| Askin v Department of Educ. of the City of N.Y. |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 06991 [110 AD3d 621] |
| October 29, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
| Michelle Askin, Appellant, v Department ofEducation of the City of New York, Respondent, et al.,Defendant. |
—[*1] Michael A. Cardozo, Corporation Counsel, New York (Ronald E. Sternberg ofcounsel), for respondent.
Order, Supreme Court, New York County (Arthur F. Engoron, J.), entered June 15,2012, which, insofar as appealed from as limited by the briefs, granteddefendants-respondents' motion to dismiss the complaint as against them, unanimouslyaffirmed, without costs.
Plaintiff alleges that, during the relevant period of the 2010-2011 school year, shewas 54 years old and serving as the principal of a school she had founded. She receivedsatisfactory performance reviews for two years, but claims to have been subjected tounfair and excessive scrutiny and reprimands during 2010 to 2011, including aninvestigation into allegations of misconduct. Plaintiff was terminated in June 2011. It isundisputed that, by these allegations, plaintiff has established the first three elements ofher claims for age discrimination under the New York State and City Human RightsLaws (HRL) (Executive Law art 15; Administrative Code of City of NY § 8-101et seq.), since she was a member of a protected class, was qualified for herposition, and was subjected to an adverse employment action (see Melman v Montefiore Med.Ctr., 98 AD3d 107, 113 [1st Dept 2012]; Bennett v Health Mgt. Sys., Inc., 92 AD3d 29, 35 [1st Dept2011], lv denied 18 NY3d 811 [2012]).
Construing the complaint liberally, presuming its factual allegations to be true, andaccording the complaint the benefit of every possible favorable inference (see 511 W.232nd Owners Corp. v Jennifer Realty Co., 98 NY2d 144, 151-152 [2002]), plaintiffhas not, however, adequately pled the fourth element of a prima facie claim ofemployment discrimination under the State and City HRL, namely, that she was eitherterminated or treated differently under circumstances giving rise to an inference ofdiscrimination (see Melman, 98 AD3d at 113; Bennett, 92 AD3d at 35).Although plaintiff asserts that defendants' actions were motivated by age-related bias, shedoes not make any concrete factual allegation in support of that claim, other than that shewas 54 years old and was treated adversely under the State law or less well under the CityHRL. Plaintiff's allegations in this respect amount to mere legal conclusions, and do notsuffice to make out this element of her claim (see Ortiz v City of New York, 105 AD3d 674 [1st [*2]Dept 2013]; McKenzie v Meridian Capital Group, LLC, 35 AD3d 676[2d Dept 2006]; see also Clyburn v Shields, 33 Fed Appx 552, 555-556 [2d Cir2002]).
Plaintiff's failure to adequately plead discriminatory animus is similarly fatal to herclaims of hostile work environment (see Chin v New York City Hous. Auth., 106 AD3d 443,445 [1st Dept 2013]) and violation of the New York State Constitution's equal protectionand antidiscrimination provisions (see NY Const, art I, § 11; Bower Assoc. v Town of PleasantVal., 2 NY3d 617, 631 [2004]). Concur—Friedman, J.P., Sweeny, Acostaand Manzanet-Daniels, JJ.