Matter of VanSavage v Jones
2014 NY Slip Op 05930 [120 AD3d 887]
August 21, 2014
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, September 24, 2014


[*1]
 In the Matter of Paul C. VanSavage, Respondent, vDenver Jones, Appellant, et al., Respondents. (Proceeding No. 1.) In the Matter ofDenver Jones, Individually and on Behalf of all Signers of a Petition Filed Pursuant toElection Law § 6-134, Appellant,
v
Gregory Peterson et al., asCommissioners Constituting the New York State Board of Elections, Respondents, andPaul C. VanSavage et al., Respondents. (Proceeding No. 2.)

Douglas Walter Drazen, Binghamton, for appellant.

Sinnreich, Kasakoff & Messina LLP, Central Islip (John Ciampoli of counsel),for Paul [*2]C. VanSavage and another,respondents.

Per Curiam. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (McNamara, J.), enteredAugust 18, 2014 in Albany County, which, among other things, granted petitioner'sapplication, in proceeding No. 1 pursuant to Election Law § 16-102, todeclare invalid the designating petition naming respondent Denver Jones as theRepublican Party candidate for the public office of State Senator for the 52nd SenateDistrict in the September 9, 2014 primary election.

Denver Jones filed a designating petition with the New York State Board ofElections seeking to be nominated as the Republican Party candidate for the public officeof State Senator for the 52nd Senate District in the September 9, 2014 primary election.After objections were filed, the State Board issued a determination on August 1, 2014that invalidated Jones' designating petition, finding that, of the 1,713 signatures claimedto be filed, 743 signatures were invalid, leaving Jones with 970 signatures, 30 short ofthe 1,000 signatures required to receive the designation. In the interim, Paul C.VanSavage commenced proceeding No. 1 pursuant to Election Law§ 16-102 seeking to invalidate Jones' designating petition on numerousgrounds, including fraud. Subsequent to the State Board's determination, Jonescommenced proceeding No. 2 pursuant to Election Law § 16-102 seekingto validate the designating petition. Following a hearing, Supreme Court found, amongother things, that Jones' designating petition was permeated by fraud and invalidated it.Jones appeals.

Initially, Supreme Court erred in invalidating the designating petition based uponalleged fraud on the part of Jones. A designating petition will be invalidated if thechallenger shows, by clear and convincing evidence, " 'that the entire petition ispermeated with fraud or that the candidate participated in, or can be charged withknowledge of, fraudulent activity' " (Matter of Valenti v Bugbee, 88 AD3d 1056, 1057 [2011],quoting Matter of Kraham vRabbitt, 11 AD3d 808, 809 [2004]). Here, VanSavage contends that Jonesparticipated in the fraudulent activity himself inasmuch as, while collecting signatures onpetitions, he falsely attested to signatures he knew to be nonauthentic. To that end,VanSavage presented a handwriting expert who testified that, on various pages on whichJones was the subscribing witness, several of the signatures were written by the sameperson.

In response, Jones testified to a particular incident in a pizza parlor during which,after handing the petition to a group of four people who had each identified themselvesand stated that they were Republican voters, he turned to answer a question from anotherpatron. Jones related that, while he had assumed that the petition was being passedaround to be signed by each person, he mistakenly stopped paying attention and it waspossible that one of those people had signed for the other three. Jones further stated thathe did not examine the signatures afterward and that he was unaware that there was aproblem until the day he received objections to his petition. Jones also testified that hehad no recollection of the other instances in which it appeared that more than onesignature was provided by the same person, but he stated that he would not allow peopleto take petitions into their homes for other people to sign and would not accept thesignatures of one spouse for another. Inasmuch as Supreme Court explicitly found Jones'testimony to be "very candid and honest" and VanSavage failed to submit any evidence[*3]that Jones knowingly accepted fraudulent signatures,we do not find clear and convincing evidence that Jones "acted fraudulently or didanything that would warrant invalidating the entire designating petition" (Matter of Nolin v McNally, 87AD3d 804, 806 [2011]; seeMatter of Bonner v Negron, 87 AD3d 737, 739-740 [2011]).

The petition not having been invalidated based upon fraud, it is still incumbent uponJones to demonstrate that he has the 1,000 valid signatures necessary to qualify forinclusion on the ballot. In that vein, we turn first to his contention that Supreme Courterred in upholding the invalidation of the signatures appearing on sheets 5-7, 14-17,19-22 and 25-26 of the designating petition because the "Witness IdentificationInformation" portion of the subscribing witness statement requesting "Town or City" and"County" were left blank. The witness identification information on designating petitionsis intended to allow for "the rapid and efficient verification of signatures within therestrictive time periods imposed by the Election Law" to facilitate the discovery of fraud(Matter of Zobel v New York State Bd. of Elections, 254 AD2d 520, 522 [1998];see Matter of Curley vZacek, 22 AD3d 954, 956 [2005], lv denied 5 NY3d 714 [2005]). Thus,where the complete residence address of the subscribing witness appears elsewhere onthe same page of the petition, an error in providing the witness identification informationhas been held to be "an inconsequential violation" and not a fatal defect (Matter ofCurley v Zacek, 22 AD3d at 956; see Matter of Arcuri v Hojnacki, 32 AD3d 658, 660[2006], lv denied 7 NY3d 707 [2006]). Here, the subscribing witness providedher complete address in the "Statement of Witness" section on each of the petition pagesat issue and her name and complete address also appears at the top of each page as amember of the committee to fill vacancies. In addition, she submitted an affidavit thatstated that she carried the petition pages at issue and that her correct residential addressappeared on each page. Thus, absent any indication of fraud or record evidence that thesubscribing witness did not reside at the address provided, we find that the signaturescontained on those pages of the petition should not have been invalidated (see Matterof Arcuri v Hojnacki, 32 AD3d at 660; Matter of Curley v Zacek, 22 AD3dat 956; see also Matter ofPowers v Kozlowski, 54 AD3d 540, 541-542 [2008], lv denied 11 NY3d701 [2008]). Accordingly, a total of 125 signatures should be reinstated to Jones'total.[FN1]

Jones next contends that Supreme Court erred in invalidating the petition sheetscirculated by Daniel McNett, pages 76 to 94, on the grounds that McNett's voterregistration had been cancelled because he did not reside at the address claimed on hisregistration form and because he had previously been convicted of a felony. Becausedisenfranchisement is a drastic punishment, Election Law § 5-402 requiresthat a voter's registration may not be cancelled until after a board of elections has notifiedthe voter of its intention to cancel and gives him or her the opportunity to be heard(see Matter of Engel v Board of Elections of State of N.Y., 143 AD2d 291, 292[1988], lv denied 72 NY2d 805 [1988]; Nesci v Canary, 112 AD2d 1056,1057 [1985], lv denied 65 NY2d 607 [1985]). Here, the record demonstrates thatMcNett was a registered voter during the first two weeks of July 2014, when he collectedsignatures for Jones and they were submitted to the State Board, and the process forcancelling his registration did not commence until July 22, 2014. Accordingly, thesignatures that McNett collected were valid, and Supreme Court erred in findingotherwise; thus, 44 signatures should be added to Jones' total (see Matter of Hudson vBoard of Elections of City of N.Y., 207 AD2d 508, 509 [1994]; Matter of Engelv Board of Elections of State of N.Y., 143 AD2d at 292; Nesci v Canary, 112AD2d at [*4]1057; see generally Matter of Robelottov Burch, 242 AD2d 397, 398 [1997]).[FN2]

Jones lastly contends that the State Board erred in invalidating pages 95, 97, 98, 102and 111 of his designating petition, all carried by Marc Romain, on various grounds. Wefirst address pages 95 and 97, which were disallowed based upon certain changes to thewitness statements. While alterations to a witness statement that are unexplained anduninitialed will ordinarily result in the invalidation of the petition page even where thealterations result in the provision of correct information, the underlying signatures neednot be nullified where an explanation is provided by affidavit or testimony (see Matter of Oberman vRomanowski, 65 AD3d 992, 993 [2009]; Matter of Curley v Zacek, 22AD3d at 957). Here, Romain submitted an affidavit that explained the alterations hemade to the witness name on page 95 and to the date on page 97 of the petition. In lightof this uncontroverted explanation, the State Board erred in invalidating all of thesignatures contained on pages 95 and 97 of Jones' petition and, consequently, the 15signatures on those two pages not invalidated by the State Board for other reasons shouldbe counted (see Matter ofRosmarin v Belcastro, 44 AD3d 1055, 1056 [2007]; Matter of Curley vZacek, 22 AD3d at 957). Similarly, absent any allegation of fraud, the overstatementof the signature totals on pages 102 and 111 of Jones' petition was not such a grossirregularity as to warrant invalidation of the entire pages and, thus, the 19 signatures onthose two pages not invalidated by the State Board for other reasons should have beencounted (see Matter of Rancourtv Magill, 87 AD3d 656, 657 [2011]; see generally Matter of Barrett vScaringe, 112 AD2d 1095, 1096-1097 [1985], affd 65 NY2d 946 [1985]).However, with respect to page 98 of the petition, we find that the State Board properlyinvalidated all of the signatures on that page, inasmuch as Romain failed to provide acomplete residence address (seeMatter of Henry v Trotto, 54 AD3d 424, 426-427 [2008]; Matter of Gleasonv Longo, 133 AD2d 289, 290 [1987]; Matter of Liepshutz v Palmateer, 112AD2d 1101, 1103 [1985], affd 65 NY2d 965 [1985]).

Both VanSavage and Jones further contend that there were additional signatures onJones' designating petition that should have been invalidated or validated. Supreme Courtdeclined to take evidence with respect to those arguments and this Court is unable toresolve those questions based upon the record before us. For that reason, we remit toSupreme Court for further proceedings on issues not decided herewith. Pursuant to ourdeterminations here, 203 signatures that were declared invalid by either Supreme Courtor the State Board should be reinstated to the total found valid by the State Board, givingJones 1,173 signatures on his designating petition and presumptively qualifying him toparticipate in the primary election.

McCarthy, J.P., Garry, Egan Jr., Lynch and Clark, JJ., concur. Ordered that the orderis modified, on the law, without costs, by reversing so much thereof as granted theapplication in proceeding No. 1 and dismissed the application in proceeding No. 2;matter remitted to the Supreme Court for further proceedings not inconsistent with thisCourt's decision; and, as so modified, affirmed.

Footnotes


Footnote 1:One signature on page14 of the designating petition had been invalidated by the State Board on separategrounds.

Footnote 2:Although the StateBoard ostensibly counted all of the valid signatures on the pages witnessed by McNett inits total of 970, the record demonstrates otherwise. Examining the State Board's staffwork sheet of objections with respect to petition pages 83, 84, 85 and 86, individualobjections were sustained to, respectively, no signatures, three signatures, threesignatures and nine signatures on those pages. Inexplicably, however, the State Boardinvalidated all of the signatures on those pages in its final tally. Because no other reasonappears in the record for having invalidated the 44 remaining signatures, we find those tobe properly added back to Jones' total.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.