| Penavic v Penavic |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 05738 [109 AD3d 648] |
| August 28, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| Silvana Penavic, Appellant, v Kresimir Penavic,Respondent. |
—[*1] Schlissel Ostrow Karabatos, PLLC, Garden City, N.Y. (Neil S. Cohen, HillaryReinharz, and Stephen W. Schlissel of counsel), for respondent.
In a matrimonial action in which the parties were divorced by judgment enteredOctober 22, 2009, which incorporated, but did not merge, the terms of the parties'stipulations of settlement dated November 18, 2008, and June 22, 2009, the plaintiffappeals, as limited by her brief, from so much of an order of the Supreme Court, SuffolkCounty (Bivona, J.), dated March 15, 2012, as denied, without a hearing, that branch ofher motion which was pursuant to Judiciary Law § 756 to hold the defendant incivil contempt of the judgment of divorce and the parties' stipulation of settlement datedJune 22, 2009, and denied, with leave to renew, that branch of the same motion whichwas for an award of an attorney's fee in the sum of $5,000.
Ordered that the order is affirmed insofar as appealed from, with costs.
The plaintiff contends that the Supreme Court improvidently exercised its discretionin denying that branch of her motion which was pursuant to Judiciary Law § 756to hold the defendant in civil contempt of a judgment of divorce entered October 22,2009, and the parties' stipulation of settlement dated June 22, 2009, relating to financialissues. Specifically, she alleges that the defendant violated article XII (2) of the subjectstipulation when, subsequent to the divorce, he increased the balance of an outstandinghome equity line of credit (hereinafter HELOC) on the former marital residence, whichwas in both of their names. Pursuant to that provision, the defendant agreed that he "shallnot incur or cause to be incurred any debt or liability . . . upon the credit ofthe [plaintiff] for which the [plaintiff] . . . may be or become liable." Thedefendant further agreed to hold the plaintiff harmless and to indemnify her against anysuch debts, liabilities, and obligations incurred by him for his benefit, including anyreasonable attorneys' fees which may be incurred by the plaintiff in connection with anybreach by the defendant of this provision. The plaintiff also contends that the SupremeCourt improvidently exercised its discretion in denying, with leave to renew, that branchof her motion which was for an award of an attorney's fee in the sum of $5,000, anexpense incurred by her because of the defendant's alleged breach in connection with theHELOC.[*2]
At the time the parties entered into the subjectstipulation, they acknowledged that the outstanding balance of the HELOC wasapproximately $25,000. After the plaintiff made a prior motion, inter alia, to hold thedefendant in civil contempt of the judgment of divorce and the subject stipulation, shelearned that the defendant had increased the outstanding balance of the HELOC to$750,000 when he disclosed this fact in his affidavit in opposition to her motion. Theplaintiff's motion was denied, and this Court affirmed that determination, concluding thatthe defendant had no obligation, under the terms of the subject stipulation, to close theHELOC or remove her name from it (see Penavic v Penavic, 88 AD3d 671, 672-673 [2011]).Thereafter, the plaintiff moved, inter alia, to hold the defendant in civil contempt of thejudgment of divorce and subject stipulation due to his increase in the balance of theHELOC, which was determined in the order appealed from.
"A motion to punish a party for civil contempt is addressed to the sound discretion ofthe motion court" (Chambers vOld Stone Hill Rd. Assoc., 66 AD3d 944, 946 [2009]; see Matter of Hughes vKameneva, 96 AD3d 845, 846 [2012]; Matter of Philie v Singer, 79 AD3d 1041, 1042 [2010])."Civil contempt 'has as its aim the vindication of a private party to litigation[,]' andincludes as its elements knowledge of the order and prejudice to the rights of a party tothe litigation" (Dalessio vKressler, 6 AD3d 57, 65 [2004], quoting McCain v Dinkins, 84 NY2d216, 226 [1994]; see Matter ofRubackin v Rubackin, 62 AD3d 11, 18 [2009]). Thus, "[a]ny penalty imposed isdesigned not to punish but, rather, to compensate the injured private party or to coercecompliance with the court's mandate or both" (Matter of Department of Envtl.Protection of City of N.Y. v Department of Envtl. Conservation of State of N.Y., 70NY2d 233, 239 [1987]; seeTown Bd. of Town of Southampton v R.K.B. Realty, LLC, 91 AD3d 628,630-631 [2012]). The movant has the burden of proving the contempt by clear andconvincing evidence (see Matter of Philie v Singer, 79 AD3d at 1042;Chambers v Old Stone Hill Rd. Assoc., 66 AD3d at 946; Matter of Rothschild vEdwards, 63 AD3d 744, 745 [2009]; Galanos v Galanos, 46 AD3d 507, 508 [2007]; Vujovic v Vujovic, 16 AD3d490, 491 [2005]).
Here, the Supreme Court providently exercised its discretion in denying that branchof the plaintiff's motion which was to hold the defendant in civil contempt, since shefailed to prove by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant's violation of thesubject stipulation prejudiced her. During the pendency of the subject motion, thedefendant paid $725,000 on the HELOC, thereby reducing the balance to what it hadbeen when the parties entered into the subject stipulation. In addition, the plaintiffacknowledges that the defendant's ability to use the HELOC had been suspended and thatshe may be able to secure her own credit. Further, the letter the plaintiff submitted fromanother bank indicating that she had been conditionally approved for a line of credit onher own home on the condition that the HELOC was closed did not demonstrate that theplaintiff's application for credit was declined due to the outstanding amount owed on theHELOC.
The Supreme Court providently exercised its discretion in denying that branch of theplaintiff's motion which was for an attorney's fee in the sum of $5,000 with leave torenew upon the submission of proper papers (cf. Garcia v Garcia, 104 AD3d 806 [2013]). Dillon, J.P.,Chambers, Austin and Hinds-Radix, JJ., concur.