| Nicholson v Incorporated Vil. of Garden City |
| 2013 NY Slip Op 08600 [112 AD3d 893] |
| December 26, 2013 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
| Michael Nicholson, Esq., et al.,Respondents, v Incorporated Village of Garden City et al.,Appellants. |
—[*1] Michael Nicholson, Garden City, N.Y., and Diana L. Nicholson, Garden City, N.Y.,respondents pro se (one brief filed).
In a hybrid action for a judgment declaring, among other things, that Local Law No.4-2009 of the Village of Garden City is unconstitutional and proceeding pursuant toCPLR article 78 to review a determination of the Board of Trustees of IncorporatedVillage of Garden City dated August 13, 2009, resolving to enact Local Law No. 4-2009of the Village of Garden City, the defendants/respondents appeal, as limited by theirbrief, from so much of an order of the Supreme Court, Nassau County (Phelan, J.),entered March 27, 2012, as denied that branch of their motion which was for summaryjudgment, in effect, declaring that Local Law No. 4-2009 of the Village of Garden City isnot unconstitutional, and granted that branch of the plaintiffs/petitioners' cross motionwhich was for summary judgment, in effect, declaring that Local Law No. 4-2009 of theVillage of Garden City is unconstitutional.
Ordered that the order is reversed insofar as appealed from, on the law, with costs,that branch of the appellants' motion which was for summary judgment, in effect,declaring that Local Law No. 4-2009 of the Village of Garden City is notunconstitutional is granted, that branch of the plaintiffs/petitioners' cross motion whichwas for summary judgment, in effect, declaring that Local Law No. 4-2009 of the Villageof Garden City is unconstitutional is denied, and the matter is remitted to the SupremeCourt, Nassau County, for further proceedings, including the entry of a judgment, interalia, declaring that Local Law No. 4-2009 of the Village of Garden City is notunconstitutional.
Local Law No. 4-2009 of the Village of Garden City (hereinafter the local law)rezoned corner lots on four avenues in the Central Section of the Village of Garden Cityfrom R-20, a residential zoning classification requiring a minimum lot size of 20,000square feet, to R-20C, a residential zoning classification prohibiting subdivision unlessthe resulting corner lot has a minimum lot size of 40,000 square feet. The local lawapplies to a 62,500-square-foot corner lot owed by the plaintiffs/petitioners (hereinafterthe plaintiffs).
Initially, since the plaintiffs are mounting a facial attack on the constitutionality ofthe local law by virtue of the declaratory judgment causes of action set forth in thecomplaint/petition, rather than challenging the local law "as applied" to their property,the challenge is ripe for review (see Yee v Escondido, 503 US 519, 533-534[1992]; Levitt v Incorporated Vil. of [*2]SandsPoint, 6 NY2d 269 [1959]; cf. Town of Islip v Zalak, 165 AD2d 83, 95-96[1991]).
We disagree with the Supreme Court's determination that the local law isunconstitutional. Legislative enactments are entitled to an "exceedingly strongpresumption of constitutionality" (Lighthouse Shores v Town of Islip, 41 NY2d7, 11 [1976]; see ATM One,LLC v Incorporated Vil. of Hempstead, 91 AD3d 585 [2012]; American Ind. Paper Mills SupplyCo., Inc. v County of Westchester, 65 AD3d 1173, 1175 [2009]). A local law iscloaked with the same strong presumption of constitutionality as a statute (see Townof Huntington v Park Shore Country Day Camp of Dix Hills, 47 NY2d 61, 65[1979]; Marcus Assoc. v Town of Huntington, 45 NY2d 501, 505 [1978]; Matter of G&C Transp., Inc. vMcGrane, 97 AD3d 817, 818 [2012]). "With the police power as the predicatefor the State's delegation of municipal zoning authority, a zoning ordinance will be struckdown if it bears no substantial relation to the police power objective of promoting thepublic health, safety, morals or general welfare" (Trustees of Union Coll. in Town ofSchenectady in State of N.Y. v Members of Schenectady City Council, 91 NY2d161, 165 [1997]; see Village of Euclid v Ambler Realty Co., 272 US 365, 395[1926]; Berenson v Town of New Castle, 38 NY2d 102, 107 [1975]).
"The power to zone is derived from the Legislature and must be exercised in the caseof towns and villages in accord with a 'comprehensive plan' " (Asian Ams. forEquality v Koch, 72 NY2d 121, 131 [1988]; see Town Law § 263;Village Law § 7-704). The function of land regulation is to implement a plan forthe future development of the community (see Berenson v Town of New Castle,38 NY2d at 109). Thus, when a plaintiff fails to establish a "clear conflict" with a formalcomprehensive plan, a zoning classification may not be annulled for incompatibility withthe comprehensive plan (InfinityConsulting Group, Inc. v Town of Huntington, 49 AD3d 813, 814 [2008];see Taylor v Incorporated Vil. of Head of Harbor, 104 AD2d 642, 644-645[1984]; Blumberg v City of Yonkers, 41 AD2d 300, 306-308 [1973]).
The record establishes that the local law is not inconsistent with the comprehensiveplan of the Village. The local law is reasonably related to the legitimate stated purpose ofpreserving larger corner lots on the larger boulevard-style streets within the CentralSection of the Village. Municipalities can "enact land-use restrictions or controls toenhance the quality of life by preserving the character and desirable aesthetic features ofa city" (Penn Central Transp. Co. v New York City, 438 US 104, 129 [1978];see Trustees of Union Coll. in Town of Schenectady in State of N.Y. v Members ofSchenectady City Council, 91 NY2d at 165). Moreover, the local law was enactedafter the issue of the subdivision of certain large corner lots in the Central Section of theVillage was studied by an expert engaged by the Village, who advised it on the necessityof additional regulation, and offered alternative approaches to resolve the issue (seeGoodrich v Town of Southampton, 39 NY2d 1008, 1009 [1976]).
The plaintiffs' property was not arbitrarily singled out for different, less favorabletreatment than neighboring properties in a manner that was inconsistent with awell-considered land-use plan, as would be required to sustain a finding ofunconstitutional reverse spot zoning (see Penn Central Transp. Co. v New YorkCity, 438 US at 132; Matterof C/S 12th Ave. LLC v City of New York, 32 AD3d 1, 9 [2006]; Peck Slip Assoc. LLC v CityCouncil of City of N.Y., 26 AD3d 209, 210 [2006]). A well-considered land-useplan can be shown by "evidence, from wherever derived," that serves to "establish a totalplanning strategy for rational allocation of land use, reflecting consideration of the needsof the community as a whole" (Taylor v Incorporated Vil. of Head of Harbor,104 AD2d 642, 644 [1984]), ensuring that the public good will not be undetermined by"special interest, irrational ad hocery" (id., quoting Matter of Town ofBedford v Village of Mount Kisco, 33 NY2d 178, 188 [1973]; see Peck SlipAssoc. LLC v City Council of City of N.Y., 26 AD3d at 210). Here, the evidencedemonstrates that the local law affects a total of 20 corner lots, and that the local lawaccords with the Village's rational comprehensive plan.
The plaintiffs' contention that the local law violates the uniformity requirement ofVillage Law § 7-702 is without merit.
Accordingly, the Supreme Court should have declared that the local law is notunconstitutional.[*3]
Since this is, in part, a declaratory judgmentaction, the matter must be remitted to the Supreme Court, Nassau County, for furtherproceedings, including the entry of a judgment, inter alia, declaring that the local law isnot unconstitutional (see Lanza v Wagner, 11 NY2d 317, 334 [1962], appealdismissed 371 US 74 [1962], cert denied 371 US 901 [1962]). Skelos, J.P.,Balkin, Leventhal and Sgroi, JJ., concur.