Hill v Country Club Acres, Inc.
2015 NY Slip Op 09152 [134 AD3d 1267]
December 10, 2015
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, February 11, 2015


[*1]
 George Hill, Appellant, v Country Club Acres, Inc.,Respondent.

Buckley, Mendleson, Criscione & Quinn, PC., Albany (John J. Criscione ofcounsel), for appellant.

Office of Theresa J. Puleo, Syracuse (Norah M. Murphy of counsel), forrespondent.

Garry, J. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Nolan Jr., J.), enteredSeptember 30, 2014 in Saratoga County, which, among other things, granted defendant'smotion for summary judgment dismissing the complaint.

Plaintiff is the sole member of 43 Round Lake, LLC (hereinafter Round Lake),which he formed in July 2010 to purchase and operate a restaurant business located in astrip mall owned by defendant. When Round Lake bought the business, it also purchasedthe restaurant's equipment, including, as relevant here, ceiling fans. At the time of thepurchase, the parties were aware that defendant planned to demolish and redevelop partof the strip mall, which would require the restaurant to vacate the mall. Plaintiff thereforeentered into a month-to-month lease on Round Lake's behalf, giving defendant the rightto terminate the tenancy upon obtaining approval for the project. In April 2011,defendant served the anticipated notice to vacate. In May 2011, plaintiff was injured in afall from a ladder that occurred while he was engaged in removing a fan from therestaurant ceiling.

Plaintiff commenced this action seeking damages pursuant to Labor Law§§ 200, 240 and 241 (6). Following discovery, defendant moved forsummary judgment dismissing the complaint. Plaintiff opposed the motion andcross-moved for partial summary judgment on the Labor Law § 240 causeof action. Supreme Court granted defendant's motion, denied the cross motion, anddismissed the complaint. Plaintiff appeals.

The Legislature's primary purpose in enacting Labor Law §§ 200,240 and 241 "was to [*2]provide for the health and safetyof employees" (Mordkofsky v V.C.V. Dev. Corp., 76 NY2d 573, 577 [1990]). Assuch, these enactments "extend special protections to employees or workers who arehired by someone—either an owner, contractor or an agent—toperform work on a building or structure" (Fallon v Flach Dev. & Realty, Inc., 71 AD3d 1258,1259 [2010] [internal quotation marks and citation omitted]; see Stringer v Musacchia, 11NY3d 212, 215 [2008]). Thus, a plaintiff who seeks to recover under the Labor Lawmust show that he or she " 'was both permitted or suffered to work on a buildingor structure and was hired by someone' " to do so (Lee v Jones,230 AD2d 435, 436 [1997] [ellipsis omitted], lv denied 91 NY2d 802 [1997],quoting Whelen v Warwick Val. Civic & Social Club, 47 NY2d 970, 971[1979]; accord Benamati vMcSkimming, 8 AD3d 815, 816 [2004]; see Labor Law § 2[5], [7]). We agree with Supreme Court that defendant established as a matter of law thatplaintiff was not hired by anyone and was not acting as an employee of defendant orRound Lake when he removed the ceiling fan and, thus, was not entitled to the protectionof Labor Law §§ 200, 240 and 241.

In support of its motion for summary judgment, defendant's representatives averredthat defendant did not hire or direct plaintiff to remove the fan, testifying that defendantallowed, but did not require, tenants to remove their property before the demolition, andthat "[i]t didn't matter" to defendant whether the property was removed or left in place.Defendant also submitted plaintiff's deposition testimony, in which he testified that hedecided on his own to remove the ceiling fan, and that defendant did not pay,compensate or direct him to do so. To demonstrate that plaintiff did not have anemployment relationship with Round Lake, defendant submitted the parties' leaseagreement, which plaintiff executed as "Member" and "Guarantor" rather than as anofficer or employee of the company. Defendant further submitted deposition testimony inwhich plaintiff identified himself as the owner of Round Lake and other individuals asemployees. He further testified that he did not receive paychecks from Round Lake, butinstead drew varying amounts from the company's revenues depending upon its incomeand his obligations. This evidence met defendant's prima facie burden of establishing thatneither defendant nor Round Lake hired or employed plaintiff to remove the fan (seeFallon v Flach Dev. & Realty, Inc., 71 AD3d at 1259).

In response, plaintiff submitted an affidavit stating that he was "employed by [RoundLake]." This claim was inconsistent with his prior deposition testimony that he was thecompany's owner rather than its employee, and "a party cannot create an issue of fact bysubmitting a self-serving affidavit that contradicts prior sworn testimony" (Benamativ McSkimming, 8 AD3d at 817 [internal quotation marks and citation omitted]; see Ginty v American Funds Serv.Co., 121 AD3d 1452, 1453 [2014]). His counsel's affirmation that plaintiff wasemployed by Round Lake was not premised on personal knowledge and has no probativevalue (see 2 N. St. Corp. v GettySaugerties Corp., 68 AD3d 1392, 1395 [2009], lv denied 14 NY3d 706[2010]; Bronson v Algonquin Lodge Assn., 295 AD2d 681, 682 [2002]).

Plaintiff further argues that the lease between defendant and Round Lake would haveprovided an adequate nexus to impose strict liability on defendant for an injury to anemployee of Round Lake (seee.g. Sanatass v Consolidated Inv. Co., Inc., 10 NY3d 333, 341-342 [2008]) andthat, as he was performing work that would otherwise have been done by an employee,he should be entitled to the same level of protection. We reject this claim. Assumingwithout deciding that an employee would be entitled to statutory protection in thesecircumstances, the roles are not equivalent. As Round Lake's owner, plaintiff wasbenefitting himself in removing the fan, both by retrieving his company's property and byperforming work that the company otherwise would have had to pay a laborer toperform. His performance of the task "[did] not give rise to mutual duties or obligationsbetween [himself and Round Lake] and [bore] none of the traditional hallmarks of anemployment relationship" (Stringer v Musacchia, 11 NY3d at 216-217). [*3]Accordingly, Supreme Court properly determined that hedid not fall within the class of workers protected by the Labor Law (see Mordkofskyv V.C.V. Dev. Corp., 76 NY2d at 577; Whelen v Warwick Val. Civic &Social Club, 47 NY2d at 971; Fallon v Flach Dev. & Realty, Inc., 71AD3d at 1259).

Lahtinen, J.P., Egan Jr. and Clark, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order is affirmed,with costs.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.