| Matter of Letourneau v Town of Berne |
| 2011 NY Slip Op 07776 [89 AD3d 1202] |
| November 3, 2011 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Ann Letourneau, Appellant v Town of Berne et al.,Respondents. |
—[*1] Donald Zee, P.C., Albany (Andrew Brick of counsel), for Town of Berne and others, respondents. Lynch & Hetman, P.L.L.C., Albany (Peter A. Lynch of counsel), for Victor Procopio,respondent.
McCarthy, J. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Connolly, J.), entered November 4,2010 in Albany County, which dismissed petitioner's application, in a proceeding pursuant to CPLRarticle 78, to review a determination of respondent Zoning Board of Appeals of the Town of Bernedenying petitioner's request to rescind a certificate of occupancy issued to respondent Victor Procopio.
In 2001, respondent Victor Procopio purchased a parcel of real property abutting HelderbergLake in the Town of Berne, Albany County. The dwelling on the property had collapsed and beendeclared unsafe by respondent Peter Schaming, the building and zoning administrator for respondentTown of Berne. Procopio obtained a building permit to demolish [*2]the structure and rebuild it.[FN*]After construction began, petitioner, who owns a neighboring parcel, made a request that the Townrescind the permit, then commenced a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 seeking to compel suchrescission. Supreme Court (Egan Jr., J.) dismissed the petition as untimely and this Court affirmed (Matter of Letourneau v Town of Berne, 56AD3d 880 [2008]).
In 2009, Procopio completed the construction and the Town issued a certificate of occupancy.Petitioner sent a letter to respondent Zoning Board of Appeals of the Town of Berne seeking rescissionof the certificate of occupancy, then commenced a proceeding seeking the same relief and an injunctionpreventing Procopio from occupying the premises until it was in compliance with local, county and stateregulations. The Board dismissed petitioner's appeal, contending that it lacked jurisdiction to interpretcounty and state regulations. Supreme Court held that the Board had jurisdiction and remanded for theBoard to resolve two questions: whether the septic system installed by Procopio constituted newconstruction under the Town's zoning code and whether Helderberg Lake is a public water source forthe Town of Bethlehem, Albany County, such that the system had to comply with certain watershedregulations.
On remand, the Board found that the evidence did not establish that Helderberg Lake was asource of public water and that Procopio's septic system was not a new septic system for newconstruction, but was a replacement system. Petitioner commenced this proceeding seeking review ofthe Board's determination and seeking to enjoin Procopio from occupying the premises. SupremeCourt (Connolly, J.) dismissed petitioner's application, finding that it was barred by laches and that itfailed on the merits. Petitioner appeals.
Initially, although the residence has been completely built, the proceeding is not moot or barred bylaches. Petitioner did not delay in seeking to protect her interests. She challenged the building project atthe beginning of construction, sought an injunction and continued to complain about the lack ofregulatory compliance throughout the process, putting Procopio on notice that she would seek reliefand that he was proceeding at his own peril in the face of her challenge (see Matter of Schupak v Zoning Bd. of Appealsof Town of Marbletown, 31 AD3d 1018, 1019-1020 [2006], lv denied anddismissed 8 NY3d 842 [2007]; compareMatter of Clarke v Town of Sand Lake Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 52 AD3d 997, 999-1000[2008], lv denied 11 NY3d 707 [2008]; Bailey v Chernoff, 45 AD3d 1113, 1115 [2007]). Thus, neither lachesnor mootness bar this proceeding.
Nevertheless, Supreme Court properly dismissed the petition on the merits. Petitioner, as the partyseeking rescission of the certificate of occupancy, bore the burden of showing that the certificate wasimproperly issued (see Matter of Hariri vKeller, 34 AD3d 583, 586 [2006]). Regarding whether Helderberg Lake was a source ofpublic water for the Town of Bethlehem, the Board noted that the submitted documents merelycontained "non-conclusive references." The letter from the Town of Bethlehem's commissioner of publicworks does not directly state that Helderberg Lake is part of the watershed that supplies water to thattown. The letter simply states that the commissioner was transmitting several documents that refer to thelake as being part of that watershed. Thus, although given the chance to assert that the lake was asource of its water supply, the Town of Bethlehem did not provide any opinion on the topic. TheAlbany [*3]County Department of Health sent a letter to Schamingstating that the lake "is utilized by the Town of Bethlehem as a source of water" for its public watersupply, and that the watershed rules "may" affect construction of a residential septic system. The letterdoes not provide the source of its statement that the lake is part of the public water supply. Also, if thelake is within the watershed, compliance with the watershed rules would seem to be mandatory, notpermissive as suggested by the use of the word "may." The documents in the record are equivocal anddo not definitively prove that the lake is within the watershed. Accordingly, the Board did not actarbitrarily or irrationally when it determined that the evidence failed to establish that Helderberg Lakeserves as a source of the public water supply for the Town of Bethlehem.
The Town of Berne's zoning ordinance provides that "[n]o person shall undertake to construct anynew [sanitary disposal] structure . . . without first meeting the requirements for a system. . . and obtaining an approved water supply in accordance with applicable regulations ofthe Town, the New York State and Albany County Departments of Health, the New York StateDepartment of Environmental Conservation, and other governmental authorities" (Code of the Town ofBerne § 190-17 [C] [1]). A certificate of occupancy may only be issued after successfulinspection of a new sanitary system, whereas a replacement system does not require an inspection(see Code of the Town of Berne § 190-17 [C] [1]). This Court affords deference to azoning board's interpretation of its own ordinances and will uphold its interpretation unless it is irrationalor unreasonable (see Matter of Smelyansky vZoning Bd. of Appeals of the Town of Bethlehem, 83 AD3d 1267, 1268-1269 [2011]; Matter of Ohrenstein v Zoning Bd. of Appeals ofTown of Canaan, 39 AD3d 1041, 1041 [2007]).
The Town of Berne's zoning ordinance does not define what constitutes a new sanitary system,which would require an inspection prior to issuance of the certificate of occupancy. The Board heardtestimony from Schaming and Lewis Buckman, the engineer who designed and installed Procopio'sseptic system, that the property contained pipes from the prior dwelling that were part of the sanitarydisposal system, but that the system was in disrepair. Schaming and Buckman both testified that areplacement septic system typically does not use any of the old system's components, as they may haverotted or become unusable, and a replacement system is often installed in a different location than thesystem it is replacing due to the unsuitability of the soil near the old system. Although the recordcontains factual discrepancies as to whether the newly constructed building was much larger than theoriginal dwelling, the property still contains a one-family residence. The Board did not act arbitrarily orirrationally in determining that the modernized septic system that Procopio installed to service hisreconstructed residence constituted a replacement for a previous septic system, rather than a newsystem (see Matter of Smelyansky v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of the Town of Bethlehem, 83AD3d at 1268; Matter of Rivendell Winery,LLC v Donovan, 74 AD3d 1594, 1595 [2010]). Accepting the Board's answers to thequestions on remand from Supreme Court, Procopio's replacement septic system was not subject tothe watershed regulations or other regulatory requirements, and no inspection of the system wasrequired prior to issuance of the certificate of occupancy. Thus, the court properly dismissed thepetition.
Rose, J.P., Malone Jr., Kavanagh and Stein, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment is affirmed,without costs.
Footnote *: Although Procopio's application forthe building permit stated that it was for new construction, the permit issued by Schaming was forreconstruction.