| Matter of Brian M. v New York State Off. of Children & FamilyServs. |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 06078 [98 AD3d 743] |
| August 29, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Brian M., Petitioner, v New York StateOffice of Children and Family Services, Respondent. |
—[*1] Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, New York, N.Y. (Michael S. Belohlavek andPatrick J. Walsh of counsel), for respondent.
Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review a determination of the New York StateOffice of Children and Family Services dated April 30, 2010, which, after a hearing, denied thepetitioner's application to amend and seal an indicated report maintained by the New York StateCentral Register of Child Abuse and Maltreatment.
Adjudged that the petition is granted, on the law, with costs, the determination is annulled,and the matter is remitted to the respondent to amend the indicated report to an unfounded reportand to seal the amended report.
The petitioner was the subject of an indicated report of maltreatment maintained by the NewYork State Central Register of Child Abuse and Maltreatment based on an alleged instance ofexcessive corporal punishment, with respect to one child (hereinafter the subject child), andinadequate guardianship under a theory of derivative maltreatment with respect to three otherchildren (hereinafter the other children). The petitioner made an application to have the reportamended from "indicated" to "unfounded." After a hearing, the New York State Office ofChildren and Family Services denied the petitioner's application to amend and seal the indicatedreport.
A maltreated child is defined as a child whose physical, mental, or emotional condition hasbeen impaired as a result of the failure of his or her parent to exercise a minimum degree of carein providing the child with proper supervision or guardianship, by unreasonably inflicting harm,including the infliction of excessive corporal punishment (see Social Services Law§ 412 [2] [a] [i]; Family Ct Act § 1012 [f] [i] [B]; 18 NYCRR 432.1 [b] [1]; see also Matter of Esteva v New York StateCent. Register of Child Abuse & Maltreatment, 82 AD3d 978, 979 [2011]). At anadministrative expungement hearing to determine whether a report of child maltreatment issubstantiated, the allegations in the report must be established by a fair preponderance of theevidence (see Matter of Lee TT. v Dowling, 87 NY2d 699, 703 [1996]; Matter of Reed v Carrion, 84 AD3d1094, 1094 [2011]). Judicial review of a determination that such a report has beensubstantiated is limited to whether the determination is supported by substantial evidence in therecord (see Matter of Blythe [*2]v Carrion, 63 AD3d 1059, 1060 [2009]; Matter of Joseph v Johnson, 27 AD3d563, 563 [2006]; see also 300 Gramatan Ave. Assoc. v State Div. of Human Rights,45 NY2d 176, 180 [1978]).
Here, even crediting the testimony of the Child Protective Services caseworker, thepetitioner's actions with respect to the subject child did not, under the circumstances here,constitute maltreatment (see Matter ofSenande v Carrion, 83 AD3d 851, 852 [2011]; Matter of Corey Mc. [Tanya Mc.], 67 AD3d 1015, 1016 [2009]; Matter of Chanika B., 60 AD3d671, 672 [2009]). Accordingly, the determination that the petitioner maltreated the subjectchild was not supported by substantial evidence (see Matter of Senande v Carrion, 83AD3d at 852; Matter of Natiello vCarrion, 73 AD3d 1070, 1071 [2010]). Furthermore, since the determination that thefather maltreated the other children was derivatively based on the maltreatment determinationwith respect to the subject child, that determination, too, is not supported by substantial evidence(cf. Matter of Amoreih S. [NicoleS.], 84 AD3d 1246, 1247-1248 [2011]; Matter of Christian O., 51 AD3d 402, 403 [2008]). Accordingly,the petition must be granted, the determination of the New York State Office of Children andFamily Services annulled, and the matter remitted to the New York State Office of Children andFamily Services to amend the indicated report to an unfounded report and to seal the amendedreport. Florio, J.P., Chambers, Hall and Miller, JJ., concur.