| Matter of Budd v State Univ. of N.Y. at Geneseo |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 08565 [133 AD3d 1341] |
| November 20, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of James E. Budd, Petitioner, v StateUniversity of New York at Geneseo, Respondent. |
Law Office of Peter K. Skivington PLLC, Geneseo (Daniel R. Magill of counsel),for petitioner.
Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Brian D. Ginsberg of counsel), forrespondent.
Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to the Appellate Division of theSupreme Court in the Fourth Judicial Department by an order of the Supreme Court,Livingston County [Robert B. Wiggins, A.J.], entered Apr. 17, 2015) to review adetermination of respondent. The determination, among other things, expelled petitioneras a student at the State University of New York at Geneseo.
It is hereby ordered that the determination is unanimously confirmed withoutcosts.
Memorandum: Petitioner commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding, transferred tothis Court pursuant to CPLR 7804 (g), seeking to annul the determination of respondentto expel him as an undergraduate student. Petitioner on four prior occasions had beensubject to discipline, including a year-long suspension, for violating respondent's StudentCode of Conduct (Code). He was subsequently expelled after respondent determined thathe violated two sections of the Code, one proscribing physical assaults and a secondprohibiting deliberate incitement of others to engage in Code-violating conduct. At thehearing on those charges, respondent relied in pertinent part on a police report andsupporting depositions describing how petitioner tackled a man to the ground, pursuedthe man to a nearby apartment with other students, and punched the man in the face.
Our review of respondent's determination "is limited to determining whether theuniversity substantially adhered to its own published rules and guidelines for disciplinaryproceedings so as to ascertain whether its actions were arbitrary or capricious"(Matter of Rensselaer Socy. of Engrs. v Rensselaer Polytechnic Inst., 260 AD2d992, 993 [1999]). A public university such as respondent must "provide its students withthe full panoply of due process guarantees . . . [,] [which] requires that[students] be given the names of the witnesses against them, the opportunity to present adefense, and the results and finding of the hearing" (Matter of Nawaz v State Univ. ofN.Y. Univ. at Buffalo School of Dental Medicine, 295 AD2d 944, 944 [2002][internal quotation marks omitted]).
Here, the record demonstrates that respondent "substantially adhered to its grievanceprocedures and that its determination is neither arbitrary nor capricious" (Matter of Krysty v State Univ. ofN.Y. at Buffalo, 39 AD3d 1220, 1220 [2007]), and that petitioner was providedwith the "full panoply of due process guarantees" to which he was entitled(Nawaz, 295 AD2d at 944). We reject petitioner's contention that respondent'sfailure to provide him certain documents through prehearing discovery denied him dueprocess. It is clear from the record that petitioner possessed the relevant documents, andtherefore he was not prejudiced by any failure on the part of respondent to provide thosedocuments to him (see generallyMatter of Kaur v New York State Urban Dev. Corp., 15 NY3d 235, 259-261[2010]). Contrary to petitioner's further contention, he was not deprived of due processby any improper combination of roles of the hearing chairperson (see [*2]Matter of Amos v Board of Educ. of Cheektowaga-SloanUnion Free School Dist., 54 AD2d 297, 304 [1976], affd 43 NY2d 706[1977]).
We reject petitioner's contention that respondent's written determination denied himdue process by failing to set forth detailed factual findings with respect to his violation ofthe Code's "deliberate incitement" provision. "In a disciplinary proceeding at a publicinstitution of higher education, due process entitles a student accused of misconduct to astatement detailing the factual findings and the evidence relied upon by thedecision-maker in reaching the determination of guilt" sufficient "to permit the student toeffectively challenge the determination in administrative appeals and in the courts and toensure that the decision was based on evidence in the record" (Matter of Boyd v State Univ. ofN.Y. at Cortland, 110 AD3d 1174, 1175 [2013] [internal quotation marksomitted]). In our view, respondent's determination, which described the evidence onwhich respondent relied and described petitioner's deliberate incitement of other studentsto join his pursuit and engage in an altercation, satisfies that standard.
Petitioner contends that he was denied due process during his administrative appealbecause the determination of that appeal improperly relied on documents concerning his"past conduct record" that were not part of the administrative record. Petitioner alsocontends that those documents should be stricken from the record. We reject bothcontentions. The Code directs that "an appeal shall be limited to review of the verbatimrecord of the initial review . . . and supporting documents"(emphasis added) and, because the Code also directs that "[a] student's past conductrecord shall be considered in the determination of appropriate sanctions," we concludethat the challenged documents are the type of "supporting documents" that were properlyreviewed as part of petitioner's administrative appeal.
Finally, we reject petitioner's further contention that he was denied due processbecause his disciplinary hearing consisted solely of hearsay evidence and he was deniedthe opportunity to confront live witnesses. "[T]he rights at stake in a school disciplinaryhearing may be fairly determined upon the 'hearsay' evidence of school administratorscharged with the duty of investigating the incidents" (Boykins v Fairfield Bd. ofEd., 492 F2d 697, 701 [1974], cert denied 420 US 962 [1975]), and "[t]helack of confrontation [does] not violate the [Code], which provide[s] for a nonadversarialfact-finding hearing 'without being unnecessarily formal or legalistic' " (Matter of Ebert v YeshivaUniv., 28 AD3d 315, 316 [2006]). Present—Centra, J.P., Peradotto,Lindley, Valentino and Whalen, JJ.