence supports the Administrator'sconclusion that petitioner was guilty of both misconduct and incompetence.

We begin by rejecting petitioner's claim that the failure of either party to call the neighbor as awitness prevented the Administrator from crediting her supervisor's testimony against her. Petitioner'ssupervisor testified to a conversation in which petitioner admitted to him that she had asked theneighbor to lie for her and then declared that "it's not like asking someone to lie for you is against thelaw." Although petitioner testified that she had neither made such an admission nor asked anyone to lie,this conflict was resolved against petitioner and we will not substitute our own credibility determinationsfor those of the Administrator (see Matter ofSindoni v County of Tioga, 67 AD3d 1183, 1184 [2009]; Matter of Ernst v SaratogaCounty, 251 AD2d 866, 867 [1998]; Matter of Smith v Board of Educ., Onteora Cent.School Dist., 221 AD2d 755, 758 [1995], lv denied 87 NY2d 810 [1996]).

As for the determination of incompetence, the evidence established that despite petitioner's positionas the designee responsible for transfers, she was unaware of the travel restrictions and written policiesgoverning interstate transfers. Due to petitioner's admitted unfamiliarity with the rules, she repeatedlyapproved a probationer's travel to Texas beyond the allowable time limit, ultimately causing Texas todeny the probationer's request to transfer to that state. Petitioner's incompetence with respect to thehandling of a convicted sex offender on probation was also documented by evidence reflecting hercontinued failure to require the probationer to complete sex offender therapy. Further, her statute oflimitations argument is unavailing given the continuous nature of the incompetence (see Matter of Canna v Town of Amherst, 55AD3d 1269, 1270 [2008], lv denied 11 NY3d 714 [2009]). The remaining charges ofincompetence, relating to petitioner's failure to properly document her case files and her failure toproperly use the computerized systems for recording information regarding the probationers under hersupervision, are also supported by substantial evidence.

As for the penalty imposed by the Administrator, petitioner's misconduct in attempting to interferewith a criminal investigation compromises her ability to act as a peace officer. That status carries with itthe higher duty of overseeing probationers, making recommendations to courts and requiringprobationers to comply with duly ordered terms and conditions of the courts. The evidence alsoestablished that petitioner's incompetence negatively impacted the probationers under her supervisionand created a risk of harm to the public. In light of these circumstances, as well as a prior letter ofreprimand in her personnel file, we conclude that the penalty of termination is not so disproportionate tothe offense as to be shocking to one's sense of fairness (see Matter of Mapp v Burnham, 8 NY3d 999, 1000 [2007]; Matter of Phillips v Le Page, 4 AD3d704, 705 [2004]; Matter of Tottey v Varvayanis, 307 AD2d at 654; Matter of Spry vDelaware County, 277 AD2d 779, 779-780 [2000]; Matter of Gradel v Lilholt, 257AD2d 972, 973 [1999]).

Spain, J.P., Kavanagh, McCarthy and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.