| Matter of Gloria M. (Kiladi M.) |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 05173 [96 AD3d 1060] |
| June 27, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Gloria M., an Infant. Rockland County Departmentof Social Services, Respondent; Kiladi M., Appellant. (Proceeding No. 1.) In the Matter ofChristy M., an Infant. Rockland County Department of Social Services, Respondent; Kiladi M.,Appellant. (Proceeding No. 2.) In the Matter of Rosa M., an Infant. Rockland County Departmentof Social Services, Respondent; Kiladi M., Appellant. (Proceeding No. 3.) In the Matter of JongM., an Infant. Rockland County Department of Social Services, Respondent; Kiladi M.,Appellant. (Proceeding No. 4.) |
—[*1] Jeffrey Fortunato, Acting County Attorney, New City, N.Y. (Barbara M. Wilmit of counsel),for respondent. Veronica J. Young, New City, N.Y., attorney for the children Rosa M., Christy M., andGloria M. Anne Dorfman, Nanuet, N.Y., attorney for the child Jong M.
In four related child protective proceedings pursuant to Family Court Act article 10, thefather appeals (1) from a fact-finding order of the Family Court, Rockland County (Warren, J.),entered March 7, 2011, which, after a hearing, found that he sexually abused the child Rosa M.,and derivatively neglected the children Christy M. and Gloria M., (2) from an order ofdisposition of the same court entered June 28, 2011, which, upon the fact-finding order enteredMarch 7, 2011, and [*2]after a dispositional hearing, inter alia,placed the children Rosa M., Christy M., and Gloria M. in the custody of the Commissioner ofSocial Services of Rockland County, (3) from a fact-finding order of the same court entered July14, 2011, which, after a hearing, found that he derivatively neglected the child Jong M., and (4)from an order of disposition of the same court entered September 7, 2011, which, upon thefact-finding order entered July 14, 2011, and after a dispositional hearing, placed the child JongM. in the custody of the Commissioner of Social Services of Rockland County.
Ordered that the appeals from the fact-finding orders entered March 7, 2011, and July 14,2011, are dismissed, without costs or disbursements, as the fact-finding orders were supersededby the orders of disposition and are brought up for review on the appeals from the orders ofdisposition; and it is further,
Ordered that the orders of disposition entered June 28, 2011, and September 7, 2011, areaffirmed, without costs or disbursements.
Based upon our review of the record and deferring to the Family Court's resolutions ofcredibility issues (see Matter of LindsayB. [Carlton B.], 80 AD3d 763 [2011]; Matter of Daniel R. [Lucille R.], 70 AD3d 839 [2010]; Matter of Maithsa Edourd S., 27 AD3d475, 476 [2006]), we conclude that the Family Court's determination that the father sexuallyabused his daughter Rosa M. is supported by a preponderance of the evidence (seeFamily Ct Act § 1046 [b] [i]; Matter of Andrew W. [Randolph A.W.], 83 AD3d 727 [2011]; Matter of Lauryn H. [William A.], 73AD3d 1175 [2010]).
Additionally, while a finding of sexual abuse of one child does not, by itself, establish thatthe other children in the household have been derivatively neglected, here, the father's abuse ofhis daughter evinced a flawed understanding of his duties as a parent and his impaired parentaljudgment sufficient to support the Family Court's finding that he derivatively neglected thechildren Christy M., Gloria M., and Jong M. (see Matter of Kassandra V. [Sylvia L.], 90 AD3d 940 [2011]; Matter of Grant W. [Raphael A.], 67AD3d 922 [2009]).
The Family Court did not improvidently exercise its discretion in closing the courtroom tothe public during a portion of the fact-finding hearing (see Family Ct Act § 1043;22 NYCRR 205.4 [b] [3]; Matter of Ruben R., 219 AD2d 117 [1996]; Matter ofKatherine B., 189 AD2d 443 [1993]).
We reject the father's contention that the Family Court deprived him of any due processrights or the Sixth Amendment right of confrontation when it allowed the child Rosa M. to testifyoutside of his presence. The father's attorney was present and was permitted to cross-examine thechild (see Matter of Sylvia J., 23AD3d 560 [2005]; Matter ofHeather S., 19 AD3d 606 [2005]). The Family Court properly balanced the respectiveinterests of the parties and, based upon the record, reasonably concluded that the child wouldsuffer emotional trauma if compelled to testify in front of the father (see Matter of Deshawn D.O. [MariaT.O.], 81 AD3d 961 [2011]; Matter of Q.-L. H., 27 AD3d 738 [2006]).
The record demonstrates that the father was afforded the effective assistance of counsel(see Family Ct Act § 262 [a] [i]; Matter of Mariah C. [Frey C.-M.], 84 AD3d 1372 [2011]; Matter of Kathleen K., 66 AD3d683, 684 [2009]; Matter of EvanF., 48 AD3d 811 [2008]).
Finally, the "essential consideration" in the placement of a child in a child protectiveproceeding and in making an award of custody is the best interests of the child, and the FamilyCourt's determination will be upheld where it has a sound and substantial basis in the record (Matter of Howard A.W. v Nyah VernellJ., 88 AD3d 733, 734 [2011] [internal quotation marks omitted]; Matter of Daniel R. [Lucille R.], 70AD3d 839, 842 [2010]; Matter of Ramazan U. v Belkis P., 303 AD2d 516, 517[2003]). Under the totality of the circumstances, releasing the children to the custody of theCommissioner of the Department of Social Services of Rockland County had a sound andsubstantial basis in the record and will not be disturbed. Skelos, J.P., Florio, Lott and Miller, JJ.,concur.