Matter of Lavine v Imbroto
2012 NY Slip Op 05969 [98 AD3d 620]
August 15, 2012
Appellate Division, Second Department
As corrected through Wednesday, September 26, 2012


In the Matter of Charles D. Lavine, Respondent,
v
MichelleImbroto, Appellant, et al., Respondents. (Proceeding No. 1.) In the Matter of Michelle Imbroto,Appellant, v Charles D. Lavine, Respondent, et al., Respondents. (Proceeding No.2.)

—[*1]

In a proceeding pursuant to Election Law § 16-102, inter alia, to validate a petitiondesignating Charles D. Lavine as a candidate in a primary election to be held on September 13,2012, for the nomination of the Democratic Party as its candidate for the public office of Memberof the Assembly, 13th Assembly District, and a related proceeding, inter alia, to invalidate thedesignating petition, Michelle Imbroto appeals from a final order of the Supreme Court, NassauCounty (Winslow, J.), entered August 6, 2012, which, after a hearing, granted the petition tovalidate the designating petition, denied the petition, inter alia, to invalidate the designatingpetition, and, in effect, dismissed the proceeding, inter alia, to invalidate the designating petition.

Ordered that the final order is affirmed, without costs or disbursements.

Generally, a designating petition will be invalidated on the ground of fraud only "where thereis a showing that the entire designating petition is permeated with fraud" (Matter of Finn v Sherwood, 87 AD3d1044, 1045 [2011]; see Matter of Proskin v May, 40 NY2d 829, 829-830 [1976]; Matter of Harris v Duran, 76 AD3d658, 659 [2010]; Matter ofRobinson v Edwards, 54 AD3d 682, 683 [2008]; Matter of Ragusa v Roper, 286AD2d 516 [2001]; Matter of Del Pellegrino v Giuliani, 153 AD2d 724, 725 [1989]), or"where the candidate has participated in or is chargeable with knowledge of the fraud"(Matter of Finn v Sherwood, 87 AD3d at 1045; see Matter of Harris v Duran, 76AD3d at 659).

Here, the appellant contends that four out of approximately 690 signatures were invalid onthe ground of fraud. Contrary to the appellant's contention, the hearing testimony regarding thesefour signatures did not demonstrate by clear and convincing evidence that the entire designatingpetition was permeated with fraud (see Matter of Finn v Sherwood, 87 AD3d at 1045;see also Matter of Harris v Duran, 76 AD3d at 659; Matter of Ferraro v McNab,96 AD2d 917 [1983], affd 60 NY2d 601 [1983]; cf. Matter of Proskin v May, 40NY2d at 829-830; Matter of Lerner v Power, 22 NY2d 767 [1968]; Matter of Harry vLiblick, 119 AD2d 845 [1986]). Moreover, the appellant failed to meet her burden ofestablishing that the candidate participated in or was chargeable with knowledge of any fraud(see Matter of Finn v Sherwood, 87 AD3d at 1045; Matter of Ragusa v Roper,286 AD2d at 517; cf. Matter of Miller v [*2]Gumbs, 207AD2d 512, 513 [1994]).

Contrary to the appellant's contention, the Supreme Court properly determined that noadverse inference should be drawn against the candidate based on the failure of certainsubscribing witnesses to appear at the hearing. The Supreme Court properly quashed thesubpoenas with respect to each of those subscribing witnesses on the ground that the subpoenaswere improperly served (see CPLR 308, 2303 [a]; cf. Serraro v Staropoli, 94 AD3d 1083 [2012]).

The appellant's remaining contention is without merit. Dillon, J.P., Florio, Eng and Cohen,JJ., concur.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.