Shay v Contento
2012 NY Slip Op 00682 [92 AD3d 994]
February 2, 2012
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, March 28, 2012


Joseph M. Shay, Appellant, v Gerald A. Contento et al.,Respondents. (And a Third-Party Action.)

—[*1]Costello, Cooney & Fearon, P.L.L.C., Syracuse (J. Patrick Lannon of counsel), forappellant.

Mitchell, Goris, Stokes & O'Sullivan, L.L.C., Cazenovia (Mark D. Goris of counsel), forrespondents.

Malone Jr., J. Appeal from that part of an order of the Supreme Court (Rumsey, J.), enteredJanuary 25, 2011 in Cortland County, which granted defendants' cross motion for summaryjudgment dismissing the complaint.

In August 2007, during a family reunion held on defendants' property, plaintiff was injuredwhen a four-wheel-drive utility vehicle[FN1] owned by defendants overturned while it was being operated by his 15-year-old half sister,third-party defendant Amanda Distin (hereinafter Distin). Seeking to recover damages for theresulting injuries, plaintiff commenced this action against defendants and, thereafter, defendantscommenced a third-party action against Distin, as well as her parents, third-party defendants LesDistin and Anne Distin. The Distins moved for summary judgment dismissing the third-partycomplaint and defendants cross-moved for [*2]summaryjudgment dismissing the complaint, each asserting that plaintiff had assumed the risks of ridingin the vehicle. Supreme Court granted the motions and plaintiff appeals from that part of theorder that granted defendants' cross motion for summary judgment dismissing the complaint.

In cases involving athletic or recreational activities, where a plaintiff has freely assumedcommonly known risks inherent in the sport or activity, primary assumption of risk negates anyduty on the part of a defendant to safeguard the plaintiff from those risks (see Trupia v Lake George Cent. SchoolDist., 14 NY3d 392, 395 [2010]; Morgan v State of New York, 90 NY2d 471,484 [1997]; Turcotte v Fell, 68 NY2d 432, 438-439 [1986]). The application of thedoctrine must be closely circumscribed to avoid undermining and displacing the principles ofcomparative causation (see Trupia v Lake George Cent. School Dist., 14 NY3d at 395;see also CPLR 1411). As such, "the inference of such an assumption as a ground forexculpation may not be made . . . except in the context of [athletic or recreational]pursuits both unusually risky and [socially] beneficial that the defendant has in some nonculpableway enabled" (Trupia v Lake George Cent. School Dist., 14 NY3d at 396).

Here, in support of their cross motion, defendants offered evidence that their propertyconsisted of approximately 140 acres of rural farmland on which they, among other things, raisedlivestock for sale. On the day in question, defendant Gerald Contento (hereinafter Contento) anddefendant Theresa Contento allowed a pavilion on the property to be used as a reunion site forapproximately 50 of their family members.[FN2] The area in which the pavilion was located was a flat grassy pasture area and had a graveldriveway that led to a pond. Contento testified that he regularly maintained the driveway,frequently inspecting it for potholes, and kept the grassy area mowed. Contento described thevehicle involved in the accident as one of three four-wheel-drive utility "farm vehicles" that wereused for farm work, such as transporting feed for the animals and moving tools, rather thanrecreational pursuits.[FN3] According to Contento, while he was preparing for the reunion, he gave his children and hisbrother-in-law permission to use the vehicle to transport party supplies to the pavilion. AlthoughContento did not recall seeing the vehicle in the vicinity of the pavilion during the reunion, herecalled that he granted Les Distin permission to use it after he had asked, but denied grantingpermission to use the vehicle to anyone else in attendance. Contento said that he did notremember seeing anyone else driving the vehicle, and he did not know that plaintiff had riddenon it until he was alerted that there had been an accident. Contento also stated that no one hadever been injured while using the farm vehicles before the instant incident.[*3]

According to Distin, the driver, she saw many peopledriving the vehicle during the reunion and did not ask for permission from Contento, her parentsor anyone else before deciding to drive it herself. Distin stated that when plaintiff got in thevehicle with her, they drove around the pond and then started down a hill on the gravel driveway,applying the brake when she reached a speed of approximately 5 or 10 miles per hour. She statedthat when she approached the end of the driveway, she knew that she had to turn around anddecided to leave the driveway and enter the adjacent grassy area. Distin stated that they went overa "hump" in the grass, at which point the vehicle became unstable and then overturned as sheattempted to make a right turn. According to Distin, when the vehicle became unstable, plaintiffreached over and grabbed the steering wheel and attempted to help her make the turn. Plaintiff'stestimony regarding the incident was consistent with Distin's, except that he claimed thatsomeone told him that Contento had given people permission to use the vehicle and that he didnot remember reaching for the steering wheel.

On this record, there is insufficient evidence to establish, as a matter of law, that primaryassumption of risk applies in this case. Even assuming, without finding, that defendants met theirinitial burden of establishing a prima facie entitlement to judgment, issues of fact exist as to,among other things, whether defendants enabled plaintiff's activity in some culpable way (seeTrupia v Lake George Cent. School Dist., 14 NY3d at 396).

Finally, as an alternative ground for affirmance defendants contend that General ObligationsLaw § 9-103 shields them from liability for plaintiff's injury. Although this issue is beingraised for the first time on appeal, it is properly before us (see Ferres v City of NewRochelle, 68 NY2d 446, 450 n 3 [1986]; Sega v State of New York, 60 NY2d 183,190 n 2 [1983]), we find it to be unpersuasive. Here, inasmuch as the negligence alleged byplaintiff is not related solely to the condition of defendants' property itself, but also to anindependent duty separate and distinct therefrom, General Obligations Law § 9-103 is nota complete bar to recovery (see Del Costello v Delaware & Hudson Ry. Co., 274 AD2d19, 22-23 [2000]; cf. Sabia v NiagaraMohawk Power Corp., 87 AD3d 1291, 1293 [2011]).

Peters, J.P., Stein, Garry and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is modified, on thelaw, with costs to plaintiff, by reversing so much thereof as granted defendants' cross motion forsummary judgment dismissing the complaint; cross motion denied; and, as so modified,affirmed. [Prior Case History: 30 Misc 3d 1215(A), 2011 NY Slip Op 50075(U).]

Footnotes


Footnote 1: This utility vehicle differs fromthe typical recreational or sporting all-terrain vehicle in that the driver and passenger sit side byside and it has a small truck-like bed behind the seats in which cargo is hauled.

Footnote 2: Plaintiff's stepfather, Les Distin,is Contento's first cousin.

Footnote 3: Contento was careful todistinguish between the "farm vehicles" at issue, which he referred to as "ATV[s]," and the"recreational vehicles," which he referred to as "four-wheelers," that his children rode for fun.Contento stated that, according to his memory, the children's four-wheelers were not out on theday of the reunion because they "never usually bring them out . . . because of thelittle kids." According to Contento, the farm vehicles "are a lot safer than the four-wheelers."


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.