| Matter of Residents for Reasonable Dev. v City of NewYork |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 04560 [128 AD3d 609] |
| May 28, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, First Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Residents for Reasonable Developmentet al., Appellants, v City of New York et al.,Respondents. |
Albert K. Butzel Law Offices, New York (Albert K. Butzel of counsel), forappellants.
Zachary W. Carter, Corporation Counsel, New York (Jane L. Gordon of counsel), formunicipal respondents.
Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP, New York (Maria T. Vullo ofcounsel), for Memorial Hospital for Cancer and Allied Diseases, The City University ofNew York and City University Construction Fund, respondents.
Order and judgment (one paper), Supreme Court, New York County (Alexander W.Hunter, Jr., J.), entered July 30, 2014, denying the petition to annul the city respondents'determination, dated December 18, 2013, which approved the proposed East 74th Streetproject for Memorial Hospital for Cancer and Allied Diseases (the clinical arm ofMemorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center and hereinafter MSK) and the City Universityof New York (CUNY) (collectively, MSK-CUNY), and dismissing the proceedingbrought pursuant to CPLR article 78, unanimously affirmed, without costs.
Upon our review of the record, we find that the city respondents took the requisite"hard look" at the relevant areas of environmental concern, in particular the project'santicipated adverse environmental impacts, and provided a "reasoned elaboration" of thebasis for their approval of the project. Their determination is not arbitrary and capriciousand is supported by the evidence (see Matter of Riverkeeper, Inc. v Planning Bd. of Town ofSoutheast, 9 NY3d 219, 231-232 [2007]; Akpan v Koch, 75 NY2d 561,570 [1990]).
Contrary to petitioners' contention, the Final Environmental Impact Statement (FEIS)was not required to consider the potential environmental impacts of the plannedconstruction of a garage 50 blocks from the main project site and the FEIS detailed thefactors considered commensurate with the circumstances and nature of the proposal.While the project and the garage exist by virtue of the same request for proposals andcontract, they are two separate, independent projects that share no common purpose andare not part of a larger plan of development. Thus, the ongoing separate environmentalreview of the garage is proper (compare Matter of Friends of Stanford Home v Town ofNiskayuna, 50 AD3d 1289 [3d Dept 2008], lv denied 10 NY3d 716[2008], with Matter of Village of Westbury v Department of Transp. of State ofN.Y., 75 NY2d 62, 69 [1989]).
Although City Environmental Quality Review [CEQR], as authorized by and inimplementation of the State Environmental Quality Review Act (ECL art 8 [SEQRA])requires that each FEIS include an analysis of a "No Action" alternative as though theproject were not being constructed and existing conditions on the project would remainunchanged, the FEIS was not required to consider petitioners' preferred alternativescenario of residential development at the project site, because that scenario would nothave met the objectives and capabilities of MSK-CUNY, the project sponsor (seeDepartment of Environmental Conservation Regulations [6 NYCRR]§ 617.9 [b] [5] [v]; see also Matter of C/S 12th Ave. LLC v City of New York, 32AD3d 1, 5 [1st Dept 2006] ["Not every conceivable environmental impact,mitigating measure or alternative must be addressed"]).
[*2] The determination granting the zoning map and textamendments as well as the special permit applications is supported by substantialevidence sufficient to evince its rationality (see Kettaneh v Board of Stds. & Appeals of the City ofN.Y., 85 AD3d 620, 621 [1st Dept 2011], lv dismissed in part, denied inpart 18 NY3d 919 [2012]). Contrary to petitioners' contention, the zoning mapamendment does not constitute illegal spot zoning merely because it involves a singleparcel only and is not ad hoc zoning legislation affecting the land of a few withoutproper regard to the needs or design of the community as a whole (see Matter ofTown of Bedford v Village of Mount Kisco, 33 NY2d 178, 187-188 [1973]). Therecord establishes that the zoning change is part of "a well considered andcomprehensive plan to serve the general welfare of the community" (see Collard vIncorporated Vil. of Flower Hill, 52 NY2d 594, 600 [1981]).
The City's use of incentive zoning is well within its broad authority and is proper(see Asian Ams. for Equality v Koch, 72 NY2d 121, 129 [1988]). Nor is thepayment for nearby parkland an illegal "quid pro quo" for specific floor area ratio; thefunds are being paid directly to the Department of Parks so that it can perform theimprovements (compare Matter of Municipal Art Socy. of N.Y. v City of NewYork, 137 Misc 2d 832 [Sup Ct, NY County 1987] [improper quid pro quo foundwhere funds were to be paid into City's general operating account]).
The Manhattan Borough Board's approval of the project is properly the result of avote by a majority of the board members present and entitled to vote (see NYCity Charter §§ 85 [c], [d]; 384 [b] [4]). While all 12 board memberswere present, one member recused herself; six (of 11) votes (in favor) constitutes amajority. There is no basis in the record for finding the recusal improper or for deemingthat the member abstained, rather than recused herself, from voting.Concur—Tom, J.P., Sweeny, Andrias, Moskowitz and Gische, JJ. [Prior CaseHistory: 44 Misc 3d 1217(A), 2014 NY Slip Op 51171(U).]