| Matter of Bates v New York State & Local Police &Fire Retirement Sys. |
| 2014 NY Slip Op 05689 [120 AD3d 872] |
| August 7, 2014 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Sarah R. Bates, Petitioner, v New YorkState and Local Police and Fire Retirement System,Respondent. |
Culley, Marks, Tanenbaum & Pezzulo, LLP, Rochester (Glenn E. Pezzulo ofcounsel), for petitioner.
Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (William E. Storrs of counsel), forrespondent.
Egan Jr., J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court byorder of the Supreme Court, entered in Albany County) to review a determination of theComptroller which denied petitioner's applications for performance of duty andaccidental disability retirement benefits.
In January 2009, petitioner, a firefighter, applied for performance of duty andaccidental disability retirement benefits, claiming that she was permanently disabled dueto injuries to her back sustained in incidents that occurred in 2000 and 2007. After theapplications initially were denied, petitioner requested a hearing and redetermination.Following a hearing, the Hearing Officer upheld the denials, finding that petitioner hadnot established that she was permanently incapacitated from performing her job dutiesand that neither incident constituted an accident within the meaning of Retirement andSocial Security Law § 363. The Comptroller thereafter upheld the HearingOfficer's decision, prompting petitioner to commence this CPLR article 78 [*2]proceeding.[FN*]
We confirm. As the applicant, petitioner bore the burden of establishing that she waspermanently incapacitated from performing her duties as a firefighter (see Matter of Pavone vDiNapoli, 114 AD3d 1012, 1013 [2014]). "Where, as here, there is conflictingmedical evidence, [the Comptroller] is vested with the exclusive authority to weigh suchevidence and credit the opinion of one medical expert over another" (Matter of Gatewood vDiNapoli, 60 AD3d 1266, 1267 [2009] [citation omitted]; accord Matter of Arroyo vDiNapoli, 93 AD3d 980, 981 [2012]).
The Comptroller credited the medical opinion of Austin Leve, the board-certifiedorthopedic surgeon who testified for respondent, over the opinions of petitioner's treatingorthopedic surgeon and her rheumatologist, and we disagree with petitioner's contentionthat Leve's opinion lacked a proper foundation. The record establishes that Leve'sopinion was based upon a physical examination of petitioner in August 2009 and areview of the pertinent medical records. Based upon such examination and review, Leveopined that, although petitioner had subjective complaints, there were no objectivefindings indicating that she was permanently incapacitated from performing her jobduties. Although petitioner is correct that Leve did not review an MRI performed on hersubsequent to his examination, Leve testified that he was aware of the MRI results andthat such results did not change his opinion. Inasmuch as Leve's opinion was rational,fact-based and founded upon a physical examination of petitioner and a review ofrelevant medical records, we decline to disturb the Comptroller's determination,notwithstanding other evidence in the record that could support a contrary result (see Matter of Marello vDiNapoli, 111 AD3d 1052, 1053 [2013]; Matter of Cantelmo v New York State Comptroller, 105 AD3d1306, 1307-1308 [2013]).
Peters, P.J., Stein, Rose and Clark, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.
Footnote *:As petitioner did notaddress the Comptroller's findings that the 2000 and 2007 incidents were not accidentswithin the meaning of Retirement and Social Security Law § 363 in herbrief, any arguments concerning the denial of her application for accidental disabilityretirement benefits are deemed abandoned (see Matter of Dymond v Hevesi, 24 AD3d 938, 938 n[2005]).