| Matter of Ortiz v Ortiz |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 04202 [118 AD3d 800] |
| June 11, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Donna M. Ortiz,Respondent, v John Ortiz III, Appellant. |
Kent V. Moston, Hempstead, N.Y. (Jeremy L. Goldberg and Argun M. Ulgen ofcounsel), for appellant.
Donna M. McCabe, Westbury, N.Y., for respondent.
Barbara H. Kopman, Westbury, N.Y., attorney for the child.
In a child custody proceeding pursuant to Family Court Act article 6, the fatherappeals from an order of the Family Court, Nassau County (Singer, J.), dated November29, 2012, which, after a hearing, granted the mother's petition to relocate to Michiganwith the parties' child.
Ordered that the order is affirmed, without costs or disbursements.
"When reviewing a custodial parent's request to relocate, the court's primary focusmust be on the best interests of the child" (Matter of Giraldo v Gomez, 49 AD3d 645, 645 [2008];see Matter of Tropea v Tropea, 87 NY2d 727, 739 [1996]; Matter of Hirtz v Hirtz, 108AD3d 712, 713 [2013]; Matter of Hamed v Hamed, 88 AD3d 791, 791 [2011]; Matter of Said v Said, 61AD3d 879, 881 [2009]). "Relocation may be allowed if the custodial parentdemonstrates, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the proposed move is in thechild's best interests" (Matter ofSteadman v Roumer, 81 AD3d 653, 654 [2011]; see Matter of Hamed vHamed, 88 AD3d at 791). "Although each custodial parent's request for relocationmust be decided on its own merits, the factors to be considered include, but are notlimited to, each parent's reasons for seeking or opposing the move, the quality of therelationships between the [child] and each parent, the impact of the move on the quantityand quality of the [child's] future contact with the noncustodial parent, the degree towhich the lives of the custodial parent and the [child] may be enhanced economically,emotionally, and educationally by the move, and the feasibility of preserving therelationship between the noncustodial parent and the [child] through suitable visitationarrangements" (Matter of Said v Said, 61 AD3d at 881; see Matter of Tropeav Tropea, 87 NY2d at 740-741; Matter of Retamozzo v Moyer, 91 AD3d 957, 957-958[2012]; Matter of Hamed v Hamed, 88 AD3d at 791-792). In relocationdeterminations, this Court's authority is as broad as that of the hearing court (seeMatter of Hirtz v Hirtz, 108 AD3d at 713; Matter of Jennings v Yillah-Chow, 84 AD3d 1376, 1377[2011]). Thus, a relocation determination will not be permitted to stand unless it issupported by a sound and substantial basis in the record (see Matter of Clarke vBoertlein, 82 AD3d 976, 977 [2011]).
Upon weighing the relevant factors, we conclude that the Family Court'sdetermination has a sound and substantial basis in the record. The mother, who wasseeking to [*2]relocate with the subject child from NewYork to Michigan, explained that she and the child were living in temporary housingprovided by their church and that they were at risk of ending up in a shelter. They hadbeen living in a two-bedroom apartment in a "pleasant" neighborhood in RockvilleCentre, but could no longer afford that apartment because, among other things, they werenot receiving any consistent or meaningful support from the father, who had recentlybeen released from incarceration. In Michigan, the mother could afford a clean, modern,and spacious two-bedroom apartment, near public transportation, on her disabilitybenefits alone. She had researched the school district the child would attend and themedical providers he would see, and testified to the assistance of a network of friendswho had already demonstrated their willingness to provide her and the child with muchneeded support and stability. Although the father was no longer incarcerated, he had notbeen fully exercising his visitation rights and was not intimately involved in the child'sdaily life. Moreover, although he had obtained employment several months before theinstant petition was filed, the father only revealed this employment and began offeringmeaningful financial support after the mother proposed the move. In any event, theliberal visitation schedule, including extended visits during summer and schoolvacations, will allow for the continuation of a meaningful relationship between the fatherand the child (see Matter of Hirtz v Hirtz, 108 AD3d at 714; Matter ofJennings v Yillah-Chow, 84 AD3d at 1377). In addition, the position of the attorneyfor the child is that relocation is in the child's best interests, and that position, since it isnot contradicted by the record, is entitled to some weight (see Matter of Hirtz vHirtz, 108 AD3d at 714; Matter of Hamed v Hamed, 88 AD3d at 792).
Accordingly, the Family Court properly granted the mother's petition to relocate toMichigan with the parties' child. Dickerson, J.P., Leventhal, Hall and Miller, JJ.,concur.