Martin v Hayes
2013 NY Slip Op 02804 [105 AD3d 1291]
April 25, 2013
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, May 29, 2013


Roger Martin, Appellant,
v
Theodore D. Hayes,Respondent.

—[*1]Law Office of Ronald R. Benjamin, Binghamton (Frederic E. Sober, BallstonSpa, of counsel), for appellant.

Levene, Gouldin & Thompson, LLP, Binghamton (Daniel R. Norton of counsel), forrespondent.

Mercure, J.P. Appeals (1) from an order of the Supreme Court (Sherman, J.), enteredMarch 14, 2012 in Tioga County, which, among other things, granted defendant's motionto dismiss the complaint, and (2) from an order of said court, entered April 26, 2012 inTioga County, which awarded defendant counsel fees.

Plaintiff and defendant live on two adjoining lots. Defendant and his deceased wifepreviously owned both lots, but sold them to defendant's stepdaughter, Marie NicoleFabi, with the intent of retaining a life estate in Lot 2. The language regarding the lifeestate, however, was mistakenly inserted into the deed for Lot 1. Plaintiff is Fabi'sparamour and resides with her on Lot 1. After his wife's death, defendant's relationshipwith Fabi and plaintiff became acrimonious. He alleges that after plaintiff trespassed onhis property numerous times, he contacted the State Police and reported the trespassingon October 5, 2011. Plaintiff commenced this action the next day, asserting a slanderclaim, and seeking punitive damages.

Defendant moved to dismiss the complaint, and requested an award of counsel feesand costs. Plaintiff cross-moved to amend the complaint, abandoning his claim soundingin slander and request for punitive damages, and seeking to assert a cause of action forprima facie tort. Noting plaintiff's concession that the original complaint failed to state acause of action for slander, Supreme Court granted defendant's motion to dismiss thecomplaint, denied plaintiff's [*2]cross motion to file anamended complaint and, upon finding plaintiff's conduct to be frivolous, granteddefendant's request for costs and counsel fees. In a subsequent order, the court directedplaintiff to pay $152.64 in costs and $4,296.64 in counsel fees. Plaintiff appeals fromboth orders.

Plaintiff argues that both the original complaint and the proposed amended complaintsufficiently state a claim for slander per se. A statement will fall into one of the fourcategories of slander per se when it is so noxious and injurious by nature that the lawpresumes that pecuniary damages will result and, thus, special damages need not bealleged (see Liberman v Gelstein, 80 NY2d 429, 434-435 [1992]; Yonaty v Mincolla, 97 AD3d141, 143-144 [2012], lv denied 20 NY3d 855 [2013]). As relevant here,"slander per se" includes "statements . . . charging [a] plaintiff with aserious crime," but "the law distinguishes between serious and relatively minor offenses,and only statements regarding the former are actionable without proof of damage"(Liberman v Gelstein, 80 NY2d at 435). Here, plaintiff argues that the complaintindicated that defendant falsely charged plaintiff with a class A misdemeanor, criminaltrespass in the second degree—i.e., "knowingly enter[ing] and remain[ing]unlawfully in a dwelling" (Penal Law § 140.15 [1]). On its face, however, thecomplaint asserts no more than an allegation that defendant falsely accused plaintiff ofsimple trespass—"knowingly enter[ing] or remain[ing] unlawfully in or uponpremises" (Penal Law § 140.05)—which is a violation and, thus, theallegation is not slanderous per se (see Liberman v Gelstein, 80 NY2d at 436; see also Cavallaro v Pozzi, 28AD3d 1075, 1077-1078 [2006]). That is, assuming without deciding that criminaltrespass in the second degree is a "serious crime," simple trespass is not.

In any event, even construing the complaint liberally and according plaintiff thebenefit of every favorable inference, it does not set forth the allegedly defamatorystatement with sufficient particularity to satisfy the requirement of CPLR 3016 (a), asplaintiff conceded before Supreme Court (see Dobies v Brefka, 273 AD2d 776,777-778 [2000], lv dismissed 95 NY2d 931 [2000]; Wadsworth vBeaudet, 267 AD2d 727, 729 [1999]). Thus, Supreme Court properly dismissed thecomplaint. Moreover, the court did not abuse its discretion in denying plaintiff's crossmotion to amend the complaint, which sought to abandon the slander claim and assertinstead a claim of prima facie tort. It is well settled that "[w]here relief may be affordedunder traditional tort concepts, prima facie tort may not be invoked as a basis to sustain apleading which otherwise fails to state a cause of action in conventional tort"(Freihofer v Hearst Corp., 65 NY2d 135, 143 [1985]; see Curiano vSuozzi, 63 NY2d 113, 118-119 [1984]; Morrison v Woolley, 45 AD3d 953, 954 [2007]; Lerwick v Kelsey, 24 AD3d931, 932 [2005], lv denied 6 NY3d 711 [2006]).

Notwithstanding the foregoing, we conclude that it is necessary to remit this action toSupreme Court because, in awarding counsel fees and costs, the court did not clearlyidentify which of plaintiff's "proposed actions" it found to be frivolous, the reasons whythe conduct was frivolous, or a justification for the amount of sanctions imposed (see Matter of Village of SaranacLake, 64 AD3d 958, 961 [2009]; cf. Shields v Carbone, 99 AD3d 1100, 1103 [2012]).Accordingly, we remit for clarification.

Lahtinen, McCarthy and Garry, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order entered March 14,2012 is modified, on the law, without costs, by reversing so much thereof as awardedcounsel fees, and, as so modified, affirmed. Ordered that the order entered April 26, 2012is reversed, on the law, without costs, and matter remitted to the Supreme Court forfurther proceedings not inconsistent with this Court's decision.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.