| Matter of Clean Water Advocates of N.Y., Inc. v New YorkState Dept. of Envtl. Conservation |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 01116 [103 AD3d 1006] |
| February 21, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of Clean Water Advocates of New York, Inc.,Appellant, v New York State Department of Environmental Conservation et al.,Respondents. |
—[*1] Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Andrew B. Ayers of counsel), forNew York State Department of Environmental Conservation, respondent. Manatt, Phelps & Phillips, LLP, New York City (Kenneth D. Friedman of counsel),for Wal-Mart Real Estate Business Trust and another, respondents.
Peters, P.J. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Teresi, J.), enteredOctober 4, 2011 in Albany County, which, in a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78,dismissed petitioner's application.
Petitioner, a not-for-profit corporation, commenced this CPLR article 78 proceedingchallenging a determination by respondent Department of Environmental Conservation(hereinafter DEC) to accept the stormwater pollution prevention plan (hereinafter SPPP)submitted by respondents Wal-Mart Real Estate Business Trust and Wal-Mart Stores,Inc. (hereinafter collectively referred to as Wal-Mart) in connection with its proposal toconstruct a Wal-Mart Supercenter in the Town of Lockport, Niagara County. SupremeCourt did not reach the merits of the petition, finding that petitioner lacked standing tomaintain the proceeding. Petitioner now appeals, and we affirm.[*2]
"For an organization to have standing to bring aCPLR article 78 proceeding challenging administrative decision making, it must showthat 'one or more of its members would have standing to sue[,] . . . that theinterests it asserts are germane to its purposes so as to satisfy the court that it is anappropriate representative of those interests . . . [and] that neither theasserted claim nor the appropriate relief requires the participation of the individualmembers' " (Matter of FingerLakes Zero Waste Coalition, Inc. v Martens, 95 AD3d 1420, 1421 [2012], lvdenied 19 NY3d 811 [2012], quoting Society of Plastics Indus. v County ofSuffolk, 77 NY2d 761, 775 [1991]). To establish standing, an individual mustdemonstrate an injury-in-fact that falls within the zone of interests protected by thepertinent statute (see New YorkState Assn. of Nurse Anesthetists v Novello, 2 NY3d 207, 211 [2004];Matter of Colella v Board of Assessors of County of Nassau, 95 NY2d 401,409-410 [2000]; Matter ofBrunswick Smart Growth, Inc. v Town of Brunswick, 73 AD3d 1267, 1268[2010]). Moreover, in matters involving land use development, it is incumbent upon theparty challenging the administrative determination to show that he or she will "sufferdirect harm, injury that is in some way different from that of the public at large"(Society of Plastics Indus. v County of Suffolk, 77 NY2d at 774; accord Matter of Save the PineBush, Inc. v Common Council of City of Albany, 13 NY3d 297, 304 [2009]; see Matter of VTR FV, LLC vTown of Guilderland, 101 AD3d 1532, 1533 [2012]).
Here, petitioner identified only one member of its organization, Joanne Woodhouse,in its attempt to establish standing. Woodhouse submitted an affidavit alleging that "[her]house is located within 900 feet of the [project site], 4 miles of the Tonawanda Creek,1.5 miles of the Erie Canal, 14 miles of Lake [Ontario] and 22 miles of the NiagaraRiver." We agree with Supreme Court that the proximity of Woodhouse's property to theproposed project does not, without more, give rise to a presumption that she would beadversely affected in a way different from the public at large (see e.g. Matter ofGallahan v Planning Bd. of City of Ithaca, 307 AD2d 684, 685 [2003], lvdenied 1 NY3d 501 [2003]; Matter of Oates v Village of Watkins Glen, 290AD2d 758, 760-761 [2002]; Matter of Buerger v Town of Grafton, 235 AD2d984, 985 [1997], lv denied 89 NY2d 816 [1997]; Matter of Burns Pharm. ofRensselaer v Conley, 146 AD2d 842, 844 [1989]). Indeed, Woodhouse did notarticulate any specific harm that she would suffer based on her proximity to the project,nor has petitioner submitted any proof establishing that DEC's acceptance of thechallenged SPPP will have any adverse environmental effects on the property of any ofits members (see Matter of Oates v Village of Watkins Glen, 290 AD2d at760-761).
Furthermore, petitioner has failed to demonstrate that the action will directly harmany of its members in their use and enjoyment of natural resources in some way differentin kind or degree from that of the public at large (see Matter of Save the Pine Bush,Inc. v Common Council of City of Albany, 13 NY3d at 304; Matter of FingerLakes Zero Waste Coalition, Inc. v Martens, 95 AD3d at 1422). In this regard, thepetition merely alleges, generally, that "[s]tormwater discharges from constructionactivity contribute to the increase of pollutants" in the Tonawanda Creek, the Erie Canal,Lake Ontario and the Niagara River. It does not allege that the specific SPPP at issuewould threaten those identified water sources in any particular way. In any event, anyclaim of environmentally-related injury to these water bodies as a result of DEC'sacceptance of the SPPP is devoid of evidentiary support and far too speculative andconjectural to demonstrate a specific injury-in-fact (see Matter of Powers v De Groodt, 43 AD3d 509, 513[2007]; Matter of New YorkPropane Gas Assn. v New York State Dept. of State, 17 AD3d 915, 916[2005]).
Moreover, petitioner has not shown that any injuries that its members would sufferdue [*3]to the alleged impacts to the water bodies wouldbe different from that faced by the general public. Although petitioner alleges that itsmembers use the water bodies for recreational purposes and as their potable water source,it does not allege, much less submit evidence, that any of its members do so any morefrequently than any other person with physical access to those same resources. It is nowsettled that standing to assert a claim based upon an impact upon a natural or culturalresource "requir[es] a demonstration that a[n individual's] use of a resource is more thanthat of the general public" (Matter of Save the Pine Bush, Inc. v Common Council ofCity of Albany, 13 NY3d at 306). As these generalized allegations do notdemonstrate an injury distinct from the general public in the area, they are insufficient toconfer standing (see Matter ofCitizens Emergency Comm. to Preserve Preserv. v Tierney, 70 AD3d 576,576-577 [2010], lv denied 15 NY3d 710 [2010]; Matter of Powers v DeGroodt, 43 AD3d at 513; Matter of Buerger v Town of Grafton, 235 AD2dat 985; Matter of Schulz v Warren County Bd. of Supervisors, 206 AD2d 672,674 [1994], lv denied 85 NY2d 805 [1995]; Matter of Otsego 2000 vPlanning Bd. of Town of Otsego, 171 AD2d 258, 260 [1991], lv denied 79NY2d 753 [1992]; compare Matter of Save the Pine Bush, Inc. v Common Councilof City of Albany, 13 NY3d at 305-306). Having failed to establish that any of itsmembers has standing to maintain this proceeding, petitioner also lacks standing andSupreme Court therefore properly dismissed the petition.
Stein, Garry and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment is affirmed, withoutcosts. [Prior Case History: 2011 NY Slip Op 32572(U).]