Matter of Isaacs (Speedy Media Assoc.,LLC—Commissioner of Labor)
2015 NY Slip Op 01215 [125 AD3d 1077]
February 11, 2015
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, April 1, 2015


[*1]
 In the Matter of the Claim of Michelle A. Isaacs,Respondent. Speedy Media Associates, LLC, Appellant; Commissioner of Labor,Respondent.

Littler Mendelson, PC, New York City (David S. Warner of counsel), forappellant.

Murphy, Burns, Barber & Murphy, LLP, Albany (Catherine A. Barber ofcounsel), for Michelle A. Isaacs, respondent.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, New York City (Mary Hughes of counsel),for Commissioner of Labor, respondent.

Garry, J.P. Appeal from two decisions of the Unemployment Insurance AppealBoard, filed February 27, 2013, which ruled, among other things, that Speedy MediaAssociates, LLC was liable for additional unemployment insurance contributions onremuneration paid to claimant and others similarly situated.

Speedy Media Associates, LLC is in the business of ensuring delivery ofnewspapers, periodicals, magazines, beverages and other items on behalf of its clients,including one client who is in the business of delivering newspapers and other items. Inaddition to its regular employees, Speedy Media hired claimant and other carriers todeliver newspapers in the metropolitan New York City area for its clients pursuant to astandard written contract designating the carriers as independent contractors andestablishing a pay rate based upon their routes. After claimant filed a claim forunemployment insurance benefits, the Department of Labor issued an initialdetermination finding that claimant was an employee and, thus, eligible to receivebenefits, and that Speedy Media was responsible for additional unemployment insurancecontributions based upon remuneration paid to claimant, and others similarly situated,since January 1, 2010. Combined hearings were held and, [*2]ultimately, the Unemployment Insurance Appeal Boardaffirmed that determination, prompting this appeal by Speedy Media.

We affirm. "Whether an employment relationship exists within the meaning of theunemployment insurance law is a question of fact, no one factor is determinative and thedetermination of the. . . [B]oard, if supported by substantial evidence on therecord as a whole, is beyond further judicial review even though there is evidence in therecord that would have supported a contrary conclusion" (Matter of ConcourseOphthalmology Assoc. [Roberts], 60 NY2d 734, 736 [1983] [citations omitted]; accord Matter of Empire StateTowing & Recovery Assn., Inc. [Commissioner of Labor], 15 NY3d 433,437 [2010]). "An employer-employee relationship exists when the evidence shows thatthe employer exercises control over the results produced or the means used to achieve theresults [although] control over the means is the more important factor to be considered"(Matter of Empire State Towing & Recovery Assn., Inc. [Commissioner ofLabor], 15 NY3d at 437 [internal quotation marks and citations omitted]; see Matter of McCollum [Fire Is.Union Free Sch. Dist.—Commissioner of Labor], 118 AD3d 1203, 1204[2014]).

The record reflects that Speedy Media hired the carriers and required that they sign astandard contract, separated the newspapers at its client's facility, established the deliveryroutes and showed new carriers their routes, and provided carriers with daily customerlists and address labels for their designated routes, although the carriers could set thesequence of their deliveries. The carriers picked up the newspapers at the client's facilityduring set times, were required to place them in bags if provided by the publisher, andwere required to make timely deliveries in their own vehicles by set times and to callSpeedy Media on weekends when their deliveries were complete. Speedy Media paid thecarriers a set rate per delivery, with a guaranteed daily minimum, by check every twoweeks regardless of whether its clients had paid, required carriers to maintain minimumvehicle insurance and did not reimburse them for expenses, and offered an accidentpolicy for which premiums were deducted from carrier paychecks. The carriers wereallowed to use helpers and were expected to provide substitutes in their absence but, ifthey did not make their deliveries, Speedy Media assumed responsibility for thedeliveries and did not pay the carriers, who risked termination. Speedy Mediaperiodically checked the routes to verify proper delivery, allowed carriers to deliverproducts for others provided it did not interfere with their duties, but did not permit themto insert materials into clients' newspapers. Customer complaints were made to SpeedyMedia or its clients, who communicated with carriers as needed.

The evidence provided ample support for the Board's finding that Speedy Mediaexercised control over significant aspects of the carriers' work and the means used toachieve timely and proper deliveries, and the Board's determination that the carriers wereits employees is consistent with prior cases involving essentially similar facts (seeMatter of Rivera [State Line Delivery Serv.—Roberts], 69 NY2d 679, 682[1986], cert denied 481 US 1049 [1987]; Matter of Charles A. Field DeliveryServ. [Roberts], 66 NY2d 516, 521 [1985]; Matter of Armison [Gannett Co., Inc.—Commissioner ofLabor], 122 AD3d 1101, 1102-1103 [2014]; Matter of Lewis [Absolute Distrib., Inc.—Commissioner ofLabor], 121 AD3d 1488, 1488-1489 [2014]; Matter of Gray [Glens FallsNewspapers—Roberts], 134 AD2d 791,791-792 [1987]; Matter of Wells[Utica Observer-Dispatch & Utica Daily Press—Roberts], 87 AD2d 960,960-961 [1982], affd 59 NY2d 638 [1983]). Finally, "[a] different finding is notcompelled by the existence of a written agreement that identifies claimant as anindependent contractor" (Matterof Kelly [Frank Gallo, Inc.—Commissioner of Labor], 28 AD3d 1044,1045 [2006], lv dismissed 7 NY3d 844 [2006]).

[*3] Egan Jr., Lynch and Clark, JJ., concur. Ordered thatthe decisions are affirmed, without costs.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.