| Brown v Cope Bestway Express, Inc. |
| 2012 NY Slip Op 06772 [99 AD3d 746] |
| October 10, 2012 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| Jessica Brown, Respondent, v Cope Bestway Express, Inc.,et al., defendants, and Orcun Apak et al., Respondents. (Action No. 1.) Samantha Eisenberg,Appellant, v Cope Bestway Express, Inc., et al., Defendants, and Orcun Apak, et al.,Respondents. (Action No. 2.) |
—[*1] Morris & Morris, Rochester, N.Y. (Deborah M. Field of counsel), forplaintiff-respondent.
In an action to recover damages for personal injuries which was commenced in the SupremeCourt, Monroe County (action No. 1), and a related action to recover damages for personalinjuries which was commenced in the Supreme Court, Nassau County (action No. 2), SamanthaEisenberg, the plaintiff in action No. 2, appeals, as limited by her brief, from so much of an orderof the Supreme Court, Nassau County (Lally, J.), entered August 3, 2011, as granted that branchof the motion of Orcun Apak and Munur Apak, defendants in both actions, which was toconsolidate the actions, and thereupon transferred the consolidated action to Monroe County.
Ordered that the order is reversed insofar as appealed from, on the facts and in the exercise ofdiscretion, with costs, that branch of the motion of the defendants Orcun Apak and Munur Apakwhich was to consolidate the actions is denied except to the extent that the actions shall be triedjointly in the Supreme Court, Nassau County, and the Clerk of the Supreme Court, MonroeCounty, is directed to deliver to the Clerk of the Supreme Court, Nassau County, all papers filedin actions No. 1 and 2 and certified copies of all minutes and entries (see CPLR 511 [d]).
On February 12, 2010, in Rochester, New York, Jessica Brown and Samantha Eisenbergallegedly were injured when an automobile in which they were passengers collided with a truck.In September 2010, Brown commenced an action in the Supreme Court, Monroe County(hereinafter action No. 1), against the owner, the lessee, and the driver of the truck. In February2011, Eisenberg commenced an action in the Supreme Court, Nassau County (hereinafter actionNo. 2), against, among others, those parties and Orcun Apak and Munur Apak (hereinaftertogether the Apaks), the owner and driver of the vehicle in which she and Brown had beenpassengers. Subsequently, Brown amended her complaint to add the Apaks as party defendants.The Apaks moved to consolidate the two actions or for a joint trial, and to have venue placed inNassau County. The Supreme Court granted the Apaks' motion to the extent of consolidating thetwo actions, and thereupon transferred the consolidated action to Monroe County. Eisenbergappeals from so much of the order as granted that branch of the Apaks' motion which was toconsolidate the actions, and thereupon transferred the consolidated action to MonroeCounty.[*2]
"Where common questions of law or fact exist, a motion to consolidate or for a joint trialpursuant to CPLR 602 (a) should be granted absent a showing of prejudice to a substantial rightby the party opposing the motion" (Perini Corp. v WDF, Inc., 33 AD3d 605, 606 [2006]; see Alizio v Perpignano, 78 AD3d1087, 1088 [2010]; Mas-Edwards vUltimate Servs., Inc., 45 AD3d 540 [2007]). When consolidation or joint trials areordered under CPLR 602 (a), venue should generally be placed in the county where the firstaction was commenced (see Nigro vPickett, 39 AD3d 720, 722 [2007]). Special circumstances, however, may warrant thecourt, in its discretion, to place venue elsewhere (see Gomez v Jersey Coast EggProducers, 186 AD2d 629, 630 [1992]; cf. Moor v Moor, 39 AD3d 507, 508 [2007]; DeGregorio vDeGregorio, 251 AD2d 366, 366-367 [1998]).
It is undisputed that these two actions arose out of the same incident and involve commonquestions of law and fact. The Supreme Court properly found that the interests of justice andjudicial economy warranted relief under CPLR 602 (a). Nevertheless, inasmuch as it was notcontroverted that Eisenberg, who resides in Nassau County, suffered serious injuries that makeher unable to attend a trial in Monroe County, we conclude, in the exercise of our discretion, thatvenue should be placed in Nassau County (see Messina v Upper Hudson Primary Care Consortium, Inc., 26 AD3d698, 699 [2006]; DeGregorio v DeGregorio, 251 AD2d at 366-367). Moreover,because the two actions involve different plaintiffs, a joint trial, rather than consolidation, is theappropriate method of achieving the goal of avoiding the unnecessary duplication of proceedings(see Mas-Edwards v Ultimate Servs., Inc., 45 AD3d at 541; Perini Corp. v WDF,Inc., 33 AD3d at 606-607; T T Enters. v Gralnick, 127 AD2d 651, 652 [1987]).Finally, a joint trial of action No. 1 and action No. 2 will not prejudice any of Brown's substantialrights (see Whiteman v Parsons Transp.Group of N.Y., Inc., 72 AD3d 677, 678 [2010]). Dillon, J.P., Balkin, Belen and Austin,JJ., concur.