| Matter of Marcus v Board of Trustees of Vil. of Wesley Hills |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 05175 [96 AD3d 1063] |
| June 27, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Neil Marcus et al., Respondents, v Boardof Trustees of Village of Wesley Hills et al., Appellants. |
—[*1] Steven Habiague (Mischel & Horn, P.C., New York, N.Y. [Scott T. Horn], of counsel), forappellants Ira Wickes and Rockland Tree Expert, Inc., doing business as Ira Wickes Arborist. Alan McGeorge, Haverstraw, N.Y., for respondents.
In a hybrid proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78, inter alia, to review a determination ofthe Board of Trustees of the Village of Wesley Hills dated June 13, 2006, adopting a resolutionenacting Local Law No. 3 (2006) of the Village of Wesley Hills, which amended the zoning lawto authorize additional special permit uses, and action for a judgment declaring that Local LawNo. 3 (2006) of the Village of Wesley Hills is null and void as unlawful spot zoning, (1) theBoard of Trustees of the Village of Wesley Hills appeals, and Ira Wickes and Rockland TreeExpert, Inc., doing business as Ira Wickes Arborist, separately appeal, from a judgment of theSupreme Court, Rockland County (Walsh, J.), dated April 15, 2010, which granted the petition tothe extent of annulling Local Law No. 3 (2006) of the Village of Wesley Hills, and (2) IraWickes and Rockland Tree Expert, Inc., doing business as Ira Wickes Arborist, appeal from anorder of the same court dated May 12, 2011, which denied their motion for leave to renew theiropposition to the petition.
Ordered that the judgment is reversed, on the law, the petition is denied, the proceeding isdismissed, and it is declared that Local Law No. 3 (2006) of the Village of Wesley Hills is notnull and void as unlawful spot zoning; and it is further,
Ordered that the appeal from the order is dismissed as academic in light of our determinationon the appeal from the judgment; and it is further;
Ordered that one bill of costs is awarded to the appellants appearing separately and filingseparate briefs.[*2]
The facts of this matter are set forth in our decision andorder on a prior appeal (see Matter ofMarcus v Board of Trustees of Vil. of Wesley Hills, 62 AD3d 799 [2009]).
The Supreme Court incorrectly determined that the adoption by the Board of Trustees of theVillage of Wesley Hills (hereinafter the Board) of a resolution enacting Local Law No. 3 (2006)of the Village of Wesley Hills (hereinafter the Local Law) constituted unlawful spot zoning. "TheLocal Law[, which added] 'Arborist Services, Landscape Services, and/or Wholesale Nurseries'as a special permit use within the R-35 zoning district" (Matter of Marcus v Board ofTrustees of Vil. of Wesley Hills, 62 AD3d at 801) did not allow for a use which was totallydifferent from that allowed in the surrounding area and was in conformity with thecomprehensive plan of the Village of Wesley Hills (see Rodgers v Village of Tarrytown,302 NY 115 [1951]; Matter of Stone v Scarpato, 285 AD2d 467 [2001]). Although thereis no doubt that the Local Law was adopted primarily for the benefit of the plant nursery andarborist business operated by Ira Wickes and Rockland Tree Expert, Inc., doing business as IraWickes Arborist (hereinafter together Wickes), zoning changes are not invalid merely because asingle parcel is involved in or benefitted by said changes (see Rodgers v Village ofTarrytown, 302 NY at 124). In any event, the Local Law applies to all parcels in the R-35zoning district which meet certain requirements, and it is undisputed that the special permit itauthorizes could be utilized by two other properties within the Village (id.). Also, there isno evidence in the record that Wickes's use of the property in compliance with the Local Law anda special permit issued thereunder would be detrimental to owners of other properties in the area(id.).
Contrary to the contentions of the petitioners/plaintiffs (hereinafter the petitioners), the Boardcomplied with the State Environmental Quality Review Act (ECL art 8) when it issued a negativedeclaration concluding that the enactment of the Local Law would have no adverseenvironmental impacts or that the identified adverse environmental impacts would not besignificant (see 6 NYCRR 617.7 [a] [2]). The record reflects that the Board "identifiedthe relevant areas of environmental concern, took a 'hard look' at them, and made a 'reasonedelaboration' of the basis for their determination" (Chinese Staff & Workers Assn. v City ofNew York, 68 NY2d 359, 363-364 [1986], quoting Matter of Jackson v New York StateUrban Dev. Corp., 67 NY2d 400, 417 [1986] [internal quotation marks omitted]; seeMatter of Concerned Citizens of Val. Stream v Bond, 282 AD2d 532 [2001]). The recordalso reveals that the Board's deferral of site-specific review of certain environmental issues to theVillage's Planning Board, upon its consideration of individual special permit applications, was noless protective of the environment (see 6 NYCRR 617.3 [g] [1]).
There is no merit to the petitioners' contention that the Local Law should be annulled due tothe Board's failure to timely file a report of the final action it had taken in connection with theLocal Law with the Rockland County Department of Planning within 30 days after the finalaction pursuant to General Municipal Law § 239-m (6). Under the circumstances of thiscase, where the Board otherwise complied with the referral provisions of General Municipal Law§ 239-m and there is no claim of prejudice, the Board's failure to timely file a report of thefinal action with the Rockland County Department of Planning after adopting the Local Law wasa mere procedural irregularity (cf. Matter of Zelnick v Small, 268 AD2d 527, 529 [2000];Matter of Ernalex Constr. Realty Corp. v City of Glen Cove, 256 AD2d 336, 338[1998]).
The petitioners' remaining contentions are without merit.
Accordingly, the petition must be denied and the proceeding dismissed, and, in the interest ofjudicial economy, for the same reasons as set forth in connection with the CPLR article 78proceeding, the declaratory judgment action will be decided by declaring that the Local Law isnot null and void as unlawful spot zoning. Angiolillo, J.P., Belen, Roman and Sgroi, JJ., concur.