Matter of Braunstein v Board of Zoning Appeals of the Town ofCopake
2012 NY Slip Op 07255 [100 AD3d 1091]
November 1, 2012
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, December 26, 2012
As corrected through Wednesday, December 26, 2012


In the Matter of Michael Braunstein et al., Appellants, v Board ofZoning Appeals of the Town of Copake, Respondent.

—[*1]Nolan & Heller, LLP, Albany (John V. Hartzell of counsel), for appellants.

Tal G. Rappleyea, Valatie, for respondent.

Lahtinen, J. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (McGrath, J.), entered August 22,2011 in Columbia County, which dismissed petitioners' application, in a proceeding pursuant toCPLR article 78, to review a determination of respondent partially granting petitioners' requestfor several area variances.

Petitioners own 130 acres of real property adjacent to Copake Lake in the Town of Copake,Columbia County, including a 4½-acre island in the lake known as Mosquito Island. Theysought to divide the property into eight lots comprised of one 63-acre parcel with an existingconservation easement and no buildings, a parcel where they currently reside, and six residentialbuilding lots. One of the building lots (proposed lot six) included Mosquito Island as well as fiveacres on the mainland across a small channel from Mosquito Island. The plan for lot six was toconstruct a bridge to the island so that a house could be built there, and to include a septic systemthat would pump effluent off the island via a pipe along the bridge to a place on the mainlandmore than 150 feet from the lake. Petitioners also sought to put five docks on the lake withinabout 100 feet of the proposed bridge that would be a common area for the owners in thedevelopment.

The Zoning Code of the Town of Copake prohibited any development within 100 feet of thelake as well as the placement of a septic tank or tile field within 150 feet of the lake. Several[*2]area variances were thus necessary to construct the proposedproject. Petitioners applied to respondent for variances to, among other things, construct a roadand bridge connecting Mosquito Island to the mainland, place utilities and a septic pipe alongthat route, and install removable docks for the owners of the mainland lots and a walkway toaccess them. Following a public hearing, respondent denied petitioners' application with regardto the variances for lot six, including the proposed bridge and septic pipe. However, respondentapproved an area variance for the common area walkway and docks, subject to the conditionsthat only three docks be constructed and that they be placed no closer than 180 feet from themainland portion of lot six. Petitioners then commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding and,after joinder of issue, Supreme Court dismissed the petition. Petitioners appeal.

Initially, we are unpersuaded by petitioners' contention that respondent violated the OpenMeetings Law (see Public Officers Law art 7). Between the close of the public hearingand the public meeting the following month at which a determination was made, respondent'scounsel communicated individually with respondent's members and prepared a draft writtendetermination. At the public meeting, respondent reviewed the proposed draft, made changes andultimately made a determination. There is no evidence that a quorum of respondent's membersmet or consulted with its counsel outside a public meeting and, accordingly, the Open MeetingsLaw was not violated (see Public Officers Law §§ 102 [1], [2]; 103 [a]; Matter of Halperin v City of NewRochelle, 24 AD3d 768, 777-778 [2005], appeal dismissed 6 NY3d 890 [2006],lv denied 7 NY3d 708 [2006]; Matter of MCI Telecom. Corp. v Public Serv. Commn.of State of N.Y., 231 AD2d 284, 290-291 [1997]).

Petitioners argue that the record does not support respondent's denial of area variancesrelated to lot six. When addressing an application for an area variance, a zoning board of appealsis statutorily required to weigh the benefit to the applicant against the detriment to thecommunity and also to consider the following factors: "(1) whether an undesirable change will beproduced in the character of the neighborhood or a detriment to nearby properties will be createdby the granting of the area variance; (2) whether the benefit sought by the applicant can beachieved by some method, feasible for the applicant to pursue, other than an area variance; (3)whether the requested area variance is substantial; (4) whether the proposed variance will have anadverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood ordistrict; and (5) whether the alleged difficulty was self-created" (Town Law § 267-b [3]; see Matter of Pecoraro v Board of Appealsof Town of Hempstead, 2 NY3d 608, 612-613 [2004]; Matter of Mary T. Probst Family Trust vZoning Bd. of Appeals of Town of Horicon, 79 AD3d 1427, 1428 [2010], lvdenied 16 NY3d 708 [2011]). "[L]ocal zoning boards have broad discretion in consideringapplications for area variances and . . . [c]ourts may set aside a zoning boarddetermination only where the record reveals that the board acted illegally or arbitrarily, or abusedits discretion, or that it merely succumbed to generalized community pressure" (Matter ofPecoraro v Board of Appeals of Town of Hempstead, 2 NY3d at 613). Our review is limited,and the fact that we might have decided the application differently is of no moment (seeMatter of Cowan v Kern, 41 NY2d 591, 599 [1977]; Matter of Smelyansky v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of the Town ofBethlehem, 83 AD3d 1267, 1268 [2011]).

Respondent made detailed findings, addressed each of the statutory factors and engaged inthe requisite weighing of benefits versus detriments. Among other things, respondent found that abridge over the channel would prevent various longstanding recreational uses through thatportion of the lake; a home in full compliance with the pertinent setback requirements could beplaced on the mainland section of lot six (rather than on the island as proposed); the sought-after[*3]variances were substantial since they resulted in constructionto the water's edge and across water in full disregard of setback requirements; and severalsignificant environmental concerns were identified ranging from sand and salt in the wetlands asa result of winter road treatment to potential pollution from a failure of the proposed elaboratepiping/pumping accompanying a septic system on the island. The record reflects that respondentsufficiently considered and weighed the pertinent factors in reaching a decision that is notarbitrary or an abuse of its discretion.

Lastly, petitioners assert that respondent imposed improper conditions upon granting thevariance for the docks. Respondent conditioned the variance by limiting the number of docks tothree (rather than the five requested) and requiring that the docks be at least 180 feet from thenarrow channel. These conditions minimized the impact and interference on the lake caused bythe docks. Since these were reasonable conditions that were related to the underlying purpose ofthe zoning code (see Town Law § 267-b [4]; Matter of Zupa v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Town of Southold, 31 AD3d570, 571 [2006]), it was not improper for respondent to impose them.

Mercure, J.P., Rose, Kavanagh and Garry, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment is affirmed,without costs.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.