| Thomas v Huh |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 01894 [115 AD3d 1225] |
| March 21, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
| —Cleveland L. Thomas et al., Respondents, v JacobK. Huh et al., Appellants, et al., Defendants. |
—[*1] Law Office of J. Michael Hayes, Buffalo (Jeanna M. Cellino of counsel), forplaintiffs-respondents.
Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Erie County (John M. Curran, J.),entered March 8, 2013. The order denied in part the motion of defendants Jacob K. Huhand USA Truck, Inc., for summary judgment dismissing plaintiffs' complaint.
It is hereby ordered that the order so appealed from is unanimously affirmed withoutcosts.
Memorandum: Plaintiffs commenced this action seeking damages for injuriesallegedly sustained by Cleveland L. Thomas (plaintiff) when the vehicle he was drivingwas struck from behind by a tractor trailer owned by USA Truck, Inc., and operated byJacob K. Huh (defendants). Defendants contend on appeal that Supreme Court erred indenying their motion for summary judgment dismissing the complaint with respect to twocategories of serious injury within the meaning of Insurance Law § 5102 (d), i.e.,permanent consequential limitation of use and significant limitation of use, and thusshould have granted their motion in its entirety. We affirm. Defendants' own submissionsin support of the motion raise triable issues of fact with respect to those two categories(see Summers v Spada, 109AD3d 1192, 1192 [2013]). Defendants submitted the reports of imaging studies ofplaintiff's spine, thereby providing the requisite objective evidence of injury (seegenerally Toure v Avis Rent A Car Sys., 98 NY2d 345, 350 [2002]), and theysubmitted several reports of tests that produced "designation[s] of . . .numeric percentage[s] of . . . plaintiff's loss of range of motion[, which] canbe used to substantiate a claim of serious injury" (id.; see Matte v Hall, 20 AD3d898, 899 [2005]).
Contrary to defendants' contention, the report of one of the physicians whoconducted an independent medical examination of plaintiff is insufficient to eliminate alltriable issues of fact and thus establish their entitlement to judgment as a matter of law.The opinion of that physician, i.e., that plaintiff's condition was the result of degenerativechanges predating the accident, fails to account for evidence that plaintiff had nocomplaints of pain prior to the accident (see Endres v Shelba D. Johnson Trucking, Inc., 60 AD3d1481, 1482-1483 [2009]; Ashquabe [*2]v McConnell, 46AD3d 1419, 1419 [2007]). In any event, his opinion is contrary to that of severalother medical professionals who concluded that plaintiff's condition was causally relatedto the accident (see Limardi vMcLeod, 100 AD3d 1375, 1377 [2012]). That same physician, moreover, wasalone in his opinion that plaintiff's limitations in his ranges of motion were magnified orself-imposed, and he provided no factual basis for that opinion (see Busljeta v Plandome Leasing,Inc., 57 AD3d 469, 469 [2008]). In light of defendants' failure to meet theirinitial burden on the motion, there is no need to consider the sufficiency of plaintiffs'opposition thereto (see Summers, 109 AD3d at 1193). Present—Smith,J.P., Fahey, Carni, Sconiers and Valentino, JJ.