| Matter of Lambraia v State Univ. of N.Y. atBinghamton |
| 2016 NY Slip Op 00246 [135 AD3d 1144] |
| January 14, 2016 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Daniel Lambraia, Petitioner, v StateUniversity of New York at Binghamton et al., Respondents. |
Aswad & Ingraham, Binghamton (James F. Moran of counsel), forpetitioner.
Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Jonathan D. Hitsous of counsel),for respondents.
Lynch, J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (transferred to this Court by orderof the Supreme Court, entered in Broome County) to review a determination ofrespondent Vice President for Student Affairs at respondent State University of NewYork at Binghamton finding that petitioner violated the Code of Student Conduct andimposing a two-year suspension.
In October 2013, petitioner, a student at respondent State University of New York atBinghamton (hereinafter SUNY) attended a house party hosted by students at CornellUniversity. While at the party, he met another guest who was a student at Cornell(hereinafter the victim). After a brief conversation, the two went to a bedroom on thesecond floor of the house and engaged in certain sexual conduct. After leaving the room,petitioner went to stay overnight at another Cornell student's house and the victimreturned to her dormitory on campus. Just prior to leaving the party, the victim told oneof her friends that "something bad" had happened; she later told her friends thatpetitioner had raped her in the upstairs bedroom. The victim's friends convinced her toreport the incident to the local police. The local police questioned the victim, who agreedto provide her clothing for DNA testing, but declined to go to the hospital to undergo arape examination. The next day, the victim sought counseling from Cornell's healthcenter. She later withdrew from school and sought treatment for depression andpost-traumatic stress disorder. The Tompkins County District Attorney did not presscharges [*2]against petitioner.
In August 2014, the victim notified SUNY that petitioner had sexually assaulted herin October 2013 and requested that he be subject to discipline pursuant to SUNY's Codeof Student Conduct (hereinafter the Code). After conducting an investigation, SUNYnotified petitioner that it was going to conduct a hearing to review the charge that he hadviolated the Code rule prohibiting "[s]exual assault, rape, and any form of sexualviolence." After hearing from petitioner, the victim and witnesses, SUNY's StudentConduct Board found that petitioner violated the rule and suspended him for two years.After an administrative appeal, respondent Vice President for Student Affairs at SUNYupheld the decision. This CPLR article 78 petition ensued.[FN*]
To impose discipline in a sexual violence case, the Conduct Board must find thestudent responsible by a preponderance of the evidence. Here, petitioner testified beforethe Conduct Board that both he and the victim understood that they were going upstairsto engage in sexual activity, that the victim was willing to go and that he askedpermission before putting on a condom and engaging in sexual intercourse. The victimtestified that she went upstairs with petitioner after making it clear that she would notengage in sexual activity, that he pushed her into a bedroom, kissed her, pushed her tothe floor and forced her to engage in certain sexual activity. She explained that sheinitially tried to push petitioner away and yell, but that she submitted after he put hishands around her neck. Petitioner's witnesses testified that while none of them saw thetwo enter the room, they observed the victim later in the evening, after they were awareof the incident, and that she did not appear to be distressed. In contrast, one of thevictim's witnesses testified that she approached him at the party and was "visibly upset,"and another witness testified that the victim grabbed his arm to tell him that she had been"attacked." Other witnesses testified that later, at the dormitory, the victim was distraughtand crying as she told them what had happened; she suffered adverse changes in herdemeanor in the days following the incident. The victim explained that she did notundergo a rape examination because a police officer advised that she would have to bearthe cost of the test and she did not want to involve her parents.
In our view, SUNY's determination that petitioner violated the rule prohibitingsexual assault was supported by substantial evidence. As noted by the Conduct Board,the victim promptly reported the incident and, as verified by SUNY staff and her treatingpsychologist, she had to leave school and was subsequently diagnosed with posttraumaticstress disorder. Although petitioner argues that his witnesses described the incident andthe victim's demeanor differently, and that the Conduct Board considered some, but notall of the evidence presented and did not credit all of the victim's testimony, we will notdisturb a finding based on a "credibility issue[ ] . . . within the sole provinceof [the Conduct Board] to determine" (Matter of Lampert v State Univ. of N.Y. at Albany, 116 AD3d1292, 1294 [2014], lv denied 23 NY3d 908 [2014]).
[*3] We also reject petitioner's claim that he was denieddue process. Generally, "[d]ue process requires that the petitioners be given the names ofthe witnesses against them, the opportunity to present a defense, and the results andfinding of the hearing" (Matter of Gruen v Chase, 215 AD2d 481, 481 [1995]; see Matter of Boyd v State Univ. ofN.Y. at Cortland, 110 AD3d 1174, 1175 [2013]). Here, petitioner argues,correctly, that due process "entitles a student accused of misconduct to 'a statementdetailing the factual findings and the evidence relied upon by the decision-maker inreaching the determination of guilt' " (Matter of Boyd v State Univ. of N.Y.at Cortland, 110 AD3d at 1175, quoting Matter of Kalinsky v State Univ. of N.Y.at Binghamton, 161 AD2d 1006, 1007 [1990]). In our view, although SUNY did notrelease certain internal documents until after it issued a determination on theadministrative appeal, the Conduct Board sufficiently detailed its factual findings, thetestimony and the evidence that it relied upon in its determination (see Matter of Schwarzmueller vState Univ. of N.Y. at Potsdam, 105 AD3d 1117, 1119 [2013]). Next, inasmuchas the Code requires either the video and/or audio recording of disciplinary hearings, andin the October 31, 2014 decision letter the Conduct Board offered petitioner theopportunity to listen to the audio recording of the hearing, we find that SUNY properlycomplied with its own rules when it refused to allow petitioner to obtain his owntranscript of the hearing. Similarly, as the Code provides that the formal rules of evidencedo not apply and gives the chairperson of the Conduct Board the discretion to determinewhat evidence is relevant, we discern no error in the determination limiting petitioner'squestions to SUNY's investigator as to why the District Attorney declined to prosecutepetitioner.
Lahtinen, J.P., McCarthy, Egan Jr. and Devine, JJ., concur. Adjudged that thedetermination is confirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.
Footnote *:We take note that byorder dated January 14, 2015, Supreme Court (Tait, J.) issued a stay of the suspensionpending a determination in the proceeding and continued the stay in a separate orderdated January 30, 2015 transferring the proceeding to this Court. Petitioner reports in hisbrief, dated June 29, 2015, that he has completed his final semester at SUNY.