Matter of Dear v New York State & Local RetirementSys.
2014 NY Slip Op 02124 [115 AD3d 1141]
March 27, 2014
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, April 30, 2014


In the Matter of Noach Dear, Petitioner, v New York Stateand Local Retirement System, Respondent.

—[*1]Heller, Horowitz & Feit, PC, New York City (Eli Feit of counsel), for petitioner.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (William E. Storrs of counsel), forrespondent.

Peters, P.J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court byorder of the Supreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review a determination of theComptroller which denied petitioner's application for a refund of certain retirementcontributions.

In 1977, petitioner became a member of the New York City Employees' RetirementSystem (hereinafter NYCERS) in connection with his employment with the City of NewYork, and his NYCERS membership remained active thereafter. In 2007, after petitionerwas elected to a judgeship, he became qualified for membership in respondent, a separateretirement system servicing eligible state employees. Consequently, petitioner enrolled inrespondent as a tier 4 member, effective January 1, 2008, after which, due to hisnon-vested status in that system, 3% of his salary was deducted from each of hispaychecks pursuant to Retirement and Social Security Law § 21 (d) and (f) and§ 613. Thereafter, on May 27, 2010, petitioner filed an application with NYCERSrequesting that his active membership in that retirement system be transferred torespondent. Once that transfer was effectuated, petitioner was credited with over 10 yearsof service and the May 2010 date was deemed to be petitioner's "[c]essation date" asdefined by Retirement and Social Security Law § 900 (f). Consequently,petitioner's membership with respondent was duly backdated to the date he originallyjoined NYCERS in 1977. This resulted in petitioner's status with respondent beingchanged to that of a tier 3 member and, [*2]because hewas now credited with more than 10 years of eligible service, the 3% contribution fromhis salary was discontinued as of May 2010.

Subsequently, petitioner contacted respondent and requested a refund of the 3%contributions deducted from his salary after he became a member in January 2008.Respondent informed petitioner that it could not refund the contributions deducted fromhis salary prior to May 2010 because, pursuant to Retirement and Social Security Law§ 902 (b) (2), it is barred from refunding contributions made prior to a member'scessation date. Petitioner timely requested a hearing challenging that denial, after whichthe Hearing Officer concluded that petitioner failed to meet his burden of establishingthat he was entitled to a refund of contributions deducted from his salary for the periodbetween January 2008 and May 2010. The Comptroller made one supplemental findingof fact, but otherwise adopted the Hearing Officer's determination.[FN*]This CPLR article 78 proceeding followed.

Petitioner does not assert that respondent misinterpreted the applicable statutoryprovisions. He maintains, however, that respondent and the Comptroller should beequitably estopped from asserting that his cessation date is in May 2010, rather than onJanuary 1, 2008, the date his application with respondent was deemed effective.According to petitioner, the Comptroller breached his fiduciary duty by providingmisinformation regarding the requirements to transfer his membership in NYCERS torespondent, thus causing him to obtain a later cessation date and suffer financially as aresult.

Even accepting petitioner's contention that the advice given to him regarding thetransfer of his NYCERS pension credit by, among others, respondent's employees wasinaccurate, confusing and/or incomplete, it is well settled that "[e]stoppel is not availableagainst a governmental agency in the exercise of its governmental functions" and"respondent[ ] may not be estopped by the erroneous acts of [its] administrativeemployees" (Matter of Limongelli v New York State Employees' RetirementSys., 173 AD2d 904, 906 [1991] [internal quotation marks and citation omitted]; see Matter of Lewandowski v NewYork State & Local Police & Fire Retirement Sys., 69 AD3d 1027, 1029[2010]). Thus, while one of respondent's employees did acknowledge at the hearing thatmore could have been done to properly advise petitioner as to the actions he was requiredto take to transfer his NYCERS pension credit, the fact remains that these required stepswere not completed prior to May 2010 and respondent was precluded under the relevantstatutes from imposing an earlier cessation date. Consequently, estoppel does not applyherein and we find no basis to otherwise disturb the Comptroller's determination (see Matter of Price v New YorkState & Local Employees' Retirement Sys., 107 AD3d 1212, 1215-[*3]1216 [2013]; Matter of Limongelli v New York StateEmployees' Retirement Sys., 173 AD2d at 906).

Stein, McCarthy and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.

Footnotes


Footnote *: The Comptrollerspecifically noted that petitioner alleged that it was a representative of his employer, theOffice of Court Administration, who initially failed to inform him that, because he wasstill an active member of NYCERS, a formal transfer request delivered to NYCERS wasnecessary to move his service to respondent. Although petitioner was provided materialsthat included the appropriate information regarding the transfer of membership credit, heindicated that he did not realize this information applied to his situation based upon hisreceipt of misinformation regarding his membership status that was not properlyexplained to him.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.