| Matter of Empara v New Rochelle Sch. Dist. |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 05743 [130 AD3d 1127] |
| July 2, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Scott Empara, Appellant, v NewRochelle School District et al., Respondents. Workers' Compensation Board,Respondent. |
Annette G. Hasapidis, South Salem, for appellant.
Cherry, Edson & Kelly, LLP, Tarrytown (Ralph E. Magnetti of counsel), forNew Rochelle School District and another, respondents.
Egan Jr., J. Appeals (1) from a decision of a panel of the Workers' CompensationBoard, filed August 21, 2013, which ruled that claimant was not entitled to an increase inthe schedule loss of use, and (2) from a decision of the full Board, filed October 30,2014, which adhered to the Board panel's decision.
Claimant, an electrician, sustained a compensable work-related injury in 2003 and,based upon the medical evidence presented, the parties stipulated to a 37.5% scheduleloss of use of claimant's left leg. Claimant sustained another injury in 2009 that resultedin arthroscopic surgery on his left knee and, based upon the opinion of his orthopedicsurgeon that claimant had reached maximum medical improvement and suffered apermanent impairment of 40% to his left leg, claimant sought additional workers'compensation benefits. By decision dated November 27, 2012, a Workers' CompensationJudge (hereinafter WCLJ) determined, without explanation or any indication as towhether the prior schedule loss of use was considered, that claimant sustained a 20% lossof use of his left leg that was causally related to the 2009 accident. The matter wascontinued for, among other things, consideration of an award of compensation. Bydecision dated January 22, 2013, the WCLJ awarded benefits based upon the 20% loss ofuse of claimant's left leg; the employer objected to the award in that it did not considerthe previous 37.5% schedule loss of use in connection with the 2003 accident.
Thereafter, the employer appealed the January 22, 2013 WCLJ decision, challengingthe schedule loss of use award. Claimant opposed, claiming that the appeal was untimelygiven that the November 27, 2012 decision—not the January 22, 2013decision—was final with regard to the issue of claimant's schedule loss of use forthe 2009 accident. Ultimately, the Workers' Compensation Board, upon full Boardreview, rejected claimant's challenge to the timeliness of the appeal and reversed theWCLJ's decision, finding that claimant was not entitled to any award for the 2009 injuryinasmuch as there was no increased schedule loss of use of the left leg greater than thatpreviously awarded in 2003. These appeals by claimant ensued.[FN*]
We are unpersuaded by claimant's contention that the Board erred in finding theemployer's appeal to be timely. Although the WCLJ's November 27, 2012 decision foundthat claimant had sustained a schedule loss of use in connection with the 2009 injury, theWCLJ did so without explanation or any indication as to whether the prior award of37.5% schedule loss of use was to be considered in calculating a compensation award.As noted by the Board, it was unclear from the November 27, 2012 decision whether anyaward would be made to claimant in light of the issue of the prior schedule loss of useaward. Under the particular circumstances of this case, and given the ambiguity in theWCLJ's November 27, 2012 decision regarding the applicability of the prior scheduleloss of use and whether apportionment would be applied to the ultimate award inconnection with the current claim, we cannot say that the Board's decision to grant theemployer's application for review was arbitrary and capricious or an abuse of discretion(see generally Matter of YouCai Zhang v Tony's Marble & Granite Supply Corp., 95 AD3d 1510, 1511[2012]; Matter of Hiser vRichmor Aviation, Inc., 52 AD3d 915, 916 [2008]).
Turning to the merits, "[w]hether a condition warrants a schedule loss award or anaward of continuing disability benefits is a question of fact for resolution by the Board,and its determination will be upheld if supported by substantial evidence" (Matter of Kondylis v AlatisInteriors Co., Ltd., 116 AD3d 1184, 1185 [2014] [internal quotation marks andcitations omitted]). As noted by the Board, a schedule award is not given for an injury,but for the residual physical and functional impairments (see State of New YorkWorkers' Compensation Board Medical Guidelines at 4 [June 1996]). Here, theindependent medical examiner testified that, although the guidelines provide for a 10%schedule loss of use, his examination of claimant revealed no atrophy, no instability andno loss of motion. "[W]hile the guidelines present useful criteria, the ultimatedetermination as to the degree of disability rests with the Board" (Matter of Carlucci v OmnibusPrint. Co., Inc., 68 AD3d 1259, 1260 [2009]). Given the foregoing medicaltestimony, substantial evidence supports the Board's finding that there was no new andgreater increase in the schedule loss of use of the left leg related to the 2009 accident.Claimant's remaining contentions, to the extent not specifically discussed herein, havebeen reviewed and found to be without merit.
McCarthy, J.P., Lynch and Devine, JJ., concur. Ordered that the appeal from theAugust 21, 2013 decision is dismissed, without [*2]costs.Ordered that the October 30, 2014 decision is affirmed, without costs.
Footnote *:The Board panel'sAugust 21, 2013 decision was superceded by the decision of the full Board, andclaimant's appeal from the Board panel decision must be dismissed (see Matter of Winters v AdvanceAuto Parts, 119 AD3d 1041, 1043 n [2014]).