| Matter of Mertz v Bradshaw |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 06639 [131 AD3d 794] |
| August 20, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of John Mertz, Appellant, v JamesBradshaw, Respondent, et al., Respondents. |
Roemer, Wallens, Gold & Mineaux, LLP, Albany (Michael R. Cuevas ofcounsel), for appellant.
M. Joe Landry, Schenectady, for James Bradshaw, respondent.
Per Curiam. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Versaci, J.), enteredAugust 5, 2015 in Schenectady County, which dismissed petitioner's application, in aproceeding pursuant to Election Law § 16-102, to declare invalid thedesignating petitions naming respondent James Bradshaw as the Republican Party,Independence Party and Green Party candidate for the public office of Town Justice ofthe Town of Rotterdam in the September 10, 2015 primary election.
Respondent James Bradshaw filed designating petitions with the SchenectadyCounty Board of Elections seeking to be nominated as the Republican Party,Independence Party and Green Party candidate for the public office of Town Justice ofthe Town of Rotterdam in the September 10, 2015 primary election. Petitionercommenced this proceeding pursuant to Election Law § 16-102 to declareinvalid, as is relevant to this appeal, those sheets of the designating petitions signed byDenise Bradshaw as commissioner of deeds, alleging that she failed to administer an oathto or obtain a statement of truth from the signers of said petitions whose signature shewitnessed, contrary to her verification on those sheets. Following a two-day hearing,Supreme Court dismissed petitioner's application, and this appeal ensued.
The Election Law provides a much simpler process for a local party member toobtain petition support for a potential candidate than for an individual of either anotherpolitical party or from outside the relevant political subdivision. A local party membermay obtain petition signatures and affirm with a simple statement that the signatories"subscribed the same in my [*2]presence on the datesabove indicated and identified himself or herself to be the individual who signed thissheet" (Election Law § 6-132 [2]). Where the petition is obtained by anindividual other than a statutorily authorized local party member, however, the petitionmay be approved by a notary public or commissioner of deeds, but it is further requiredthat each individual signatory be "duly sworn" (Election Law § 6-132[3]).[FN1]
Here, Denise Bradshaw was gathering signatures on multiple party lines, and at issueare three lines in which she was not a duly registered party member. At the hearing, inaddition to testimony from signatories that no oath or affirmation as to the truth of theirstatements was elicited prior to signing the petitions, Denise Bradshaw herself clearlyacknowledged in her testimony that she had neither administered an oath to any signatoryon the challenged petitions, nor had she asked any of them to swear or affirm to tell thetruth before signing. This is contrary to her attestation as a commissioner of deeds, whichappears on the face of each sheet of the challenged designating petitions, as requiredpursuant to Election Law § 6-132 (3). As respondent argues, case law hasestablished that not all of the formalities of an oath need be observed (see Matter of Bonner vNegron, 87 AD3d 737, 738 [2011]; Matter of Nolin v McNally, 87 AD3d 804, 806 [2011]).Nonetheless, we are constrained to find that the evidence did not support a finding ofsubstantial compliance with the statutory requirements. Accordingly, the signaturescollected by Denise Bradshaw are rendered invalid (see Matter of Caruso vCasciola, 27 NY2d 657, 657 [1970]; Matter of Hall v Dussault, 109 AD3d 679, 680 [2013];Matter of Bonner v Negron, 87 AD3d at 738; Matter of Nolin v McNally,87 AD3d at 806; Matter of Imrev Johnson, 54 AD3d 427, 428 [2008]). Consequently, the designating petitionsfor both the Republican Party and Independence Party do not contain a sufficient numberof valid signatures and those designating petitions are invalid.[FN2]
Lahtinen, J.P., McCarthy, Garry and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that the order ismodified, on the law, without costs, by reversing so much thereof as dismissedpetitioner's application to declare invalid the designating petitions naming respondentJames Bradshaw as the Republican Party and Independence Party candidate for the [*3]public office of Town Justice of the Town of Rotterdam inthe September 10, 2015 primary election; application granted to said extent and saiddesignating petitions declared invalid; and, as so modified, affirmed.
Footnote 1:As Supreme Courtfound, this renders the petitioning process more cumbersome in the "real life situation" ofcarrying petitions door to door. Notably, however, this provision serves to "expand[ ]access to the ballot, while safeguarding the integrity of the election process" (Matter of LeBron v Clyne, 65AD3d 801, 803 [2009]).
Footnote 2:Although certain GreenParty signatures are similarly invalidated, a sufficient number remain to allow JamesBradshaw to appear on that party primary ballot. Further, we fully agree with SupremeCourt that petitioner failed to establish by clear and convincing evidence that there wasany fraudulent procurement of the signatures so as to warrant invalidating said GreenParty designating petition in its entirety (see Matter of Vincent v Sira, 131 AD3d 787 [2015] [decided herewith]; Matter of Nolin v McNally, 87 AD3d 804, 806 [2011]).