| Matter of J. Owens Bldg. Co., Inc. v Town ofClarkstown |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 04487 [128 AD3d 1067] |
| May 27, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of J. Owens Building Co., Inc., et al.,Petitioners, v Town of Clarkstown et al.,Respondents. |
Feerick Lynch MacCartney, PLLC, South Nyack, N.Y. (Dennis E. A. Lynch ofcounsel), for petitioners.
Amy Mele, Town Attorney, New City, N.Y. (Paul K. Schofield of counsel), forrespondents.
Proceeding pursuant to EDPL 207 to review a determination of the Town Board ofthe Town of Clarkstown dated April 8, 2014, made after a public hearing, authorizing thecondemnation of certain real property.
Adjudged that the petition is granted, on the law, with costs, the determination isrejected, and the matter is remitted to the Town Board of the Town of Clarkstown toconduct an appropriate environmental review pursuant to the State EnvironmentalQuality Review Act (ECL art 8) in accordance herewith.
The scope of judicial review in a proceeding pursuant to EDPL 207 "is limited towhether the proceeding was constitutional, whether the proposed acquisition is withinthe condemnor's statutory jurisdiction or authority, whether the determination andfindings were made in accordance with the procedures set forth in EDPL article 2 and theState Environmental Quality Review Act [(hereinafter SEQRA)], and whether a publicuse, benefit, or purpose will be served by the proposed acquisition" (Matter of Peekskill Hgts., Inc. vCity of Peekskill Common Council, 110 AD3d 1079, 1080 [2013]; seeEDPL 207 [C]; Matter of Waldo's, Inc. v Village of Johnson City, 74 NY2d 718,720 [1989]; Matter of Hargrovev New York City School Constr. Auth., 95 AD3d 1116, 1116 [2012]). Here, thepetitioners correctly contend that the determination of the Town Board of the Town ofClarkstown (hereinafter the Town Board) should be rejected on the ground that it failedto comply with SEQRA by improperly segmenting the SEQRA review process.
"Segmentation" is defined under SEQRA as "the division of the environmentalreview of an action such that various activities or stages are addressed under [SEQRA] asthough they were independent, unrelated activities, needing individual determinations ofsignificance" (6 NYCRR 617.2 [ag]; see 6 NYCRR 617.3 [g] [1]). "Consideringonly a part or segment of an action is contrary to the intent of" SEQRA (6 NYCRR 617.3[g] [1]).
The respondents sought to acquire the petitioners' property for the purpose of, amongother things, drainage and storm water management improvements (hereinafter thedrainage plan) in connection with a larger project known as the West Nyack DowntownRevitalization Project. The record reflects that the drainage plan "is a key component tothe overall revitalization plans for the [*2]Hamlet" ofWest Nyack. Even though the drainage plan was part of the larger revitalization project,the Town Board, acting as the lead agency, studied only the potential impact of thedrainage plan during its SEQRA review. However, under SEQRA, the Town Board wasobligated to consider the environmental concerns raised by the entire project (see6 NYCRR 617.3 [g] [1]; Matter of Long Is. Pine Barrens Socy. v Town Bd. of Townof Riverhead, 290 AD2d 448, 448-449 [2002]; Matter of Teich v Buchheit,221 AD2d 452, 453-454 [1995]). If, at this stage, the larger project is merely speculativeor hypothetical, then the Town's separate consideration of the drainage plan would notconstitute impermissible segmentation (see Matter of Village of Tarrytown vPlanning Bd. of Vil. of Sleepy Hollow, 292 AD2d 617, 620-621 [2002]). However,the respondents are not claiming that the larger project is speculative or hypothetical.Moreover, to the extent that the Town Board concluded that segmenting theenvironmental review of the drainage plan from that of the larger revitalization projectwas warranted under the circumstances presented here, it was required under the SEQRAregulations to "clearly state in its determination of significance . . . thesupporting reasons[,]" "demonstrate that such review is clearly no less protective of theenvironment[,]" and to identify and discuss "[r]elated actions . . . to thefullest extent possible" (6 NYCRR 617.3 [g] [1]). The Town Board failed to do so. Sincethe Town Board failed to properly comply with SEQRA, the determination and findingsmust be rejected, and the matter remitted to the Town Board to undertake an appropriatereview (see Matter of Riverso vRockland County Solid Waste Mgt. Auth., 96 AD3d 764, 766 [2012]) thateither considers the entire revitalization project as a whole or makes findings required by6 NYCRR 617.3 (g) (1) that are supported by applicable facts.
In light of our conclusion herein, we do not reach the parties' remaining contentions.Eng, P.J., Leventhal, Hall and Roman, JJ., concur.