| Spiegel-Porco v Porco |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 02956 [127 AD3d 847] |
| April 8, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
[*1]
| Paulette J. Spiegel-Porco, Respondent, v ElliottP. Porco, Appellant. |
Elliott P. Porco, Scarsdale, N.Y., appellant pro se.
Arnold S. Kronick, White Plains, N.Y., for respondent.
In an action for a divorce and ancillary relief, the defendant appeals, as limited by hisbrief, from so much of a judgment of the Supreme Court, Westchester County(Christopher, J.), entered July 26, 2012, as, upon a decision of the same court datedOctober 31, 2011, made after a nonjury trial, directed him to pay to the plaintiff the sumof $1,879 per month for child support and the principal sum of $6,443 for child supportarrears.
Ordered that the judgment is reversed insofar as appealed from, on the law, withcosts, and the matter is remitted to the Supreme Court, Westchester County, torecalculate, with all convenient speed, the defendant's child support obligation and childsupport arrears, in accordance herewith; and it is further,
Ordered that, in the interim, the defendant shall continue to pay child support in thesum of $1,879 per month.
The parties were married on August 21, 2004, and have one child. On September 1,2009, the plaintiff commenced this action for a divorce and ancillary relief. After thecommencement of the action, the defendant continued to live in the marital residencewith the plaintiff and the child. During that time, pursuant to a pendente lite orderentered January 14, 2010, the defendant was directed to pay all carrying charges for theresidence and 66% of child care costs and unreimbursed health care costs for the child.However, on June 8, 2010, the defendant was directed to leave the marital residence, andto pay child support in the sum of $1,500 per month, in addition to the carrying chargesfor the residence.
Prior to the trial, a neutral forensic accountant was appointed by the court to analyzethe defendant's income stream from five businesses and to determine the defendant'sincome for purposes of calculating the parties' respective child support obligations. In thereport of his findings, the forensic accountant concluded that the defendant's annualincome was $150,000, which the trial court later adjusted to $132,000 based on theaccountant's testimony that he double-counted certain income received by the defendant.The court then determined that the defendant's pro rata share of basic child support andstatutory add-ons was 54%, and that the defendant's monthly child support [*2]obligation was $1,879. The court further directed thehusband to pay child support arrears in the sum of $6,443, representing the differencebetween the child support obligation contained in the order dated June 8, 2010, and thechild support obligation determined after trial. The defendant appeals from thedeterminations of his child support obligation and child support arrears.
The defendant correctly contends that, in calculating child support arrears, the trialcourt erred in failing to credit him for the amount that he paid for the carrying costs ofthe marital residence pursuant to the order dated June 8, 2010 (see Lauria v Lauria, 45 AD3d535 [2007]; Graham v Graham, 277 AD2d 423, 424 [2000]; cf. Fredericks v Fredericks, 85AD3d 1107, 1109 [2011]; see also Harris v Harris, 97 AD3d 534, 536 [2012]), as wellas for the 12% of add-on expenses and forensic accountant's fees that he had overpaidpursuant to the order entered January 14, 2010, which had set his pro rata share ofexpenses at 66% (see generally Yecies v Yecies, 108 AD2d 813, 814 [1985]).Contrary to the plaintiff's contention, both of these matters were before the trial courtand, thus, are properly before this Court for appellate review.
In calculating the defendant's child support obligation, the trial court further erred infailing to account for child support "actually paid" by the defendant, pursuant to ajudgment of divorce, on behalf of his four children from a prior marriage (seeDomestic Relations Law § 240 [1-b] [b] [5] [vii] [D]). In that respect, thecourt incorrectly concluded that there was no evidence in the record that the defendanthad actually made such child support payments. To the contrary, the plaintiff's evidenceincluded the defendant's Citibank statements for the period from January 20, 2009,through November 17, 2009, which demonstrated that the defendant had paid certainsums of child support to the New York State Child Support Processing Center. Uponremittal, the payments documented in those Citibank statements for the period fromJanuary 20, 2009, through November 17, 2009, must be subtracted from the defendant'sincome, and the parties' respective child support obligations recalculated (seeDomestic Relations Law § 240 [1-b] [b] [5] [vii] [D]; cf. Baumgardner vBaumgardner, 98 AD3d 929, 931 [2012]).
There is no further basis, however, for disturbing the trial court's determination of thedefendant's annual income. " 'In determining a child support obligation, a courtneed not rely on a party's own account of his or her finances' " (Lago v Adrion, 93 AD3d697, 698 [2012], quoting Bell v Bell, 277 AD2d 411, 412 [2000]; see Wesche v Wesche, 77AD3d 921, 923 [2010]). Rather, "[w]here a party's account is not believable, thecourt may impute a true or potential income higher than alleged" (Wesche vWesche, 77 AD3d at 923; see Greisman v Greisman, 98 AD3d 1079, 1080 [2012]; Scammacca v Scammacca, 15AD3d 382 [2005]). Here, the court's imputation of income was supported by theforensic accountant's testimony and other evidence (see Turco v Turco, 117 AD3d 719, 720 [2014]; Lago vAdrion, 93 AD3d at 699).
The parties' remaining contentions are without merit. Skelos, J.P., Roman,Hinds-Radix and LaSalle, JJ., concur.