Matter of Hall v Dussault
2013 NY Slip Op 05651 [109 AD3d 679]
August 15, 2013
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, September 25, 2013


In the Matter of Geoffrey T. Hall, Appellant-Respondent, vDavid W. Dussault et al., Respondents-Appellants, et al., Respondents. (Proceeding No.1.) In the Matter of John Dellaratta et al., Appellants-Respondents,
v
David W.Dussault et al., Respondents-Appellants, et al., Respondents. (Proceeding No.2.)

—[*1]M. Joe Landry, Schenectady, for appellant-respondent andappellants-respondents.

Roemer, Wallens, Gold & Mineaux, LLP, Albany (Michael R. Cuevas of counsel),for respondents-appellants.

[*2]Per Curiam. Cross appeals from an order of theSupreme Court (Reilly Jr., J.), entered August 5, 2013 in Schenectady County, which,among other things, granted petitioners' applications, in two proceedings pursuant toElection Law § 16-102, to declare invalid the designating petition namingrespondents David W. Dussault and Michael T. Horan as Republican Party candidatesfor certain public offices in the Town of Niskayuna at the September 10, 2013 primaryelection.

The present proceedings were commenced in an effort to invalidate the designatingpetition of respondents David W. Dussault and Michael T. Horan (hereinaftercollectively referred to as the candidates), who are seeking the Republican Partynominations for the offices of, respectively, Member of Niskayuna Town Council andJustice of the Town of Niskayuna. The candidates argued that Supreme Court lackedpersonal jurisdiction in both proceedings, and unsuccessfully moved to dismiss thepetitions. Supreme Court thereafter invalidated the designating petition, but directedrespondent Schenectady County Board of Elections to give Republican Party voters anopportunity to ballot at the upcoming primary election. Petitioners in both proceedingsappeal, and the candidates cross-appeal.

Initially, the candidates were served in the manner directed by the orders to showcause, namely, express mail in proceeding No. 1 and residential delivery in proceedingNo. 2. As those methods were "reasonably calculated to give notice to the necessaryparties so that receipt of such notice would normally be expected within the statutory14-day period for commencing a proceeding concerning the validity of a designatingpetition," the candidates' motions to dismiss were properly denied (Matter of Elston vMahoney, 122 AD2d 969, 970 [1986], appeal dismissed, lvs denied 68NY2d 765 [1986]; see Matter of Contessa v McCarthy, 40 NY2d 890, 891[1976]; Matter of Rue v Hill, 287 AD2d 781, 782-783 [2001], lv denied97 NY2d 602 [2001]).

Turning to the merits, Supreme Court invalidated the designating petition due toerrors committed by two subscribing witnesses, thus invalidating the signatures they hadwitnessed and causing the petition to lack the requisite number of signatures. SupremeCourt further "order[ed] an opportunity to ballot, which is 'designed to give effect to theintention manifested by qualified party members to nominate some candidate, where thatintention would otherwise be thwarted by the presence of technical, but fatal defects indesignating petitions, leaving the political party without a designated candidate for agiven office' " (Matter ofLandry v Mansion, 65 AD3d 803, 805 [2009], quoting Matter of Harden vBoard of Elections in City of N.Y., 74 NY2d 796, 797 [1989]; see Matter of Bowen v UlsterCounty Bd. of Elections, 21 AD3d 693, 694-695 [2005], lv denied 5NY3d 706 [2005]).

The record establishes that one of the subscribing witnesses, a commissioner ofdeeds, failed to inform any of "the signers that, by signing the petition, they affirmed thetruth of the matter to which they subscribed" (Matter of Nolin v McNally, 87 AD3d 804, 806 [2011];see Election Law § 6-132 [3]; Matter of Caruso v Casciola, 27NY2d 657, 658 [1970]; Matter of Helfand v Meisser, 22 NY2d 762, 762-763[1968]). While the signatures collected by him were rendered invalid as a result, underthe circumstances presented here his failure constituted nothing more than a "technicalirregularity" (Matter of Caruso v Casciola, 27 NY2d at 658; see Matter ofNolin v McNally, 87 AD3d at 805-806; Matter of Bonner v Negron, 87 AD3d 737, 739-740[2011]).[*3]

The second subscribing witness, Horan,mistakenly executed the statement intended for a notary public or commissioner of deedsrather than that meant for party members. While Horan is in fact a notary public, he didnot identify himself as such in the witness statement (see Election Law §6-132 [3]; Matter of Fuentes v Lopez, 264 AD2d 490, 490 [1999]). Thesignatures that Horan witnessed were rendered invalid as a result, but his failure toindicate his position was a technical defect that did "not call into serious question theexistence of adequate support among eligible voters" (Matter of Harden v Board ofElections in City of N.Y., 74 NY2d at 797; compare Matter of Maresca vAlbanese, 153 AD2d 719, 720 [1989], lv denied 74 NY2d 609 [1989]).Absent any indication that fraud was involved or that the voters who signed the invalidpages were not entitled to sign the petition, Supreme Court properly directed anopportunity to ballot for the offices of Member of Niskayuna Town Council and Justiceof the Town of Niskayuna (see Matter of Landry v Mansion, 65 AD3d at805-806; compare Matter of Bowen v Ulster County Bd. of Elections, 21 AD3dat 695). We do note, however, that the opportunity to ballot should be used to select onlyone candidate for the office of Member of Niskayuna Town Council—despite thefact that two seats on the council are open—as the invalidated petition manifestedan intent to nominate only one candidate (see Matter of Hunting v Power, 20NY2d 680, 681 [1967]; Matter of Hochberg v D'Apice, 112 AD2d 1067, 1068[1985], affd for reasons stated below 65 NY2d 960 [1985]). As such, the orderwill be modified accordingly. The remaining arguments of the parties, to the extent theyare properly before us, have been considered and rejected.

Peters, P.J., McCarthy, Garry and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the order ismodified, on the facts, without costs, by directing that respondent Schenectady CountyBoard of Elections provide registered voters of the Republican Party with an opportunityto ballot for only one candidate for the office of Member of Niskayuna Town Council atthe September 10, 2013 primary election, and, as so modified, affirmed.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.