| Edwards v Davison |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 02684 [94 AD3d 883] |
| April 10, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| J. Yuhanna Edwards et al., Appellants, v Irwin S. Davisonet al., Respondents. |
—[*1] Loretta J. Hottinger, Corporation Counsel, Mount Vernon, N.Y. (Brian G. Johnson ofcounsel), for respondents.
In a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review a determination of the Zoning Boardof Appeals of the City of Mount Vernon dated December 3, 2010, which, after a hearing, grantedthe applications of Veronica Realty Corp. for use and area variances, the petitioners appeal froma judgment of the Supreme Court, Westchester County (Cacace, J.), entered May 20, 2011, whichdenied the petition and dismissed the proceeding.
Ordered that the judgment is reversed, on the law, without costs or disbursements, theproceeding is reinstated, the petition is granted, the determination is annulled, and theapplications for use and area variances are denied.
" 'Generally, a court may set aside a local zoning board's determination considering avariance application only if the zoning board acted illegally, arbitrarily, abused its discretion, orsuccumbed to generalized community opposition, and must sustain the determination if it has arational basis in the record' " (Matter ofWestbury Laundromat, Inc. v Mammina, 62 AD3d 888, 891 [2009], quoting Matter of Ramundo v Pleasant Val. ZoningBd. of Appeals, 41 AD3d 855, 858 [2007]). " 'To qualify for a use variance premisedupon unnecessary hardship there must be a showing that (1) the property cannot yield areasonable return if used only for permitted purposes as currently zoned, (2) the hardship resultedfrom unique characteristics of the property, (3) the proposed use would not alter the character ofthe neighborhood, and (4) the alleged hardship was not self-created' " (Matter of WestburyLaundromat, Inc. v Mammina, 62 AD3d at 891, quoting Matter of Miller Family Ltd. Partnership v Trotta, 23 AD3d 389,389-390 [2005]; see General City Law § 81-b [3] [b]). With regard to the firstelement, the applicant must establish that "no permissible use will yield a reasonable return"(Matter of Village Bd. of Vil. of Fayetteville v Jarrold, 53 NY2d 254, 258 [1981]). Theapplicant must submit "proof, in dollars and cents form, of all matters bearing upon the returnavailable under existing zoning" (id. at 257).
Here, Veronica Realty Corp. (hereinafter Veronica Realty) failed to present any [*2]evidence to the Zoning Board of Appeals of the City of MountVernon (hereinafter the ZBA) that Veronica Realty would be unable to realize a reasonablereturn if it operated a conforming business and, thus, failed to satisfy the first statutory element insupport of its application for a use variance. As the record was devoid of any evidence, in dollarsand cents form, of Veronica Realty's inability to realize a reasonable return under the existingpermissible uses, there was no rational basis for the ZBA's finding that the premises would notyield a reasonable return in the absence of the requested use variance (id. at 260; seeMatter of Park Hill Residents' Assn. v Cianciulli, 234 AD2d 464 [1996]; Matter ofFerruggia v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Town of Warwick, 233 AD2d 505 [1996]).
Since the use variance should have been annulled, the area variance applicable to theproposed nonconforming use should also have been annulled as academic (see e.g. Matter ofKing v Ronik, 237 AD2d 358 [1997]).
In light of our determination, we need not reach the petitioners' remaining contention. Skelos,J.P., Eng, Belen and Cohen, JJ., concur.