Noghrey v Town of Brookhaven
2012 NY Slip Op 01439 [92 AD3d 851]
February 21, 2012
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, March 28, 2012


Parviz Noghrey, Respondent,
v
Town of Brookhaven et al.,Appellants.

—[*1]Snitow Kanfer Holtzer & Millus, LLP, New York, N.Y. (Paul F. Millus and Virginia K.Trunkes of counsel), for appellants.

Gleich, Siegel & Farkas, Great Neck, N.Y. (Stephan B. Gleich and Lawrence W. Farkas ofcounsel), for respondent.

In an action, inter alia, to recover damages for a regulatory taking of property without justcompensation, the defendants appeal from (1) so much of an order of the Supreme Court, SuffolkCounty (Whelan, J.), dated February 11, 2010, as, upon a jury verdict finding, among otherthings, that the plaintiff sustained damages in the principal sum of $1,202,000 ($842,000 for theproperty known as Diamond Plaza and $360,000 for the property known as Liberty Plaza),denied their motion pursuant to CPLR 4404 (a) to set aside the verdict and for judgment as amatter of law, or, in the alternative, to set aside the verdict as contrary to the weight of theevidence and for a new trial, (2) a judgment of the same court dated May 7, 2010, and (3) anamended judgment of the same court dated September 20, 2010, which, upon the jury verdict andthe order, inter alia, is in favor of the plaintiff and against them in the principal sum of$1,202,000.

Ordered that the appeals from the order and the judgment are dismissed, without costs ordisbursements; and it is further,

Ordered that the amended judgment is modified, on the law and the facts, (1) by reducing theaward from the principal sum of $1,202,000 to the principal sum of $842,000, and (2) by deletingthe provision thereof awarding the plaintiff interest on the principal sum of $1,202,000; as somodified, the amended judgment is affirmed, without costs or disbursements, that branch of thedefendants' motion pursuant to CPLR 4404 (a) which was to set aside the jury verdict withrespect to the property known as Liberty Plaza as contrary to the weight of the evidence and for anew trial with respect to that property is granted, the order dated February 11, 2010, is modifiedaccordingly, so much of the ninth and twelfth causes of action of the amended complaint asalleged a partial regulatory taking of the property known as Liberty Plaza without justcompensation pursuant to 42 USC § 1983 are severed, and the matter is remitted to theSupreme Court, Suffolk County, for a new trial on those portions of the ninth and twelfth causesof action, and for a recalculation of interest on the damages award pertaining to the propertyknown as Diamond Plaza [*2]in accordance herewith, andthereafter for the entry of appropriate amended judgments.

The appeal from the intermediate order must be dismissed because the right of direct appealtherefrom terminated with the entry of judgment in the action (see Matter of Aho, 39NY2d 241 [1976]). The issues raised on the appeal from the order are brought up for review andhave been considered on the appeal from the amended judgment (see CPLR 5501 [a][1]). The appeal from the judgment must be dismissed as the judgment was superseded by theamended judgment.

The salient facts concerning the plaintiff's claim that a comprehensive rezoning by the Townof Brookhaven effectuated a partial regulatory taking without just compensation of his twoproperties known as Liberty Plaza and Diamond Plaza are set forth in this Court's decision on aprior appeal (see Noghrey v Town ofBrookhaven, 48 AD3d 529 [2008]). On the prior appeal, this Court determined that thejury charge failed to convey the extent of diminution in value necessary to support a partialregulatory taking under federal law, pursuant to Penn Central Transp. Co. v New YorkCity (438 US 104 [1978]), necessitating reversal of a judgment entered in favor of theplaintiff. A new trial was held on that claim, after which the jury found that the rezoningeffectuated a Penn Central taking of the plaintiff's two properties. The jury found that theplaintiff sustained damages in the principal sum of $1,202,000 ($842,000 for the property knownas Diamond Plaza and $360,000 for the property known as Liberty Plaza). The Supreme Courtdenied the defendants' motion pursuant to CPLR 4404 (a) to set aside the verdict and forjudgment as a matter of law, or, in the alternative, to set aside the verdict as contrary to theweight of the evidence and for a new trial.

The plaintiff then submitted a proposed judgment with prejudgment interest calculations,supported by the affidavit of an investment manager who affirmed that such were in accordancewith the standard of a "reasonably prudent investor." Over the defendants' opposition, theSupreme Court accepted the plaintiff's proffered prejudgment interest calculations and enteredjudgment in his favor accordingly. An amended judgment was thereafter entered.

Contrary to the defendants' contention, the finding that the rezoning effectuated a partialregulatory taking of the two properties under federal law was supported by legally sufficientevidence (see Cohen v Hallmark Cards, 45 NY2d 493, 499 [1978]; see also PennCentral Transp. Co. v New York City, 438 US at 124).

However, the jury verdict with respect to the property known as Liberty Plaza wasinconsistent and contrary to the weight of the evidence. The jury was instructed that damageswere to be assessed by determining the value of the properties immediately before andimmediately after the rezoning. The difference between those two values would be the plaintiff'sdamages. Given the expert testimony, the lowest value which could be ascribed to Liberty Plazaprior to the rezoning was $776,500. The damages award of $360,000 represented only a 46% lossin value from that figure. Such a diminution in value cannot support a finding that a regulatorytaking occurred (see Noghrey v Town of Brookhaven, 48 AD3d at 531-532 [andcollected cases]). Accordingly, there was no fair interpretation of the evidence by which the jurycould have found both that the rezoning effectuated a regulatory taking of Liberty Plaza and thatthe plaintiff's damages as to that property were only $360,000. Thus, the Supreme Court shouldhave granted that branch of the defendants' motion pursuant to CPLR 4404 (a) which was to setaside the verdict with respect to Liberty Plaza as contrary to the weight of the evidence and for anew trial with respect to that property. We decline the defendants' request to direct the SupremeCourt, upon retrial, to submit specific interrogatories to the jury (see CPLR 4111 [c];Lunn v County of Nassau, 115 AD2d 457, 458 [1985]).

There was a fair interpretation of the evidence supporting the jury's verdict with respect tothe property known as Diamond Plaza, and that portion of the verdict will therefore not bedisturbed (see Lolik v Big V Supermarkets, 86 NY2d 744, 746 [1995]; Ward v Watson, 72 AD3d 808,809 [2010]; Chase Manhattan Bank v State of New York, 103 AD2d 211, 223-224[1984]).

Furthermore, the Supreme Court properly accepted the plaintiff's proffered calculations ofprejudgment interest in accordance with the "reasonably prudent investor" standard (seeSchneider v County of San Diego, 285 F3d 784, 793-794 [2002]; United States v 50.50Acres of Land, [*3]931 F2d 1349, 1354 [1991]; 520 E. 81st St. Assoc. v State of NewYork, 19 AD3d 24, 28 [2005]).

Accordingly, so much of the ninth and twelfth causes of action of the amended complaint asalleged a partial regulatory taking of the property known as Liberty Plaza without justcompensation pursuant to 48 USC § 1983 are severed, and the matter is remitted to theSupreme Court, Suffolk County, for a new trial on those portions of the ninth and twelfth causesof actions and for a recalculation of interest on the damages award pertaining to the propertyknown as Diamond Plaza, and thereafter for the entry of appropriate amended judgments. Dillon,J.P., Dickerson, Eng and Leventhal, JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.