| Matter of Exxon Mobil Corp. v State of N.Y. Tax AppealsTrib. |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 01840 [126 AD3d 1059] |
| March 5, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Exxon Mobil Corporation,Petitioner, v State of New York Tax Appeals Tribunal et al.,Respondents. |
McCarter & English, LLP, New York City (David J. Shipley of counsel), forpetitioner.
Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Robert M. Goldfarb of counsel),for Commissioner of Taxation and Finance, respondent.
Clark, J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (initiated in this Court pursuant toTax Law § 2016) to review a determination of respondent Tax AppealsTribunal which, among other things, sustained a sales and use tax assessment imposedunder Tax Law articles 28 and 29.
At all relevant times, petitioner owned, operated or was responsible forenvironmental concerns at numerous facilities in New York where petroleum was used.The Department of Taxation and Finance conducted an audit of petitioner, after which itissued a notice of determination finding that petitioner owed approximately $500,000 insales tax on payments made to contractors from 2000 through 2004. Specifically, thosepayments were made for required testing and monitoring on properties affected bypetroleum spills. Petitioner challenged the notice of determination and, following ahearing, an Administrative Law Judge upheld it. Respondent Tax Appeals Tribunalthereafter affirmed. Petitioner commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding seekingreview of the Tribunal's determination, and we now confirm.
Tax Law § 1105 (c) (5) imposes a sales tax on purchases of servicesrelated to "[m]aintaining, servicing or repairing real property, property or land. . . as distinguished from adding to or improving such real property,property or land, by a capital improvement." 20 NYCRR 527.7 (a) (1) further defines"[m]aintaining, servicing and repairing" as "all activities [*2]that relate to keeping real property in a condition of fitness,efficiency, readiness or safety or restoring it to such condition." Petitioner asserts that themonitoring and testing services paid for here were not taxable, as they were onlyintended to ascertain the condition of the affected property and not to remediate thepetroleum spills. We disagree.
Under well-established principles of law, "an agency's interpretation of the statutes itadministers must be upheld absent demonstrated irrationality or unreasonableness"(Lorillard Tobacco Co. v Roth, 99 NY2d 316, 322 [2003] [internal quotationmarks and citation omitted]; accord Matter of Xerox Corp. v New York State Tax AppealsTrib., 110 AD3d 1262, 1264 [2013]; Matter of Island Waste Servs., Ltd. v Tax Appeals Trib. of the Stateof N.Y., 77 AD3d 1080, 1082 [2010], lv denied 16 NY3d 712 [2011]).Petitioner points out that no deference will generally be afforded to administrativeagencies in matters of pure statutory interpretation (see Matter of O'Brien v Spitzer, 7 NY3d 239, 242 [2006];Matter of Xerox Corp. v New York State Tax Appeals Trib., 110 AD3d at 1264).Inasmuch as the present case involves the specific application of broad statutorylanguage, however, deference to the agency that is charged with administering the statuteis appropriate (see Matter of Xerox Corp. v New York State Tax Appeals Trib.,110 AD3d at 1264; Matter of Island Waste Servs., Ltd. v Tax Appeals Trib. of theState of N.Y., 77 AD3d at 1082; compare Matter of Michael A. Goldstein No. 1 Trust v Tax AppealsTrib. of the State of N.Y., 101 AD3d 1496, 1497 [2012], lv denied 21NY3d 860 [2013]). Contrary to petitioner's further assertion, the burden rested upon it toestablish that the specific sales at issue here were not taxable (see Tax Law§ 1132 [c] [1]; Matter of Cecos Intl. v State Tax Commn., 71 NY2d934, 937 [1988]; compare Matter of Building Contrs. Assn. v Tully, 87 AD2d909, 910 [1982] [challenge to regulatory provision imposing sales tax on specified salesof services]).
As this Court and the Court of Appeals have "noted, both the statute and regulationcontain broad language" (Matter of Island Waste Servs., Ltd. v Tax Appeals Trib. ofthe State of N.Y., 77 AD3d at 1082; see Matter of Rochester Gas & Elec.Corp. v New York State Tax Commn., 71 NY2d 931, 933-934 [1988]). The removalof hazardous waste from a property constitutes a taxable maintenance service and,indeed, petitioner does not dispute that a purchase of services related to the remediationof spilled petroleum is taxable (see Matter of Island Waste Servs., Ltd. v Tax AppealsTrib. of the State of N.Y., 77 AD3d at 1082; Matter of Tonawanda Tank Transp.Serv. v Tax Appeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 168 AD2d 748, 750 [1990]). Petitionerclaims that the services at issue here are not related to the improvement of propertyaffected by a petroleum spill, but that claim is not borne out by the record. Petroleumdischarges are prohibited in New York and, when a spill occurs, petitioner is obliged tonotify the Department of Environmental Conservation and may coordinate with thatDepartment to remediate the spill (see Navigation Law §§ 173,175, 176 [7]). Petitioner is required to conduct an environmental investigation of the spillarea, including the monitoring and testing services at issue here, as part of its remediationeffort. While an active cleanup of a spill site is not required in every case, the samemonitoring and testing procedures are always employed, and it may take years for thoseprocedures to reveal what type of remediation is required. Moreover, if activeremediation is conducted, further monitoring and testing is required to ensure that theremedial system may be safely removed. Under these circumstances, there was nothingirrational in the finding that the monitoring and testing services at issue constituted an"integral part of the" taxable remediation efforts, even if they were billed separately(Matter of Tonawanda Tank Transp. Serv. v Tax Appeals Trib. of State of N.Y.,168 AD2d at 750; see Matter of Cecos Intl. v State Tax Commn., 71 NY2d at936; Matter of Penfold v State Tax Commn., 114 AD2d 696, 697 [1985]). As aresult, the Tribunal properly found them to be taxable services under Tax Law§ 1105 (c) (5), to wit, "activities that relate to keeping real property in acondition of fitness, efficiency, readiness or safety or restoring it to such condition" (20NYCRR 527.7 [a] [1]; see Matter of Island Waste Servs. v Tax Appeals Trib. of theState of N.Y., 77 AD3d at 1083; Matter of Tonawanda Tank [*3]Transp. Serv. v Tax Appeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 168AD2d at 750).[FN*]
Petitioner's remaining arguments have been considered and found to be lacking inmerit.
McCarthy, J.P., Lynch and Devine, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.
Footnote *:The Tribunal noted itsbelief that all services related to "cleanup" of a petroleum spill, as that term is used in theNavigation Law, were taxable under Tax Law § 1105 (c) (5) (seeNavigation Law §§ 172 [4], [5]; 176; State of New York v Neill, 17AD3d 802, 803 [2005], appeal dismissed 5 NY3d 823 [2005]). We need not,and do not, resolve that broader question because the Tribunal found that the specificactivities here were taxable under Tax Law § 1105 (c) (5), even withoutreference to the Navigation Law.