Matter of Gibson v Board of Educ. for the City School Dist. ofAlbany
2012 NY Slip Op 04441 [96 AD3d 1120]
June 7, 2012
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, August 1, 2012


In the Matter of Bessie Gibson, Petitioner,
v
Board ofEducation for the City School District of Albany et al., Respondents.

—[*1]David N. Green, Loudonville (Robert M. Cohen, Ballston Lake, of counsel), forpetitioner.

Girvin & Ferlazzo, P.C., Albany (Jeffrey D. Honeywell of counsel), forrespondents.

Spain, J.P. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by order of theSupreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review a determination of respondent Board ofEducation for the City School District of Albany which terminated petitioner's employment.

Petitioner, employed since 1993 with the City School District of Albany—mostrecently as an account clerk—was charged with two specifications of incompetence:unsatisfactory work performance and excessive absenteeism, during the 2009-2010 school year.Following a hearing pursuant to Civil Service Law § 75, petitioner was found guilty ofboth specifications. The Hearing Officer, in a detailed written report, recommended dismissal asa penalty. Respondent Board of Education for the City School District of Albany accepted theHearing Officer's findings and recommendation and terminated petitioner's employment.Petitioner commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding challenging her dismissal, contendingthat the evidence did not support the Board's finding that her conduct and deficiencies rose to thelevel of incompetence, and that dismissal is an inappropriate and excessive penalty.

The determination of the Board must be upheld where, as here, it is supported by substantialevidence (see Matter of Wilson v Townof Minerva Town Bd., 65 AD3d 788, 789[*2][2009]; see also Matter of Mapp v Burnham, 8NY3d 999, 1000 [2007]). Significantly, "a finding of incompetence . . . onlyrequires evidence of some dereliction or neglect of duty" (Matter of Branam v Simons,300 AD2d 973, 974 [2002]; accordMatter of Phillips v Le Page, 4 AD3d 704, 705 [2004]). The testimony of petitioner'sdirect supervisors, coworkers and two district-level assistant supervisors, and the documentaryevidence—including petitioner's employee evaluations in March 2009 and May 2010 andattendance records—provided overwhelming evidence to substantiate each of thespecifications of misconduct.

The testimony at the hearing established that after six years as an account clerk in thepurchasing department, during which she was warned about her inadequate job performance andexcessive absenteeism, and in order to provide her with a new work environment, petitioner wastransferred in July 2008 to the food services department, where she was assigned a variety oftasks appropriate to her account clerk title. The evidence established recurring problems withpetitioner's work performance from the outset, which continued until these charges were filed in2010, including failing to take accurate or complete telephone messages, thereby makingresponding to said calls difficult, incorrect filing of paperwork, advising parents to submitinaccurate income information on their applications for the free/reduced lunch program ormisadvising parents regarding eligibility for same, failing to maintain accurate inventories,neglecting to timely pay vendors and failing to maintain accurate and timely attendance recordsrequired in order for the District to obtain reimbursement for the after school snack program. Shewas observed neglecting her duty to answer telephones, including hanging up on callers orfeigning being engaged in a call, and allowing paperwork to languish on her desk. Despite beingadvised of her mistakes and repeatedly retrained by different individuals onnumerous—mostly repetitive—tasks, the errors, deficiencies and failure to completetasks in a timely or accurate manner—or at all—persisted; this often necessitatedthat her tasks be permanently reassigned, corrected or completed by others. Likewise, petitionerwas assigned certain limited duties relating to payroll for her department, but regularly madeerrors which, although explained to her, she failed to correct in the next payroll period; hersubmissions were often late (more than half the time) and she refused additional training when itwas offered.

Attendance records demonstrate petitioner's three-year history of habitual and excessiveabsenteeism, for which she was warned in 2007, and that she had exhausted her sick time andtaken unapproved days off without pay in the 2009-2010 school year. The testimony of hersupervisor established that her chronic absences became predictable, in that she usually called insick the day following any day in which there was perceived turmoil at the office or when shewas questioned about her work.

The Hearing Officer credited the testimony of respondents' witnesses, all of whom hadsignificant employment history with the District, and no motive for them to testify untruthfullywas suggested. Given the abundant testimony and evidence of petitioner's ongoing inability toperform her job duties despite retraining, and of her excessive absenteeism, all of whichnegatively affected her department's operations and burdened her coworkers and supervisors, aswell as other departments, we find that substantial evidence supports the finding of incompetence(see Matter of Phillips v Le Page, 4 AD3d at 705).

Further, on the record before us, we do not find the penalty of termination shocking to thejudicial conscience (see Matter of Kelly v Safir, 96 NY2d 32, 39 [2001]; Matter ofPell v Board of Educ. of Union Free School Dist. No. 1 of Towns of Scarsdale & Mamaroneck,Westchester County, 34 NY2d 222, 234 [1974]; see also Matter of Ellis v Mahon, 11 NY3d 754, [*3]755 [2008]). Petitioner's incompetence was ongoing andmulti-faceted, with negative evaluations dating back to 2003; she failed to improve despiterepeated retraining. She was given numerous warnings over a period of many years and failed toassume responsibility for her shortcomings. In view of the foregoing, the Board's implicitconclusion that further attempts to rehabilitate and retrain petitioner would be futile is neitherunfair, shocking nor an abuse of discretion.

Kavanagh, Stein and McCarthy, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination is confirmed,without costs, and petition dismissed.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.