| Matter of Cappello (ELRAC LLC—Commissioner ofLabor) |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 00265 [113 AD3d 952] |
| January 16, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
| In the Matter of the Claim of Christine M. Cappello,Respondent. ELRAC LLC, Appellant; Commissioner of Labor,Respondent. |
—[*1] Cynthia Feathers, Glens Falls, for Christine M. Cappello, respondent.
Appeal from a decision of the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Board, filed May 11,2012, which ruled that claimant was entitled to receive unemployment insurance benefits.
From August 2007 until March 2011, claimant worked as a station manager for a carrental company at a major airport. On December 26, 2010, following an extensivesnowstorm that disrupted public transportation, claimant's manager authorized her to renta sports utility vehicle at a discounted rate so that she could drive to her home, butexpected her to return the vehicle on December 30, 2010 when she reported to work. Shereturned the vehicle when she arrived at work on December 30, 2010, but when itbecame apparent that she did not have a ride home, she had one of her employees extendthe rental contract at the discounted rate. She later had another employee extend thecontract for additional days at the discounted rate. Claimant returned the vehicle andended the rental on January 14, 2011. As the result of an audit report prepared on January17, 2011, the employer discovered that claimant had the rental contract extended at thediscounted rate by having other employees perform the transactions on the computer. Theemployer investigated the incident and, upon concluding that claimant violated theemployer's policy and committed theft, discharged her on March 4, 2011. Claimant wasinitially disqualified from receiving unemployment insurance benefits on the ground thatshe lost her employment through misconduct, and this decision was upheld by anAdministrative Law Judge following a hearing. The Unemployment Insurance AppealBoard, however, reversed this decision and found that claimant was entitled to receivebenefits. The employer now appeals.[*2]
The Board concluded that claimant did not loseher employment due to misconduct because the employer delayed in terminating her afterlearning of her actions and did not provide a reasonable excuse for the delay. We find,however, that this conclusion is not supported by the record. The employer became awareof claimant's inappropriate conduct on January 17, 2011 and immediately proceeded toconduct an investigation, obtaining a statement from one employee on January 21, 2011.Although claimant was apparently absent from work for a week in February 2011, theemployer obtained a statement from her on February 23, 2011 as part of its continuinginvestigation. The employer discharged claimant less than two weeks later. Under thecircumstances presented, we do not find that the employer engaged in an inordinate delayin terminating claimant such that it could not rely upon her misconduct as the reason forher discharge.
It is well settled that an employee's dishonesty or failure to comply with anemployer's policy and procedures constitutes disqualifying misconduct (see Matter of Jenkins[Commissioner of Labor], 109 AD3d 1073, 1073 [2013]; Matter of Farnsworth [EllisHosp.—Commissioner of Labor], 108 AD3d 1008, 1009 [2013]). Here,the evidence is undisputed that claimant violated the employer's policy governingemployee rentals by having other employees complete rental contracts for her at anunauthorized discounted rate. Given claimant's misconduct, substantial evidence does notsupport the Board's decision that she was entitled to receive benefits (see Matter of Brown [Lincoln Ctr.for the Performing Arts, Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 83 AD3d 1231,1232 [2011]; Matter of Takser[New York Compensation Ins. Rating Bd.—Commissioner of Labor], 63AD3d 1478, 1480 [2009], lv dismissed 13 NY3d 810 [2009]). Therefore, itsdecision must be reversed.
Peters, P.J., Lahtinen, McCarthy and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the decisionis reversed, without costs, and matter remitted to the Unemployment Insurance AppealBoard for further proceedings not inconsistent with this Court's decision.