| Matter of Hart v Town Bd. of Town of Huntington |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 00665 [114 AD3d 680] |
| February 5, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| In the Matter of Seth Hart et al.,Appellants, v Town Board of Town of Huntington et al., Respondents, et al.,Respondent. |
—[*1] James F. Matthews, Huntington, N.Y., for respondents Town Board of the Town ofHuntington, consisting of Frank P. Petrone, Susan A. Berland, Mark A. Cuthbertson,Glenda A. Jackson, and Mark Mayoka, Town of Huntington, and Department ofPlanning and Environment for the Town of Huntington. Berkman, Henoch, Peterson, Peddy & Fenchel, P.C., Garden City, N.Y. (Joseph E.Macy of counsel), for respondent Triangle Equities 496 W. Jericho Turnpike,LLC.
In a hybrid proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review two determinations ofthe Town Board of the Town of Huntington, both dated January 11, 2011, approvingResolution 2011-31, which adopted a Findings Statement pursuant to the New YorkState Environmental Quality Review Act (ECL art 8) and Resolution 2011-32, whichenacted Local Law Introductory No. 7-2010 of the Town of Huntington so as to rezonecertain real property, respectively, and action for a judgment declaring, inter alia, thatLocal Law Introductory No. 7-2010 of the Town of Huntington constitutes illegal spotzoning, was not enacted in accordance with a comprehensive municipal land-use plan,and was otherwise illegal, the petitioners/plaintiffs appeal from (1) an order of theSupreme Court, Suffolk County (Leis III, J.), dated February 27, 2012, which denied thepetition and granted the motion of the respondents/defendants Town Board of the Townof Huntington, consisting of Frank P. Petrone, Susan A. Berland, Mark A. Cuthbertson,Glenda A. Jackson, and Mark Mayoka, the Town of Huntington, and the Department ofPlanning and Environment for the Town of Huntington, and the separate motion of therespondent/defendant Triangle Equities 496 W. Jericho Turnpike, LLC, for summaryjudgment in connection with the third cause of action, which sought declaratory relief,and (2) a judgment of the same court entered May 18, 2012, which upon the order, is infavor of the respondents/defendants Town Board of the Town of Huntington, consistingof Frank P. Petrone, Susan A. Berland, Mark A. Cuthbertson, Glenda A. Jackson, andMark Mayoka, the Town of Huntington, the Department of Planning and Environmentfor the Town of Huntington, and Triangle Equities 496 W. Jericho Turnpike, LLC, andagainst them dismissing the petition/complaint.
Ordered that the appeal from the order is dismissed; and it is further,[*2]
Ordered that the judgment is modified, on thelaw, (1) by deleting the provision thereof dismissing the third cause of action, and (2) byadding thereto a provision declaring that Local Law Introductory No. 7-2010 of theTown of Huntington does not constitute illegal spot zoning, was enacted in accordancewith a comprehensive municipal land-use plan, and is not otherwise illegal; as somodified, the judgment is affirmed; and it is further,
Ordered that one bill of costs is awarded to the respondents/defendants Town Boardof the Town of Huntington, consisting of Frank P. Petrone, Susan A. Berland, Mark A.Cuthbertson, Glenda A. Jackson, and Mark Mayoka, the Town of Huntington, and theDepartment of Planning and Environment for the Town of Huntington, and to therespondent/defendant Triangle Equities 496 W. Jericho Turnpike, LLC, appearingseparately and filing separate briefs, payable by the petitioners/plaintiffs.
The appeal from the order must be dismissed because the right of direct appeal fromso much of the order as granted the motion of the several respondents/defendants forsummary judgment in connection with the third cause of action terminated with the entryof judgment in the action (see Matter of Aho, 39 NY2d 241, 248 [1976]), andbecause there is no right of appeal from an interlocutory order entered in a proceedingpursuant to CPLR article 78 (see CPLR 5701 [b] [1]). The issues raised on theappeal from the order are brought up for review and have been considered on the appealfrom the judgment (see CPLR 5501 [a] [1]).
This dispute arises out of the rezoning of a parcel of real property in the Town ofHuntington (hereinafter the Town) from an R-40 district, which permits the constructionof one single-family residence per acre, to an R-RM Retirement Community District. Thepetitioners/plaintiffs (hereinafter the petitioners) acknowledged that the subject property,although zoned R-40, was operated for many years as a nonconforming horse farm andstables, which included businesses such as tree cutting, woodchipping, and woodcarving, and was occupied by numerous nonconforming structures.
Triangle Equities 496 W. Jericho Turnpike, LLC (hereinafter Triangle), proposed theconstruction of 66 townhouses on the subject property, as part of a larger projectconsisting of a total of 80 townhouses and 3 single-family homes. Triangle proposed toerect 14 of the townhouses and the 3 single-family homes on adjoining parcels in theTown of Oyster Bay. Nine of the units were to be classified as affordable housing.
In December 2008, while Triangle's application to rezone was pending and the Townwas conducting an environmental assessment with respect to the impact of Triangle'sproposed project, the Town Board of the Town of Huntington (hereinafter the Board)adopted a master plan denominated as the Horizons 2020 Comprehensive Plan Update(hereinafter the Master Plan), which urged the preservation of open spaces while"promoting a more diverse housing stock affordable to all income groups." Thepetitioners note that the subject property was listed as an "Open Space Index Parcel" inthe 1974 Town of Huntington Open Space Index Report. However, in 2007, theHuntington Environmental Open Space Advisory Committee visited the site, noted thatits natural features had been disturbed, and determined that the Town should not pursuethe acquisition of the property for parkland.
In January 2011, after conducting a public hearing on the matter and after issuance ofthe Final Environmental Impact Statement pursuant to the State Environmental QualityReview Act (ECL art 8; hereinafter SEQRA), the Board approved Triangle's application.Shortly thereafter, the petitioners, who had opposed the project from its inception,commenced this hybrid proceeding and action against the Board, the Town, and theDepartment of Planning and Environment for the Town (hereinafter collectively theTown respondents) and Triangle. Pursuant to the first and second causes of action, thepetitioners sought review, pursuant to CPLR article 78, of the resolutions thatrespectively adopted a Findings Statement pursuant to SEQRA and rezoned the subjectproperty. In a third cause of action, they sought a judgment declaring, inter alia, that therezoning constituted illegal spot zoning and was not accomplished in accordance with acomprehensive municipal land-use plan.[*3]
The Town respondents and Triangle separatelymoved for judgment in their favor on the merits in connection with the first two causes ofaction, which sought relief pursuant to CPLR article 78, and for summary judgment inconnection with the third cause of action, which sought a declaratory judgment. TheSupreme Court granted the motions, and the petitioners appeal.
A party challenging the determination of a local governmental board bears the heavyburden of showing that the target regulation " 'is not justified under the police power ofthe state by any reasonable interpretation of the facts' " (Matter of Town of Bedford vVillage of Mount Kisco, 33 NY2d 178, 186 [1973], quoting Shepard v Village ofSkaneateles, 300 NY 115, 118 [1949]). If the validity of the legislative classificationfor zoning purposes is even "fairly debatable," it must be sustained upon judicial review(see Matter of Town of Bedford v Village of Mount Kisco, 33 NY2d at 186;Taylor v Incorporated Vil. of Head of Harbor, 104 AD2d 642, 645 [1984])."Thus, when a plaintiff fails to establish a clear conflict with the comprehensive plan, thezoning classification must be upheld" (Infinity Consulting Group, Inc. v Town of Huntington, 49AD3d 813, 814 [2008]; seeNicholson v Incorporated Vil. of Garden City, 112 AD3d 893 [2013]).
In the instant case, in opposition to the prima facie showing of the Town respondentsand Triangle, the petitioners failed to raise a triable issue of fact as to whether there was aclear conflict between the rezoning and the Master Plan. The Master Plan outlined anumber of concerns and goals, one of which was to retain the low-density, village-likecharacter of the Town. However, the Master Plan also detailed additional goals inrecognition of the fact that the demographics of the Town's population were changing,such as the need for a diverse housing stock, the need for senior housing, the need foraffordable housing, and the need to preserve open spaces. Although the proposeddevelopment will likely increase the density of the neighborhood, it also will preserve asizable portion of the property as open land, provide senior housing, and provide anumber of affordable units. Thus, the determination to rezone the subject property was incompliance with the overall policies outlined in the Master Plan, and it does notconstitute impermissible spot zoning (see Taylor v Incorporated Vil. of Head ofHarbor, 104 AD2d at 645).
The petitioners' remaining contentions, including those addressed to the Townrespondents' compliance with SEQRA, are without merit.
Since this is, in part, a declaratory judgment action, the judgment should haveincluded a provision declaring that Local Law Introductory No. 7-2010 of the Town ofHuntington does not constitute illegal spot zoning, was enacted in accordance with theMaster Plan, and is not otherwise illegal (see 200 Genesee St. Corp. v City of Utica, 6 NY3d 761[2005]; Lanza v Wagner, 11 NY2d 317, 334 [1962], appeal dismissed371 US 74 [1962], cert denied 371 US 901 [1962]). Balkin, J.P., Chambers,Lott and Hinds-Radix, JJ., concur.