| Matter of Jamison v Fischer |
| 2010 NY Slip Op 08677 [78 AD3d 1466] |
| November 24, 2010 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Randolph Jamison, Respondent, v BrianFischer, as Commissioner of Correctional Services, Appellant. |
—[*1] Donna H. Lee, New York City, for respondent.
Stein, J. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Teresi, J.), entered April 9, 2010 inAlbany County, which granted petitioner's application, in a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78, toannul a determination of respondent finding petitioner guilty of violating certain disciplinary rules.
Petitioner, an inmate, commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding following his unsuccessfuladministrative appeal of a tier III disciplinary hearing that found him guilty of assaulting staff, creating adisturbance, refusing to be frisked and violent conduct. After concluding that petitioner had beenimproperly denied the right to call witnesses at the hearing, Supreme Court granted the petition anddirected that all references to the matter be expunged from petitioner's institutional record. On thisappeal, respondent concedes that petitioner's rights were violated, but argues that remittal of the matterfor a new hearing rather than expungement was the proper remedy.
We cannot agree. "An inmate generally has the right to call witnesses at a disciplinary hearing whendoing so would not jeopardize institutional safety or correctional goals" (Matter of Buari v Fischer, 70 AD3d1147, 1148 [2010] [citations omitted]). While regulatory violations of this right will necessitateremittal for a new hearing, constitutional violations require [*2]expungement (see Matter of Barnes v LeFevre, 69 NY2d 649,650 [1986]; Matter of Contras v Coughlin, 199 AD2d 601, 602-603 [1993]; see generally Matter of Alvarez v Goord, 30AD3d 118, 120 [2006]). In this regard, we have held that "[a] hearing officer's actual outrightdenial of a witness without a stated good-faith reason, or lack of any effort to obtain a requestedwitness's testimony, constitutes a clear constitutional violation" (Matter of Alvarez v Goord, 30AD3d at 121). Here, the misbehavior report giving rise to the proceeding alleged that petitioner strucka correction officer while he was waiting outside of his cell to be escorted to a prison visitation room.At the ensuing hearing, petitioner denied striking the officer and requested that several inmates whopurportedly observed the incident be called to testify in his defense.
Following an adjournment, the Hearing Officer informed petitioner that five of the requestedwitnesses "don't want to testify, nobody saw anything or heard anything. [They] [a]ll refused to testify,saying they saw nothing, know nothing." However, "Requested Inmate Witness Refusal to Testify"forms submitted with respect to these inmates indicate that each inmate refused to provide anyinformation regarding his ostensible unwillingness to testify. Moreover, all of the forms are unsigned andfour of them are entirely blank but for those portions completed by the correction officer who preparedthem.[FN*]Notably, the Hearing Officer did not inquire of this correction officer as to the facts surrounding theinmates' refusals (see Matter of Hill vSelsky, 19 AD3d 64, 66 [2005]; Matter of Matos v Goord, 293 AD2d 855, 856[2002]).
When two additional refusal forms were subsequently presented to the Hearing Officer, he notedthat "[b]oth give no reason as to why they don't want to testify but both [inmates] signed that they don'twish to testify." One of these forms is nonetheless similarly blank and unsigned; as to the other, while itis signed, the reason provided for the inmate's refusal to testify is "I'm not in my cell." Again, the recordlacks any indication that the Hearing Officer communicated with these inmates—or with thecorrection officer who prepared the forms—to verify their refusals to testify (see Matter ofBarnes v LeFevre, 69 NY2d at 650). Under these circumstances, we conclude that the HearingOfficer's failure to ascertain the reasons for the unwillingness to testify by the inmate witnessesrequested by petitioner was a violation of petitioner's right to call witnesses, requiring expungement,rather than remittal (see Matter of Alvarez v Goord, 30 AD3d at 120; Matter of Contras vCoughlin, 199 AD2d at 602-603; compare Matter of Roberson v Bezio, 70 AD3d 1226, 1227 [2010],lv denied 14 NY3d 714 [2010]; Matter of Buari v Fischer, 70 AD3d at 1148).
Rose, J.P., Lahtinen, McCarthy and Garry, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment is affirmed,without costs. [Prior Case History: 2010 NY Slip Op 30548(U).]
Footnote *: An explanation on the fifth formstates, "I don't want to testify."