| Matter of Zen Ctr. of Syracuse, Inc. v Gamage |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 03294 [94 AD3d 1490] |
| April 27, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
| In the Matter of Zen Center of Syracuse, Inc., Respondent, v JohnC. Gamage, Commissioner, Department of Assessment of City of Syracuse, County ofOnondaga, State of New York, Appellant. |
—[*1] Clifford Forstadt, Dewitt (Robert Temple of counsel), for petitioner-respondent.
Appeal from a judgment (denominated order) of the Supreme Court, Onondaga County(Donald A. Greenwood, J.), entered August 1, 2011 in a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78.The judgment granted the amended petition.
It is hereby ordered that the judgment so appealed from is unanimously affirmed withoutcosts.
Memorandum: Petitioner is a not-for-profit corporation "organized and operated for thefurtherance of the Zen Buddhist religion and activities related thereto." Petitioner owns propertyin the City of Syracuse, which it uses as a residential and dining facility for students of ZenBuddhism and visiting clergy. Petitioner commenced this hybrid CPLR article 78 proceeding anddeclaratory judgment action seeking a real property tax exemption pursuant to RPTL 420-a (1)(a). Respondent appeals from a judgment granting the amended petition and determining thatpetitioner is tax exempt for the 2010 tax year. We shall treat this as a proceeding solely pursuantto CPLR article 78 inasmuch as petitioner may thereby obtain the relief sought, without thenecessity of a declaration. We affirm.
Contrary to respondent's contention, "there is no requirement that an application be filed toobtain an RPTL 420-a exemption" (Matter of Eternal Flame of Hope Ministries, Inc. v King, 76 AD3d775, 777 [2010], affd 16 NY3d 778 [2011]; see Kahal Bnei Emunim & TalmudTorah Bnei Simon Israel v Town of Fallsburg, 78 NY2d 194, 201-204 [1991], reargdenied 78 NY2d 1008 [1991]). Thus, Supreme Court properly granted petitioner the RPTL420-a exemption, despite the fact that petitioner did not file an application for an exemption withrespondent (see Kahal Bnei Emunim & Talmud Torah Bnei Simon Israel, 78 NY2d at201-204).[*2]
Respondent further contends that the court erred ingranting petitioner the RPTL 420-a exemption because petitioner failed to commence a taxcertiorari proceeding pursuant to RPTL article 7 (see generally RPTL 706). We reject thatcontention. RPTL 420-a (1) (a) provides a mandatory tax exemption for "[r]eal property ownedby a corporation . . . organized or conducted exclusively for religious. . . purposes, and used exclusively for carrying out thereupon . . . suchpurposes." According to petitioner, respondent "wrongfully and illegally failed to classify [theproperty] as exempt religious property . . . ." A "proceeding commenced tochallenge the denial of a mandatory exemption is, in essence, a challenge to the taxing authority'sjurisdiction over the subject property" (Eternal Flame of Hope Ministries, Inc., 76 AD3dat 777; see Kahal Bnei Emunim & Talmud Torah Bnei Simon Israel, 78 NY2d at204-205; Hewlett Assoc. v City of New York, 57 NY2d 356, 363-364 [1982]; seealso Xerox Corp. v Town of Webster, 204 AD2d 990, 991 [1994]). "It is well recognizedthat where a challenge is made to the taxing authority's jurisdiction over the subject property, thesettled rule that review of a tax assessment may be obtained only by way of the statutorycertiorari procedures is not applicable" (Hewlett Assoc., 57 NY2d at 363; see KahalBnei Emunim & Talmud Torah Bnei Simon Israel, 78 NY2d at 205; Xerox Corp.,204 AD2d at 991). Thus, inasmuch as petitioner contends that the property is wholly exemptfrom taxation pursuant to RPTL 420-a (1) (a), "review by way of collateral proceedings isappropriate" (Hewlett Assoc., 57 NY2d at 363; see Kahal Bnei Emunim & TalmudTorah Bnei Simon Israel, 78 NY2d at 204-205; see also Xerox Corp., 204 AD2d at991).
Contrary to respondent's contention, petitioner met its burden of establishing that the subjectproperty is used exclusively in furtherance of its religious purpose (see RPTL 420-a [1][a]; see e.g. Congregation RabbinicalColl. of Tartikov, Inc. v Town of Ramapo, 17 NY3d 763, 764 [2011]; Matter of Adult Home at Erie Sta., Inc. vAssessor & Bd. of Assessment Review of City of Middletown, 10 NY3d 205, 215-216[2008]). Respondent's remaining contentions are not preserved for our review (see Ciesinskiv Town of Aurora, 202 AD2d 984, 985 [1994]; see generally Matter of County of Niagara v Daines, 79 AD3d1702, 1704 [2010], lv denied 17 NY3d 703 [2011]) and, in any event, they arewithout merit. Present—Centra, J.P., Carni, Lindley, Sconiers and Martoche, JJ.