| Michaan v Gazebo Hort., Inc. |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 03240 [117 AD3d 692] |
| May 7, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
[*1]
| Steven Michaan et al., Appellants, v GazeboHorticultural, Inc., et al., Respondents. |
Whitman Breed Abbott & Morgan LLC, White Plains, N.Y. (John T. Shabanand Stephen H. Orr of counsel), for appellants.
Ronald Steinvurzel, White Plains, N.Y., for respondents.
In an action, inter alia, to recover damages for breach of contract, fraud, and breachof the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, the plaintiffs appeal, as limited bytheir brief, from so much of an order of the Supreme Court, Westchester County(Walker, J.), entered April 11, 2013, as granted those branches of the defendants' motionwhich were pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (7) to dismiss the third and fourth causes ofaction.
Ordered that the order is affirmed insofar as appealed from, with costs.
Over a period of nearly four years, commencing in June 2008, the plaintiffs hired thedefendants to perform various landscape design and masonry work projects at theirhome. The plaintiffs subsequently commenced this action seeking damages, inter alia, forbreach of contract, fraud, and breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fairdealing. The plaintiffs allege that they were fraudulently induced to hire the defendantsby the low estimates the defendants provided for each project. The plaintiffs furtherclaim that during the course of completing the projects, the defendants charged themsubstantially more than the quoted estimates.
The defendants moved, inter alia, pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (7) to dismiss the thirdcause of action, which alleged fraud, and the fourth cause of action, which alleged breachof the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. The Supreme Court granted thosebranches of the defendants' motion, and the plaintiffs appeal.
On a motion pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (7) to dismiss a pleading for failure to statea cause of action, the pleading must be liberally construed, the factual allegations must bedeemed true, and the pleading party must be accorded the benefit of every possiblefavorable inference (see Leon v Martinez, 84 NY2d 83, 87 [1994]; Fuller v Collins, 114 AD3d827 [2014]; Kopelowitz& Co., Inc. v Mann, 83 AD3d 793, 797 [2011]; Panish v Panish, 24 AD3d642, 643 [2005]).
To properly plead a cause of action to recover damages for fraud, a plaintiff mustallege that (1) the defendant made a false representation of fact, (2) the defendant hadknowledge of the falsity, (3) the misrepresentation was made in order to induce theplaintiff's reliance, (4) there was justifiable reliance on the part of the plaintiff, and (5)the plaintiff was injured by the reliance (see Crescentini v Slate Hill Biomass Energy, LLC, 113 AD3d806 [2014]; Vermont Mut.Ins. Co. v McCabe & Mack, LLP, 105 AD3d 837, 839 [2013]; Pace v Raisman & Assoc.,Esqs., LLP, 95 AD3d 1185, 1188-1189 [2012]). In addition, CPLR 3016 (b)requires, in relevant part, that where a cause of action is based upon fraud, thecircumstances constituting the wrong shall be stated in detail.
Applying these principles here, the Supreme Court properly granted that branch ofthe defendants' motion which was to dismiss the third cause of action, which allegedfraud. The complaint asserted only in conclusory terms that the estimates provided by thedefendants were too low, and failed to adequately plead facts from which it could beinferred that the defendants knew their estimates were false at the time they wereprovided (see Sklover &Donath, LLC v Eber-Schmid, 71 AD3d 497, 498 [2010]; see also Genovese v State FarmMut. Auto. Ins. Co., 106 AD3d 866, 867 [2013]; Tsutsui v Barasch, 67 AD3d896, 899 [2009]).
The Supreme Court also properly granted that branch of the defendants' motionwhich was to dismiss the fourth cause of action, which alleged breach of the impliedcovenant of good faith and fair dealing. Implicit in every contract is a covenant of goodfaith and fair dealing, which encompasses any promise that a reasonable promisee wouldunderstand to be included (see New York Univ. v Continental Ins. Co., 87 NY2d308, 318 [1995]; Staffenberg vFairfield Pagma Assoc., L.P., 95 AD3d 873, 875 [2012]). The covenant isbreached "where one party to a contract seeks to prevent its performance by, or towithhold its benefits from, the other" (Collard v Incorporated Vil. of Flower Hill,75 AD2d 631, 632 [1980], affd 52 NY2d 594 [1981]; see Aventine Inv. Mgt.v Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, 265 AD2d 513, 514 [1999]; Dvoskin vPrinz, 205 AD2d 661, 662 [1994]). The fourth cause of action fails to state a causeof action because it does not contain any allegation that the defendants sought to preventthe performance of a contract, or to withhold the benefits of a contract from the plaintiffs(see Aventine Inv. Mgt. v Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, 265 AD2d at514). Rivera, J.P., Leventhal, Hinds-Radix and Maltese, JJ., concur.