| Matter of Mowry v DiNapoli |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 07794 [111 AD3d 1117] |
| November 21, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of John M. Mowry,Petitioner, v Thomas P. DiNapoli, as State Comptroller, et al.,Respondents. |
—[*1] Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (William E. Storrs of counsel), forrespondents.
Spain, J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by orderof the Supreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review a determination ofrespondent Comptroller which denied petitioner's application for salary and servicecredits.
Petitioner was hired as the attorney for the Mexico Central School District in 1974and served in that capacity until his retirement in 2002. Similarly, petitioner served as theattorney for the Village of Mexico during roughly that same time frame. During theseperiods, petitioner also served as an attorney for other public entities and maintained aprivate law practice. In 2010, eight years after his retirement, petitioner received a letterdetermination from respondent New York State and Local Retirement System informinghim that, based upon a review of petitioner's relationship with both the school district andthe Village, he had incorrectly been reported as an employee, rather than as anindependent contractor. Accordingly, both petitioner's salary and credited service werebeing removed from his records and, as a result, his annual benefit amount had beenreduced and he was responsible for over $162,000 in overpayments and arrears.Following a hearing, the Hearing Officer determined that petitioner failed to sustain hisburden of proof that he was an employee of the school district or the Village, and deniedhis application for salary and service credits. Respondent Comptroller accepted theHearing Officer's findings and conclusions, prompting petitioner to commence thisCPLR article 78 proceeding.[*2]
Where professional services are involved, theabsence of direct control is not dispositive of the existence of an employer-employeerelationship (see Matter of Myron Goldstein, P. C. [Roberts], 61 NY2d 937[1984]; Matter of Ianniello [Sweeney], 238 AD2d 661, 661 [1997]). Rather, suchan employment relationship may be evidenced by "control over important aspects of theservices performed other than results or means" (Matter of ConcourseOphthalmology Assoc. [Roberts], 60 NY2d 734, 736 [1983]; see Matter of Empire State Towing& Recovery Assn., Inc. [Commissioner of Labor], 15 NY3d 433, 437-438[2010]; Matter of Parisi[Commissioner of Labor], 54 AD3d 456, 457 [2008]), i.e., "over-all control issufficient to establish the employee relationship where [professional] work is concerned"(Matter of Salamanca Nursing Home [Roberts], 68 NY2d 901, 903 [1986];see Matter of Boone [Shore Rd. Community Serv.—Sweeney], 245 AD2d617, 618-619 [1997]). In our view, the Comptroller's determination that petitioner wasnot an employee of the school district is not supported by substantial evidence.
Here, both the school board president and the assistant superintendent testified thatthe school board routinely engaged in discussions about whether to retain petitioner'sservices as an employee or an independent contractor, and the board continually chosethe former because it was more cost effective for the school district. The testimony alsoindicated that, although there was no written contract with petitioner, the board and theassistant superintendent directed petitioner as to what work needed to be completed andwhen services were to be performed, the assistant superintendent and board reviewedpetitioner's work for its sufficiency and the president monitored petitioner's performanceand conducted annual performance evaluations. Additionally, both the testimony anddocumentary evidence indicated that petitioner was a salaried employee paid every twoweeks by paycheck, from which income taxes, Social Security, Medicare and healthinsurance premiums were deducted, and petitioner received a W-2 form annually.Further, petitioner's appointment as an employee of the school district was recognized bythe County Department of Civil Service as a "School Attorney"—an exemptposition—at a salary in 1974 of $3,400 per year. Petitioner took an oath of officeannually and the school district maintained a personnel file on him. Significantly,although petitioner did not have set hours, the assistant superintendent testified that hewas available on an as-needed basis and, even if petitioner did not perform work for theschool district during a pay period, he would receive a paycheck for that periodnonetheless. Although petitioner chose to use his own law office and staff, which wereabout two blocks from the school district office, the competent testimony established thatoffice space, office equipment, clerical staff and supplies were available to petitionerthrough the school district when needed, and they were used by him from time to time,usually on meeting days.
To the extent that any of this evidence was rebutted, the Retirement System relied onthe testimony of the school district treasurer, who admittedly only occasionally workedwith petitioner. Furthermore, she testified that she had no knowledge about howpetitioner received work assignments, the nature of his work duties or his relationshipwith either the school board or the superintendent, or whether he was ever evaluated.While the Retirement System also relied on a questionnaire completed by the schooldistrict, we note that the majority of the information supplied on the form came from thetreasurer, with the balance being supplied by another former school board president whodid not testify and whose term of service and basis of knowledge regarding petitioner'sengagement with the school district were not established. As such, we cannot concludethat the Comptroller's determination with respect to the school district was supported bysubstantial evidence (see Matter of Empire State Towing & Recovery Assn., Inc.[Commissioner of Labor], 15 NY3d at 437-438; compare Matter of [*3]Handley vNew York State Teachers' Retirement Sys., 74 AD3d 1384, 1386-1387 [2010];Matter of Fernandez v NewYork State & Local Retirement Sys., 17 AD3d 921, 922 [2005], lvdenied 5 NY3d 707 [2005]; Matter of Young v McCall, 253 AD2d 997,997-998 [1998]; Matter of Mancuso v Regan, 190 AD2d 948, 948-949 [1993];Matter of Brosnahan v New York State Employees' Retirement Sys., 174 AD2d954, 956 [1991], lv denied 78 NY2d 858 [1991]).
We reach a different conclusion, however, with regard to petitioner's relationshipwith the Village. Petitioner admitted that he served in the capacity of Village Attorney asan independent contractor prior to 1994, and that he was thereafter placed on the payrollpursuant to his request, for the sole purpose of accruing retirement benefits. Testimonyfrom the village clerk treasurer indicated that there was no reason for the change instatus other than petitioner's request and that, other than the fact that his pay was reportedto the Retirement System, there was no substantive change in petitioner's relationship tothe Village (see Matter of Young v McCall, 253 AD2d at 997-998). The labelassigned by the parties to the employment relationship between them is not determinativeof whether an employer-employee relationship or independent contractor status exists(see Matter of Handley v New York State Teachers' Retirement Sys., 74 AD3d at1385-1386) and, upon application of the relevant factors, we find substantial evidence tosupport the Comptroller's determination that petitioner was an independent contractorand not an employee of the Village (see Matter of Fernandez v New York State &Local Retirement Sys., 17 AD3d at 922; Matter of Young v McCall, 253AD2d at 998; Matter of Mancuso v Regan, 190 AD2d at 949).
Lastly, we reject petitioner's contention that the determination was barred by lachesbased on the unreasonable and inexcusable delay. The Comptroller is statutorily requiredto correct errors in the retirement benefit records and adjust payments accordingly toensure the integrity of the public retirement system (see Retirement and SocialSecurity Law § 111 [c]; DiNapoli v Town of New Scotland, 90 AD3d 1401, 1402 n2 [2011]; Matter of Blais v NewYork State Teachers' Retirement Sys., 68 AD3d 1266, 1268 [2009]).
Lahtinen, J.P., Stein and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination ismodified, without costs, by annulling so much thereof as determined that petitioner wasnot an employee of the Mexico Central School District; petition granted to that extentand matter remitted to respondent Comptroller for further proceedings not inconsistentwith this Court's decision; and, as so modified, confirmed.