Matter of Muscarella v Nassau County Bd. of Elections
2011 NY Slip Op 06272 [87 AD3d 645]
August 16, 2011
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, September 28, 2011


In the Matter of Joseph D. Muscarella,Respondent,
v
Nassau County Board of Elections, Respondent, and Terence W. Kelly,Appellant.

—[*1]

In a proceeding pursuant to Election Law § 16-102, inter alia, to invalidate a petitiondesignating Terence W. Kelly as a candidate in a primary election to be held on September 13,2011, for the nomination of the Independence Party as its candidate for the public office ofMember of the Town Council of the Town of Oyster Bay, Terence W. Kelly appeals from a finalorder of the Supreme Court, Nassau County (Driscoll, J.), entered August 10, 2011, which, aftera hearing (Dana, Gibson, Ct. Atty. Refs.), granted the petition to invalidate the designatingpetition.

Ordered that the final order is affirmed, without costs or disbursements.

The appellant, Terence W. Kelly, challenged approximately 40 line-by-line determinationsmade by the Court Attorney Referees which invalidated certain signatures on his designatingpetition on the ground that they were not sufficiently similar to the signatures on the voterregistration forms on file with the Nassau County Board of Elections. In support of hiscontention, the appellant offered into evidence 26 affidavits of persons whose signatures hadbeen invalidated, attesting to the validity of their signatures on the designating petition. TheSupreme Court, inter alia, determined that, while probative, these affidavits were not dispositiveof the question of whether the signatories signed the designating petition at issue, and noted thatthe signatories could have testified either before the Court Attorney Referees or the SupremeCourt. The Supreme Court conducted a de novo review of the Court Attorney Referees' findingsbased upon the affidavits and the evidence that was before the Court Attorney Referees. Uponreview, the Supreme Court determined that 13 of the signatures initially invalidated by the CourtAttorney Referees were in fact substantially similar to the signatures as they appeared on theregistration forms. The remaining signatures, however, were determined by the Supreme Court tobe invalid, even when taking the affidavits into consideration. Since this ruling resulted in aninsufficient number of signatures on the designating petition, the Supreme Court granted thepetition to invalidate the designating petition.

Contrary to the appellant's contention, the Supreme Court properly determined that thedesignating petition did not contain the requisite number of valid signatures. Under thecircumstances of this case, where the petitioner raised a claim of forgeries, the affidavitssubmitted by the appellant were not dispositive of the issue of whether the affiants signed thedesignating petition (cf. Matter of Jaffeev Kelly, 32 AD3d 485 [2006]).[*2]

The appellant's contention that the Supreme Court failedto afford notarized signatures a presumption of regularity is raised for the first time on appealand, therefore, is not properly before this Court (see Matter of Romaine v Suffolk County Bd. of Elections, 65 AD3d993 [2009]; Matter of Leroy vBoard of Elections in City of N.Y., 65 AD3d 645 [2009]).

The appellant's remaining contention is without merit. Rivera, J.P., Angiolillo, Dickerson,Eng and Hall, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.