| Matter of Moye v Fischer |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 01847 [93 AD3d 1006] |
| March 15, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Gilbert Moye, Appellant, v Brian Fischer,as Commissioner of Corrections and Community Supervision,Respondent. |
—[*1] Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Peter H. Schiff of counsel), forrespondent.
Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Connolly, J.), entered March 3, 2011 inAlbany County, which dismissed petitioner's application, in a proceeding pursuant to CPLRarticle 78, to review a determination of respondent which found petitioner guilty of violatingcertain prison disciplinary rules.
While he was being counseled by a correction officer, petitioner struck the officer in the facewith a closed fist. The officer forced petitioner to the ground and petitioner continued to struggle,ignoring the officer's directive to cease such conduct. Petitioner finally stopped when he wasplaced in mechanical restraints. He was thereafter charged in a misbehavior report withassaulting staff, refusing a direct order and engaging in violent conduct. Following a tier IIIdisciplinary hearing, he was found guilty of the charges and the determination was later affirmedon administrative appeal. He then commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding. After service ofrespondent's answer, Supreme Court dismissed the petition and this appeal ensued.
Petitioner contends that he was denied adequate employee assistance because his assistantfailed to interview all of his requested inmate witnesses, who apparently refused to testify at thehearing. He further asserts that he was not provided with copies of the witness refusal forms andthe Hearing Officer did not call the assistant as a witness to testify as to the refusals even thoughhe indicated that he would do so at the hearing. Inasmuch as the record reveals that petitioner wasnot provided an explanation for the refusal of his requested inmate [*2]witnesses to testify, either by his assistant or the Hearing Officer,we conclude that he was deprived of his right to call witnesses.
Initially, we note that an inmate has a conditional constitutional right to call witnesses at aprison disciplinary hearing and, if a request for a particular witness is denied, the inmate must beprovided with a statement of the reason for the denial (see Matter of Laureano vKuhlmann, 75 NY2d 141, 146-147 [1990]; Matter of Hill v Selsky, 19 AD3d 64, 66 [2005]; see also 7NYCRR 254.5 [a]). This principle applies as well where a requested witness has refused totestify (see Matter of Barnes v LeFevre, 69 NY2d 649, 650 [1986]; Matter of Hill vSelsky, 19 AD3d at 66). Notably, this Court has held that "[a] deprivation of the inmate'sright to present witnesses will be found when there has been no inquiry at all into the reason forthe witness's refusal, without regard to whether the inmate previously agreed to testify"(Matter of Hill v Selsky, 19 AD3d at 66 [2005] [emphasis omitted]; see Matter of Crosby v Selsky, 24AD3d 990, 991 [2005]). In the case at hand, it is unclear whether any of the requestedinmate witnesses ever agreed to testify. Nevertheless, the assistant interviewed all of them,reported that they would not testify and even prepared a memorandum to this effect for theHearing Officer. Significantly, however, there is nothing in the record to explain the reasons forthe inmates' refusals to testify (compareMatter of McFadden v Venettozzi, 65 AD3d 1401, 1402 [2009]). No witness refusalforms were ever produced and the assistant was never called to testify concerning thecircumstances of the refusals (see Matter of Crosby v Selsky, 24 AD3d at 991). In viewof the foregoing, we conclude that the Hearing Officer's failure to ascertain the reason for theinmates' refusals to testify violated petitioner's right to call witnesses and requires expungement,rather than remittal (see Matter ofJamison v Fischer, 78 AD3d 1466, 1467 [2010]; compare Matter of Buari v Fischer, 70 AD3d 1147, 1148 [2010]).Moreover, petitioner is entitled to the restoration of good time lost as a result of the disciplinarydetermination (see Matter of Barnes v LeFevre, 69 NY2d at 650; Matter of Pereira v Fischer, 87 AD3d1192 [2011]). In view of our disposition, we need not address petitioner's remaining claims.
Lahtinen, J.P., Spain, Malone Jr., Garry and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgmentis reversed, on the law, without costs, petition granted, determination annulled and respondent isdirected to expunge all references to this matter from petitioner's institutional record.