| Matter of Boni Enters., LLC v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of theTown of Clifton Park |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 00428 [124 AD3d 1052] |
| January 15, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Boni Enterprises, LLC, et al.,Appellants, v Zoning Board of Appeals of The Town of Clifton Park et al.,Respondents. |
Tabner, Ryan & Keniry, LLP, Albany (Dana L. Salazar of counsel), forappellants.
Thomas R. McCarthy, Clifton Park, for respondents.
McCarthy, J.P. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Crowell, J.), enteredJuly 3, 2013 in Saratoga County, which, among other things, dismissed petitioners'application, in a combined proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 and action fordeclaratory judgment, to, among other things, review a determination of respondentZoning Board of Appeals of the Town of Clifton Park interpreting the Town Code of theTown of Clifton Park to prohibit petitioners' proposed development.
Petitioner Boni Enterprises, LLC (hereinafter Boni) and petitioner Country ClubAcres, Inc. (hereinafter CCA) own contiguous parcels of real property in the Town ofClifton Park, Saratoga County. Petitioners submitted a revised application for site planreview to the Town of Clifton Park Planning Board, outlining a plan to build 74one-family dwellings on the Boni parcel and 15 commercial buildings—to be usedas office buildings, warehouses and flex space—on the CCA parcel. The PlanningBoard took the position that it was unable to consider the application because respondentSteven M. Myers, the Town's Zoning Enforcement Officer, believed that there werezoning issues with petitioners' site plan. Based on their disagreement with Myers'sinterpretation of the Town Code, petitioners appealed to respondent Zoning Board ofAppeals of the Town of Clifton Park (hereinafter the ZBA) for a definitive interpretationof the Town Code's zoning provisions in relation to their site plan. The ZBA upheldMyers's interpretation, which, among other things, determined that multiple one-familydwellings could not be constructed on Boni's parcel.
[*2] Petitioners commenced this combined proceedingpursuant to CPLR article 78 and action for declaratory judgment seeking, among otherthings, review of the ZBA's determination. Respondents counterclaimed for declarationsthat Myers's interpretation of the Town Code was correct. Supreme Court dismissed thepetition and did not make any definitive declarations. Petitioners appeal.
Supreme Court erred in deferring to the ZBA's interpretation of the zoningordinance, and the ZBA erred in its interpretation of the Town Code as it pertains to theBoni parcel. Although courts generally grant deference to a zoning board of appealsregarding its determination, no deference is required if the issue is one of pure legalinterpretation of the zoning law (see Matter of Albany Basketball & Sports Corp. v City ofAlbany, 116 AD3d 1135, 1137 [2014], lv denied 23 NY3d 907 [2014];see also Matter of New York Botanical Garden v Board of Stds. & Appeals ofCity of N.Y., 91 NY2d 413, 419 [1998]). Because zoning ordinances are inderogation of common law, they must be strictly construed against the municipality thatdrafted them, and any ambiguity must be resolved in favor of property owners (seeMatter of Albany Basketball & Sports Corp. v City of Albany, 116 AD3d at1137; Matter of Salton v Townof Mayfield Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 116 AD3d 1113, 1113-1114 [2014]). TheBoni parcel is located in a B-1 zoning district, which has 18 listed permitted uses,including one- and two-family dwellings (see Town Code of the Town of CliftonPark § 208-32 [A] [14]). Pursuant to section 208-33 (B) of the Town Code, in a B-1 district, "[n]o preexistingbuilding(s) shall be rehabilitated or remodeled or new building(s) constructed on a vacantlot to a size greater than 12% of the lot size, with no single building to have a maximumsquare footage exceeding 4,800 square feet. Multiple buildings on a lot are allowed aslong as the overall density limitations of this article are not exceeded."
Essentially, petitioners argue that the word "buildings" in the last sentence of section208-33 (B) of the Town Code includes one-family dwellings, leading to the conclusionthat the Town Code permits them to build multiple dwellings on the Boni parcel as longas they comply with the density limitations. The parties do not appear to dispute thatpetitioners' proposal, as submitted, to build 74 one-family dwellings on that parcel wouldcomply with those density limitations. Respondents contend that the Town Codedifferentiates between dwellings and other buildings, such that the two words cannot beused interchangeably. For example, in the two subdivisions following the above-quotedlanguage, the Town Code states that landscaping in a B-1 district "shall be in accordancewith that similarly associated with residential dwellings" (Town Code of the Town ofClifton Park § 208-33 [C]), and the architectural design of buildings in aB-1 district "shall be consistent with the designs compatible for residential dwellings"(Town Code of the Town of Clifton Park § 208-33 [D]). Part of the purposeof a B-1 district, as noted in the Town Code, is "to allow the conversion of existingresidential dwellings and vacant lots into general office uses while maintaining the area'sresidential character. . . . It is intended that buildings in this district becompatible in size and appearance with residential dwellings" (Town Code of the Townof Clifton Park § 208-30 [A]).
A dwelling clearly falls within the definition of a building under the Town Code,which is defined as "[a] structure wholly or partially enclosed within exterior walls orwithin exterior and party walls and a roof, affording shelter to persons, animals orproperty" (Town Code of the Town of Clifton Park § 208-7 [A], building).The word dwelling is defined to include a "building designed or used primarilyfor human habitation" (Town Code of the Town of Clifton Park § 208-7[A], dwelling [emphasis added]), and a one-family dwelling is defined as "[a] permanentbuilding containing only one dwelling unit" (Town Code of the Town of CliftonPark § 208-7 [A], dwelling, one-family [emphasis added]). Respondents arecorrect that the words building and dwelling are not synonymous and cannot be usedinterchangeably, because a [*3]dwelling is a subset of thebroader term building. Stated another way, not every building is a dwelling, but everydwelling is a building. We agree with respondents that respondent Town of Clifton Parkprobably never envisioned a landowner being able to build 74 one-family dwellings on asingle, unsubdivided parcel in a business district. Nevertheless, the plain language of theTown Code, strictly construed against the municipality, must be interpreted as permittingmultiple buildings—including one-family dwellings—on a single lot aslong as they do not exceed the density limitations (see Town Code of the Townof Clifton Park § 208-33 [B]). Accordingly, the ZBA's determination mustbe annulled to the extent that it incorrectly interpreted that portion of the TownCode.
Supreme Court correctly determined that Local Law No. 8 (1991) of the Town ofClifton Park (hereinafter Local Law No. 8) was properly enacted. Petitioners contendthat Local Law No. 8—which amended the zoning ordinance to create a businessdistrict covering a certain area that contains the CCA parcel (formerly zoned as a planneddevelopment district)—is invalid because it was allegedly enacted without propernotice. The purpose of the notice requirement is to "fairly apprise[ ] the public of thefundamental character of the proposed zoning change" in a manner that "describes theproposed change with reasonable precision" and does "not mislead interested parties intoforegoing attendance at the public hearing" (Matter of Gernatt Asphalt Prods. v Townof Sardinia, 87 NY2d 668, 678 [1996]; accord Interlaken Homeowners' Assn. vCity of Saratoga Springs, 267 AD2d 842, 845-846 [1999]; see Town Law§ 264 [1]). Although the notice here did not state that the proposedordinance would repeal Local Law No. 2 (1970) of the Town of Clifton Park, the noticedid state that the proposed ordinance would amend the zoning ordinance in relation totwo business districts and identified the geographical area that would be affected, whichincluded the CCA parcel. Thus, the record establishes that the Town gave the requirednotice that "in general terms describ[ed] the proposed ordinance" (Town Law§ 130; see Town Law § 264 [1]). Accordingly,respondents are entitled to a declaration that Local Law No. 8 was properly enacted.
The Town's failure to update its zoning map to reflect the 1991 zoning change of theCCA parcel did not render Local Law No. 8 null and void. The Town Code mentions anofficial zoning map in several places, including section 208-31, which states that "[t]helocation and boundaries of the B-1 and B-2 Districts are declared and delineated on the[o]fficial [z]oning [m]ap as attached hereto" (Town Code of the Town of Clifton Park§ 208-31), and notes that the zoning map is on file in the Town offices(see Town Code of the Town of Clifton Park § 208-30 [A];§ 208-74 [B] [stating that if certain zoning changes are approved, theofficial zoning map shall be amended to define the new boundaries]). It does not appearthat any map is attached to the Town Code. The record does include a full-sized zoningmap, dated 2006, which indicates that the CCA parcel is zoned as a planned developmentdistrict. However, the record does not indicate that the Town ever expressly incorporatedthis or any other zoning map into the Town Code (see Town Law§ 265 [2]), nor did the Town adopt an official zoning map pursuant to theprocedures set forth in Town Law § 270 (see Hull v Town of Ithaca,139 AD2d 887, 888-889 [1988]; compare Matter of Oakwood Prop. Mgt., LLC v Town ofBrunswick, 103 AD3d 1067, 1071 [2013], lv denied 21 NY3d 853[2013]). The Town attorney averred that he conducted a diligent search of the Townrecords and did not uncover an official map. The record does contain some supplementalzoning maps, dated 1991, no longer showing the CCA parcel zoned as a planneddevelopment district, but as a business district—consistent with Local Law No. 8.Section 208-3 (B) states, after a subdivision listing the types of zoning districts in theTown, that "[a] description of district boundaries is on file in the office of the TownClerk, as well as a map upon which the districts are laid out for ready reference" (TownCode of the Town of Clifton Park § 208-3 [B]). This implies that thewritten descriptions are controlling, while the map is simply available[*4]as a reference tool. The next section, section 208-4 (A),after stating that district boundary lines are generally property lines or center lines ofstreets "[u]nless shown to the contrary on the [z]oning [m]ap," provides that "[q]uestionsconcerning the exact location of the district boundary lines shall be resolved by theZoning Enforcement Officer" (Town Code of the Town of Clifton Park§ 208-4 [A]). Inasmuch as the record does not reflect that the Town hasadopted an official zoning map, the failure to update its zoning map—which isunofficial and available merely as a reference tool—does not affect the validity ofLocal Law No. 8.
The parties' remaining contentions have been reviewed and are either academic orwithout merit.
Garry, Lynch, Devine and Clark, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment is modified,on the law, without costs, by reversing so much thereof as dismissed the claims ofpetitioner Boni Enterprises, LLC; it is declared that (1) the Town Code of the Town ofClifton Park does not prohibit petitioner Boni Enterprises, LLC from constructingmultiple one-family dwellings on a single lot in the B-1 district, (2) Local Law No. 8(1991) of the Town of Clifton Park was properly enacted and (3) the real property owned bypetitioner Country Club Acres, Inc. that is at issue in this litigation is located in the zoning districts as set forth by Local Law No. 8 and, as so modified, affirmed.