Matter of Avramis v Sarachan
2012 NY Slip Op 05364 [97 AD3d 874]
July 5, 2012
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, August 22, 2012


In the Matter of Maria Avramis, Respondent , v Robert Sarachan, asCity Prosecutor of the City of Ithaca, et al., Appellants. (Proceeding No. 1.) In the Matter ofMaria Avramis, Respondent,
v
Board of Zoning Appeals of the City of Ithaca et al.,Appellants, et al., Respondents. (Proceeding No. 2.)

—[*1]Young Sommer, LLC, Albany (Michael J. Moore of counsel), for Robert Sarachan andothers, appellants.

Harris Beach, PLLC, Ithaca (Russell E. Maines of counsel), for respondent.

Lahtinen, J. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Mulvey, J.), entered September6, 2011 in Tompkins County, which, among other things, partially granted petitioner'sapplications, in two combined proceedings pursuant to CPLR article 78 and actions fordeclaratory judgment, to, among other things, annul a determination of respondent Zoning Boardof Appeals of the City of [*2]Ithaca finding petitioner'senlargement of a parking area to be an unauthorized extension and enlargement of anonconforming use.

Petitioner is the longtime owner of a four-unit, 12-bedroom apartment building in the City ofIthaca, Tompkins County, which is used primarily as housing for college students. The propertyalso had four off-street parking spaces located in front of the building. The applicable zoning waschanged in 1977 to allow only single and two-family dwellings, resulting in petitioner'sapartment building becoming a legally nonconforming use of the property. In 2007, petitionerreceived a building permit allowing her to remove a rear porch and make various interioralterations, which would not increase the number of occupants of the building. As workprogressed, petitioner also started constructing, without a permit, a parking lot in the rear of herproperty to replace the front parking area as well as increase the number of available parkingspaces for the building.

Following complaints by neighbors and an investigation of the work, a representative of theCity's Building Department notified petitioner that she must submit documentation for site planreview regarding the rear yard parking, that the amount of parking for the property was limited tothe four grandfathered spaces, and that a use variance would be necessary to expand parkingbeyond four vehicles. Petitioner applied for site plan approval for rear yard parking for eightvehicles and then supplemented the application seeking rear yard parking for 10 vehicles. Theapplication was rejected because it exceeded the four grandfathered spaces without a usevariance. Following the submission of further documentation, appearances of counsel andcomments from neighbors, respondent Board of Zoning Appeals of the City of Ithaca (hereinafterBoard) upheld the determination that a use variance was necessary to construct more than fourparking spaces.

Various proceedings were commenced and, as relevant to this appeal, petitioner sought,among other things, to compel the City's Building Commissioner to issue a permit forconstruction of off-street rear yard parking and to annul the Board's determination that a usevariance was necessary to exceed four parking spaces. Supreme Court, among other things, foundthat, under the City's zoning ordinance, off-street rear yard parking was a permitted accessory useof the nonconforming apartment building. The court declared that the off-street parkingprovisions of the ordinance (which would allow more than four parking spaces on petitioner'sproperty) controlled and further declared that installation of parking spaces in conformity withthe ordinance did not require a use variance. The decision of the Board was thus annulled andrespondents were directed to accept petitioner's application for site plan review. Respondentsappeal.

Except "where the question is one of pure legal interpretation" (Matter of Teachers Ins. &Annuity Assn. of Am. v City of New York, 82 NY2d 35, 42 [1993]), " '[t]he [Board's]interpretation [of its zoning ordinance] is entitled to great deference and will not be disturbedwhere . . . it is not shown to be irrational or unreasonable' " (Matter of Kantor v Olsen, 9 AD3d814, 815 [2004], quoting Matter of Sacandaga Park Civic Assn. v Zoning Bd. of Appealsof Town of Northampton, 296 AD2d 807, 808 [2002]; see Matter of Takourian v Town of Bethel Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 90AD3d 1454, 1455 [2011]; Matter ofSmelyansky v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of the Town of Bethlehem, 83 AD3d 1267, 1268[2011]). When that interpretation involves a determination regarding a nonconforming use, anowner who challenges the zoning board faces a "burden of persuasion [that] is high because ofthe law's traditional aversion to nonconforming uses" (Matter of Pelham Esplanade v Boardof Trustees of Vil. of Pelham Manor, [*3]77 NY2d 66, 70[1990]). Nonconforming uses are generally viewed "as detrimental to a zoning scheme, and theoverriding public policy of zoning . . . is aimed at their reasonable restriction andeventual elimination" (Matter of Toys "R" Us v Silva, 89 NY2d 411, 417 [1996]; seeVerstandig's Florist v Board of Appeals of Town of Bethlehem, 229 AD2d 851, 852 [1996])."While nonconforming uses are generally permitted to continue, they may not be enlarged as amatter of right" (Matter of Rudolf Steiner Fellowship Found. v De Luccia, 90 NY2d 453,458 [1997] [citation omitted]; see Matter of Gilchrist v Town of Lake George PlanningBd., 255 AD2d 791, 792-793 [1998]).

Initially, we note that the dispute is primarily about the number of parking spaces sincerespondents acknowledge that petitioner has a right to four parking spaces which, subject to siteplan review, can be relocated to the rear of the property. When the parking provisions of thezoning ordinance are read in isolation, those provisions would allow (and even require) morethan four spaces on petitioner's property. The Board, however, determined that the parkingprovisions apply only to conforming use property and not to nonconforming property. Read inthe context of the entire zoning ordinance and the goals incorporated therein, this interpretation isnot unreasonable. There is nothing in the zoning ordinance that clearly requires a contraryinterpretation.

Additionally, under the Board's interpretation of the zoning ordinance, it viewed petitioner'sentire parcel—not simply the structure thereon—to be nonconforming since bothmultiple residential units and accompanying parking of numerous vehicles on a single parcelwould be significantly at odds with the general purposes of an area zoned for single andtwo-family dwellings. While a different interpretation might have been feasible, the Board'sinterpretation was neither irrational nor unreasonable and, in fact, it was consistent with thegeneral policy when dealing with nonconforming uses. The zoning ordinance gave manyexamples of accessory uses, and parking for a nonconforming apartment building was notincluded therein. Under the prevailing circumstances, it was reasonable for the Board to interpretthe zoning ordinance so as to consider the entire property as a nonconforming use rather thansimply a nonconforming structure with an accessory use. In any event, the effort to more thandouble the amount of parking constituted such a significant increase in intensity and volume overwhat had existed as to go beyond a mere accessory use (see Gilchrist v Town of Lake GeorgePlanning Bd., 255 AD2d at 792-793).

The provisions of the zoning ordinance specifically addressing nonconforming uses providethat such uses may not be extended or enlarged unless a variance is granted. Accordingly, thatpart of the petition seeking to annul the determination of the Board that required a variance toexceed four parking spaces should have been dismissed and the request for a declaration withregard thereto denied.

Mercure, J.P., Rose, Stein and McCarthy, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment is modified,on the law, without costs, by reversing so much thereof as partially granted petitioner'sapplications and annulled the determination of respondent Board of Zoning Appeals of the Cityof Ithaca that required a use variance for the installation of additional parking spaces beyond fourspaces and declared the rights of parties with regard thereto; petitions dismissed to that extent;and, as so modified, affirmed.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.