| Matter of Bottom v Fischer |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 05319 [129 AD3d 1604] |
| June 19, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Anthony Bottom, Also Known as JalilMuntaqim, Appellant, v Brian Fischer, Commissioner, New York State Department ofCorrections and Community Supervision, Respondent. |
Michael Kuzma, Buffalo, for petitioner-appellant.
Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Allyson B. Levine of counsel), forrespondent-respondent.
Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court, Wyoming County (Mark H. Dadd,A.J.), entered December 26, 2013 in a CPLR article 78 proceeding. The judgment,insofar as appealed from, denied the petition in part.
It is hereby ordered that said appeal from the judgment insofar as it exempts fromdisclosure the May 16, 2012 letter is unanimously dismissed as moot, and the judgment ismodified on the law by granting that part of the petition seeking reasonable attorney'sfees and other litigation costs reasonably incurred by petitioner, and as modified thejudgment is affirmed with costs, and the matter is remitted to Supreme Court, WyomingCounty, to determine the amount of such attorney's fees and litigation costs.
Memorandum: Petitioner commenced this proceeding seeking, inter alia, an orderdirecting respondent to comply with his request for documents under the Freedom ofInformation Law ([FOIL] Public Officers Law art 6). Respondent denied petitioner'srequest and thereafter denied his administrative appeal in its entirety on the ground thatthe documents sought were exempt from disclosure pursuant to Public Officers Law§ 87 (2) (a), (f) and (g). In a prior order, Supreme Court directed respondent"to provide petitioner's counsel with affidavits or other proof supporting the applicationof the specific exemptions for the information which was withheld." Respondent thendisclosed the majority of the records requested. The court thereafter granted the petitionto the extent that, with the exception of the May 16, 2012 letter to the Division of Parolefrom the New York County District Attorney's Office, respondent was directed toprovide access for inspection and copying redacted copies of those documents responsiveto the FOIL request that had not previously been disclosed to petitioner's counsel.
At the outset, we note that, inasmuch as petitioner has received a copy of the May 16,2012 letter, his appeal from that part of the judgment exempting that letter fromdisclosure has been rendered moot (see Matter of Usatynski v Daines, 86 AD3d 914, 914-915[2011]). Contrary to petitioner's contention, we conclude that respondent was entitled toredact from certain documents the names of organizations that "if disclosed couldendanger the life or safety of any person" belonging to such organizations (PublicOfficers Law § 87 [2] [f]; see Matter of Bellamy v New York City Police Dept., 87 AD3d874, 875 [2011], affd 20 NY3d 1028 [2013], rearg denied 21 NY3d974 [2013]).
We agree with petitioner, however, that the court abused its discretion in denying,without explanation, that part of his petition seeking an award of reasonable attorney'sfees and other litigation costs reasonably incurred in this proceeding. Petitioner satisfiedthe prerequisites for such an award pursuant to Public Officers Law § 89 (4)(c). Inasmuch as respondent ultimately provided all but one of the documents in theFOIL request, petitioner "substantially prevailed" within the meaning of the statute(§ 89 [4] [c]; seeMatter of New York State [*2]Defenders Assn. v NewYork State Police, 87 AD3d 193, 195-196 [2011]; Matter of New York Civ. LibertiesUnion v City of Saratoga Springs, 87 AD3d 336, 338 [2011]). Further,respondent had no reasonable basis for its blanket denial of petitioner's request(see Public Officers Law § 89 [4] [c] [i]). Indeed, respondent'scontention that it had a reasonable basis for denying access to all of the requesteddocuments is belied by its release of the majority of those documents when the courtdirected it to justify their nondisclosure (see New York State Defenders Assn., 87AD3d at 197). We conclude, therefore, that petitioner "has been subjected to the verykinds of 'unreasonable delays and denials of access' which the counsel fee provisionseeks to deter" (Matter of LegalAid Socy. v New York State Dept. of Corr. & Community Supervision, 105AD3d 1120, 1122 [2013]). Thus, we modify the judgment by granting that part ofthe petition seeking an award of reasonable attorney's fees and other litigation costsreasonably incurred by petitioner, and we remit the matter to Supreme Court to determinethe amount thereof. Present—Scudder, P.J., Smith, Sconiers, Whalen andDeJoseph, JJ.